Friday, January 31, 2014

A Cheeky Christian (Updated)

Anti-Zionist clergyman Stephen Sizer (Christ Church, Christchurch Road, Virginia Water, Surrey) has posted a sermon.


Chutzpah, I think, would be parallel to the charge of cheeky, as the Brits might phrase it.  And no being of that faith, I will not turn a cheek.

There has "been a family dispute over the inheritance of Abraham. Millions and millions of the relatives of Ishmael and Isaac believe they are the rightful heir", is his foundation basis.

He's concerned of "accusations of holocaust denial, anti-semitism, racism, apartheid and Islamophobia. And, sadly, it is being perpetuated by some misguided Christians."  In other words, it's all we Jews' fault.

Sizer, down-sizing history, Bible, law, and whatnot, will assist you "to discover the rightful heirs of Abraham, how to resolve this age long conflict, and most important of all, how you can claim a share of Abraham’s inheritance."

I think you know where this is going (where he is going, well, let's leave that to theology).

Let's deal with those Seven Steps.  And I'll have to trim down his ramblings.

1.    Abraham’s Inheritance was Promised

“On that day the Lord made a covenant with Abram and said, “To your descendants I give this land, from the Wadi of Egypt to the great river, the Euphrates…” (Genesis 15:18-21)
The ‘wadi of Egypt’ is probably one of the tributaries of the Nile. The Euphrates begins in Turkey and flows through Syria and Iraq before entering the Persian Gulf. So parts of Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Palestine, Iraq, and even Kuwait and Saudi Arabia are included.  While most secular Israeli’s today would not identify with these ‘biblical’ borders, the founders of Zionism like Theodore Herzl, Vladimir Jabotinsky and David Ben-Gurion, certainly did.
The State of Israel was founded in 1948 but successive governments have yet to declare what they regard as their international borders. Why? Because they want as larger share of Abraham’s inheritance.

Father Sizer, or is it Padre?  Even medieval Jewish commentators disagree as to those borders.  But in any case, Israel's borders have been fixed through peace treaties.  Egypt and Jordan.  The Lebanese and the Arabs-who-call-themselves-Palestinians have as yet to agree to live peacefully with Israel.

And don't forget.  Abraham was, actually, the first to accept partition.  Genesis, Chapter 13:

9 Is not the whole land before thee? separate thyself, I pray thee, from me; if thou wilt take the left hand, then I will go to the right; or if thou take the right hand, then I will go to the left.' 

2.    Abraham’s Inheritance was Misunderstood

He writes

Let me give you an example. The International Christian Embassy in Jerusalem (ICEJ)...fund the colonisation of Palestine [I can't wait to see if he writes that the Arabs 'colonised' Palestien' too] by assisting Jewish people from around the world to emigrate and live in the illegal Settlements.
The irony is, Abraham’s inheritance has been misunderstood since the days of Moses. {He then quotes Deuteronomy 1:41-44 about the battle withe Amorites but that was a one-time error and when God wanted them to fight, he was with them all the way.  He didn't say not to fight at all.

He notes that the Children of Israel "boasted", and that as per Ezekiel 33:23-28

The same arrogance prevailed in the days of Ezekiel....Therefore say to them, ‘This is what the Sovereign Lord says: Since you eat meat with the blood still in it and look to your idols and shed blood, should you then possess the land?  You rely on your sword, … Should you then possess the land?’ “Say this to them: ‘This is what the Sovereign Lord says: As surely as I live …  I will make the land a desolate waste, and her proud strength will come to an end…"...Abraham’s inheritance was promised but misunderstood because they forgot it was God’s land. It could not be conquered by a bigger army but only by God’s providence.

Well, we now surely haven't forgotten and since we staved off an invasion in 1948 and other battles and wars quite successfully, does that not indicate Divine compliance and support?


3.    Abraham’s Inheritance was Conditional

There should not have been any ambiguity over title to the land because the Lord was crystal clear in Leviticus:

“‘The land must not be sold permanently, because the land is mine and you reside in my land as foreigners and strangers.” (Leviticus 25:23)

God’s people were only permitted to reside in God’s land as foreigners and strangers.

The land was never their personal possession.

Well, we know he didn't give it to anyone else.  And that his prophets indicated we'd return.

And yes,

That is precisely why the Ten Northern tribes were eventually kicked out of the land and exiled to Assyria. Then  the remaining tribes of Judah and Benjamin were also exiled to Babylon.   Abraham’s inheritance was promised but misunderstood because they were only ever foreigners and tenants. Their continued residence was always conditional on faithful obedience.

But the Exile was ended, twice.  Once 70 years later and again, starting in the mid-19th century.


4.    Abraham’s Inheritance was Partially Experienced

Some claim the borders of Israel will extend from the Nile to the Euphrates because God’s word has not yet been fulfilled literally. But that is not what the Bible actually says...Abraham’s inheritance was promised but misunderstood because residence was always conditional and only ever experienced partially in Canaan.

These or that borders, the Land was promised to the Jews (you do, Sizer, believe that, yes?) and to no other.  The foreigner could reside and he needed to be respected.  But no right of "possession", especially not in place of the Jews.  Oh, is Sizer a supersessionist?


5.    Abraham’s Inheritance was to be Shared


He quotes

When the exiles returned to the Promised Land, as a sign of their repentance, God insisted they share the land with those of other nations residing among them.
“You are to distribute this land among yourselves according to the tribes of Israel. You are to allot it as an inheritance for yourselves and for the foreigners residing among you and who have children. You are to consider them as native-born Israelites; along with you they are to be allotted an inheritance among the tribes of Israel. In whatever tribe foreigners reside, there you are to give them their inheritance,” declares the Sovereign Lord. (Ezekiel 47:21-23)...

But doesn't that insistence happen after

behold, waters issued out from under the threshold of the house eastward, for the forefront of the house looked toward the east; and the waters came down from under, from the right side of the house, on the south of the altar.

First that and then Ezekiel's prophecy?

And of course in the time of redemption all nations shall come up to Jerusalem, a city of the Jews. And the sojourner will not live in his country but

that in what tribe the stranger sojourneth, there shall ye give him his inheritance, saith the Lord GOD

Sizer goes further:

...God...specifically mentions the Egyptians, the Iraqis, the Palestinians, Lebanese and the Africans. People of other nations were given citizenship in Israel by God because of their faith not their race.  God even anticipated that some would not be pleased to extend citizenship to other nations.

"Palestinians"?  Where are they mentioned?  What "citizenship"?

He quotes Isaiah:

“Let no foreigners who have bound themselves to the Lord say, “The Lord will surely exclude me from his people.”… And foreigners who bind themselves to the Lord to minister to him, to love the name of the Lord, and to be his servants… and who hold fast to my covenant—these I will bring to my holy mountain and give them joy in my house of prayer… for my house will be called a house of prayer for all nations.” (Isaiah 56:3, 6-7)
Now why would foreigners think “The Lord will surely exclude me from his people?” Because some of God’s people were doing the excluding! This week 30,000 Africans have been protesting in Tel Aviv because the Israeli government refuses to give them refugee status.

Yes, "residence was always conditional" but "return" was always promised.  And this: "land was to be shared on the basis of faith not race" is true, but the faith is Judaism, not Christianity.

6.    Abraham’s Inheritance is only through Jesus Christ

...Jesus is the true heir to Abraham’s inheritance. This is certainly how the writer to Hebrews portrays Jesus.
“In the past God spoke to our ancestors through the prophets at many times and in various ways, but in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son, whom he appointed heir of all things, and through whom also he made the universe.” (Hebrews 1:1-2)
Jesus is the “Heir of all things”. 

As a Jew, well, we could quibble about that.  But a s a Christian?  You're kidding?

He doesn't know Hebrew or Greek when Sizer writes:

The Apostle Paul elaborates: “The promises were spoken to Abraham and to his seed. Scripture does not say “and to seeds,” meaning many people, but “and to your seed,” meaning one person, who is Christ.” (Galatians 3:16)

Sorry, but "seed", זרעך, is indeed singular as a collective noun and means progeny, not a person and not Jesus in the sense of a Christian.  Jesus as a Jew, yes.

So the inheritance God promised Abraham would be fulfilled not through his physical descendants but through Abraham’s true heir – the Lord Jesus Christ.  

That's a neat theology trick. *


7.    Abraham’s Inheritance is in Heaven

He quotes (Hebrews 11:8-16) to claim

God had never intended Abraham’s inheritance to be a piece of real estate between Egypt and Iraq...The inheritance of Abraham was never intended to be the ‘everlasting’ possession of Palestine but an eternal home in heaven. 

I wonder what the Muslims think of this.

And then he gets exclusionist himself:

So let me ask you, do you belong to Christ? Have you received Jesus as your Lord and Saviour? Then you are a child of God. You are a legitimate heir and beneficiary of Abraham’s inheritance...Let us pray.

The Reverend Sizer, have a pint.

__________

*

I now realize that this needs a bit more explanation.

Sizer, following a twisted theological argument, bases himself on a Jew who, after realizing that his only path to success in propagating his religious outlook, is to divorce it from Judaism but to disguise that by circumventing what Judaism says while nevertheless, stealing from Judaism and supplanting it. That is, the gentile can be gentile and Jewish at the same time but even better than the Jews.  Specifically, God's promise of a covenant in which the Land of Israel is to be an everlasting possession of the Jewish People as a nation is to be wrest away from the Jews and awarded not to a people but to all peoples on the basis of a new faith, one that does not demand the fulfillment of the commandments.  And this is doubling annoying since, as we read in Sizer, he takes away from we Jews our land because we do not fulfill, supposedly, those commandments which Christians don't have to follow.  So how can they be given the share in the Land?

As noted:

Paul is forced to stress that God has done something completely new. He has skipped the old Covenant completely and included the gentiles directly in the promise to Abraham. Beker claims that for Paul: “Abraham can only be maintained in salvation-history as a figure of promise . . . The ‘Jewish’ dispensation of circumcision and the Torah has only been a curse and an obstacle . . . an interloper that inserted itself illegitimately between the promise to Abraham and its exclusive fulfilment in Christ.”...The non-Jews were now invited into the Covenant relationship. N. T. Wright takes a similar view, arguing that gentiles are now invited into the “eschatological phase” of Israel’s history which will result in the final victory of God over all gods and nations.

This illogical.


^

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

mi novice observation is that all of shvatim yisrael are all ready there:

Five Minutes for Israel said...

The real irony about Christian replacement theory is that whatever God in his heaven thinks about Christians taking over from Jews on solid ground the Muslims are taking over from the Christians.

reda said...

Thanks for the information and links you shared this is so useful and quite informative!
https://www.roknelbeet.com/نقل-اثاث-بمكة/
https://www.roknelbeet.com/نقل-اثاث-بجدة/
https://www.roknelbeet.com/نقل-اثاث-بالدمام/
https://www.roknelbeet.com/تخزين-اثاث-بالرياض/

Packers And Movers Mumbai said...

We Provide Best Packers And Movers Mumbai List for Get Free Best Quotes, Compare Charges, Save Money And Time,
Household Shifting Services.
Packers and Movers Mumbai

accountingwizards said...

Quickbooks POS Error 193 is a particular sort of Point of Sale issue that you experience when handling your mailbag. You may confront part of issues with your Point of offer and QuickBooks Error 193 is one among them.

Unknown said...

If You can't regulate adequate time to set a cellular phone at norton server error then search for the strategy under only. To stop getting the Norton antivirus tech support number USA you may have to grasp the program of action that is unquestionably knowledgeable about down listed here. It may thoroughly current you With all the resolution which you're seeking calling Norton antivirus customer support phone number which assists you to solve your queries. Visit Here: https://www.ihelplinenumber.com/Norton-Antivirus-Customer-Support/

packers and movers in mumbai said...

If you are looking Best Movers and Packers in Mumbai then Indian Packers and Movers is the right place to fulfill all your packing and moving services. Having the industry experience and expertise, our services are offered for home, business and local shifting, corporate and domestic relocation, car transportation services to our clients. We provide best Packers and Movers services in Mumbai at very affordable price @ Packers and movers in Mumbai

Unknown said...

QuickBooks Customer Service Phone Number may well aid enterprises to simplify their process plan failures and faults of QuickBooks. A complete great deal more compact enterprises frequently attained puzzled that the quantity tax they need to shell out or there are several inconveniences arrives within their way that how bookkeeping is executed properly. This method options a suitable Quickbooks customer support phone number and delivers purchasers an approach whereby these are able to unravel their challenges. Read more Get a quick reaction from examining her Corporation company Market professionals by the use of QuickBooks customer support phone number at any time and from anyplace. Visit Here: https://quickbookssupportphonenumbers.us/

Unknown said...

Are you currently looking for excellent Quickbooks Support? Inform us your trouble and after that we are going to get started work on your QuickBooks accounting application. The Quickbook Support Phone Number 1888-323-1555 has several qualified technicians who're often ready to supply quick solution regardless of what the sort of issue you might be dealing with. The QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number has hugely equipped specialists, who will take care of all kinds of concerns besides, at the same time. Grab your cellphone and call to the toll free number at any time, We are here to assist you whenever.

Moving Solutions said...

Hiring packers and movers in Gurgaon is not too hard if you take help of the best moving professionals. Best movers and packers Gurgaon assist with their skilled and trained team to pack, load, unload and unpack your belongings.
So be aware and hire the best mover packer to save your valuables.
packers and movers Gurgaon
packers and movers Gurgaon Charges

Jamess said...

it is actually a web site where all your valuable valuable employees are certain to get the data of your own paychecks. It saves significantly more time consumed by doing printing and mailing paystubs every day or replacing lost or damaged paystubs.
QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Payroll Support Number
QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support Number
QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support
Phone Number for QuickBooks Payroll Support
QuickBooks 24/7 Payroll Support Phone Number USA
QuickBooks Desktop Payroll Support Phone Number
Quickbooks Enhanced Payroll Customer Support
QuickBooks Online Payroll Contact Number
QuickBooks Payroll Contact Phone Number
QuickBooks Payroll Help Phone Number USA
QuickBooks Payroll Service Phone Number
QuickBooks Payroll Support Contact Number
QuickBooks Payroll Technical Support Phone Number
Support for QuickBooks Payroll
QuickBooks Payroll Support USA
QuickBooks Payroll Technical Support
QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number USA
QuickBooks Payroll Helpline Number
QuickBooks Payroll Customer Service Number
QuickBooks Payroll Customer Service
QuickBooks Payroll 24/7 Support Number

HP Printer Support said...

HP Printer Support

HP Printer Support Phone Number

HP Printer Support Number

HP Printer Technical Support Number

HP Printer Technical Support Phone Number

Hp printer firmware error

Hp printer firmware error



How to fix hp printer paper jam issue
how to fix hp printer paper jam issue


troubleshoot hp printer error code 79

troubleshoot hp printer error code 79

hp printer support said...

HP Printer Support Phone Number

HP Printer Contact Number

Brother Printer Support Phone Number

Brother Printer Support Phone Number


Canon Printer Support Phone Number
Canon Printer Support Phone Number


Epson printer Support Phone Number
Epson Printer Support Phone Number

Epson Printer Support Number

Epson Printer Support

epson printer support phone number said...

HOme PAGE
Epson Printer Support Phone Number

Epson Printer Support Number

Epson Printer Customer Support Number

Epson Printer Customer Support

Epson Printer Technical Support


Epson Printer Technical Support Number
Epson Printer Technical Support Number

Epson Printer Technical Support Phone Number


Epson
Epson Printer Support Phone Number

Epson Printer Support Number

Epson Printer Technical Support Number

Epson Printer Technical Support Phone Number

Epson Printer Technical Support

Epson Printer Tech Support Phone Number

Epson Support

nickjonas said...

canon Printer Suppor

canon Printer Support Number

canon Printer Support Phone Number

canon Printer Tech Support Phone Number

canon Printer Support Number

canon Printer Support

canon Printer Customer Care

canon Printer Customer Support Number

canon Printer Customer Support Phone Number

canon Printer Toll Free Number

canon Printer TollFree Number

canon Printer Contact Number

canon printer is not responding
canon printer is not responding

canon printer error code 6000
canon printer error code 6000

how to fix-canon printer error code 5800
how to fix canon printer error code 5800

canon printer driver support
canon printer driver support

HP Printer Support said...

HP hp Printer
hp printer Support

hp Support

brother printer
brother printer Support

brother Support

canon printer
canon printer Support

canon Support

epson
epson printer Support

epson Support

Dell Printer
dell printer Support

dell Support

Lexmark Printer
Lexmark Support

Lexmark printer Support

Quicken Support said...


Quicken
Quicken Support Phone Number

Quicken Support Phone Number USA

Quicken Support Number

Quicken Support

QuickBooks
QuickBooks Support Phone Number

QuickBooks Support Phone Number USA

QuickBooks Support Number

QuickBooks Support

Sage
Sage Support Phone Number

Sage Support Phone Number USA

Sage Support Number

Sage Support

TurboTax
TurboTax Support Phone Number

TurboTax Support Number

TurboTax Support



James said...

HP Support Number provide online help & support for every HP Product, Visit website and connect with our HP technicians to resolve your HP related every issues instantaly.
HP Customer Support
HP Support
HP Support Number
HP Printer Support

CANON PRINTER SUPPORT said...

Canon printer support allows you to interact your any technical issues about canon printers, with us. if any kind of queries visit our website. link given in the discription
Canon printer support , we are here to help you out from any type of technical queries in canon printers. if you have any queries related canon printer visit our link given in the description. we are available 24*7 for you.canon printer support number
canon printer helpline number
canon printer tech support
canon printer technical support number
canon printer toll free number


Epson PRINTER TECH SUPPORT TEAM said...


epson Printer Support

epson Printer Support

epons printer customer support number

epson Printer Technical Support Number

Canon Printer Support Phone Number said...

Canon Printer support are here to help you out from an kind of technical queries related to canon printer. We have highly experienced and reliable team members with us. Just contact us by visiting our website link. Get our other support like support number, support phone number, technical support, helpline support. we are 24*7 available. Canon Printer Support
Canon Printer Support Number
Canon Printer Support Phone Number
Canon Printer Customer Support Number
Canon Printer Support Toll-Free Number
Canon Printer Tech Support Number
Canon Printer Technical Support Number
Canon Printer Helpline Number

Packers and Movers in Mumbai said...

Contact to the best Packers and Movers in Mumbai for 100% secured relocation of your house and office, we are the top Packers and Movers Mumbai to relocate bike, car and both. We are the most popular Packer and Mover in Mumbai to install RO, AC and both, we are the top rated Packer and Mover Mumbai to relocate above 3BHK.


http://www.findpackers.com/packers-and-movers-in-mumbai

Aria Madelyn said...

Contact to the best Packers and Movers in Hyderabad for 100% secured relocation of your house and office, we are the top Packers and Movers Hyderabad to relocate bike, car and both. We are the most popular Packer and Mover in Hyderabad to install RO, AC and both, we are the top rated Packer and Mover Hyderabad to relocate above 3BHK.

Packers and movers in delhi
packers and movers in kolkata
packers and movers in bangalore
packers and movers in pune
packers and movers in faridabad
packers and movers in mumbai
packers and movers in hyderabad
packers and movers in noida

sowmya said...


Thanks for sharing this wonderful article.
Best packers and movers in Bangalore
packers and movers in koramangala
packers and movers in hebbal
packers and movers in indiranagar
packers and movers in jp nagar
packers and movers in madiwala
packers and movers in yeshwanthpur
packers and movers in adugodi
packers and movers in bellandur
packers and movers in banashankari

pavithrasri said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
pavithrasri said...


Thanks for sharing this wonderful article

Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers in banashankari
Packers and Movers in bommanahalli
Packers and Movers domlur
Packers and Movers in yelahanka

Quickbooks error said...

Quickbooks error h202 can keep you from getting to your organization records and hence, requirements to get settled right away.

pavithrasri said...

Thanks for sharing this amazing article

Top cyber security companies in delhi ncr
Cyber security expert in delhi ncr
cyber security expert
vapt
VCISO

MTB-Bikes said...

fastest electric unicycle