Knesset Members Moshe Feiglin, Uri Ariel and Tzippi Hotebeli joined a prayer service held by the Movement for the Rebuilding of the Templel at the Temple Mount in Jerusalem..The presence of the MKs prevented the Jerusalem District Police from arresting any of the other worshippers as the MKs have parliamentary immunity. Officers with the Waqf Guard, the special force tasked with maintaining public order at the Temple Mount, attempted to prevent Feiglin from entering the premises, but he insisted on his right to pray there while wearing a tallit.The prayer service itself was held under police protection, as the MKs were subjected to harsh expletives by the other Muslim worshipers at the site.Feiglin stressed the importance of maintaining the rights of all Jewish worshipers in the holy site: "At first, the [police] tried to stop us from entering the plaza, saying that we would be causing a public disturbance, but there is nothing 100 men and women armed with a tallit can't do. Surrounded by police officers, and with the Ilsmaic fanatics yelling at us, we stood off to the side far from any Muslim building and prayed."Feiglin said, "I felt a great sense of duty, as well as a sense of privilege, to stand here and make sure that every Jew in the world is free to pray as they see fit. It is inconceivable that one religion will assume sole exclusive ownership over a location which is the holiest place for Jews worldwide...we have to remember that there is more bringing us together that there is pulling us apart, and that the least we can do is allow every man and every woman to pray according to their conscience."
No, not really.
Knesset Members Stav Shaffir, Tamar Zandberg and Michal Rozin on Tuesday joined the monthly prayer service held by the Women of the Wall at the Western Wall Plaza in Jerusalem.The Women of the Wall have been holding monthly prayer services at the Western Wall for the past 24 years. They do so while donning a tallit – the traditional Jewish prayer shawl – which is illegal for women visiting the site, and often results in their arrest.However, the presence of the MKs prevented the Jerusalem District Police from arresting any of the women on Tuesday as the MKs have parliamentary immunity.Officers with the Kotel Guard, the special force tasked with maintaining public order at the Western Wall Plaza, attempted to prevent Shaffir from entering the premises, but she insisted on her right to pray there while wearing a tallit.The prayer service itself was held under police protection, as the women were subjected to harsh expletives by the other worshipers at the site.Shaffir stressed the importance of maintaining the rights of all Jewish worshipers in the holy site: "At first, the [police] tried to stop us from entering the plaza, saying that we would be causing a public disturbance, but there is nothing 100 women armed with a tallit can't do. Surrounded by police officers, and with the haredi men yelling at us from across the fence, with stood before the Western Wall and prayed."Shaffir said that while she does not normally don the Jewish prayer shawl,
"I felt a great sense of duty, as well as a sense of privilege, to stand here and make sure that every Jew in the world is free to pray as they see fit. It is inconceivable that one faction of Judaism will assume ownership over the holiest place for Jews worldwide."According to Shaffir, "While there are real differences between the various factions in Judaism on the correct way to worship God, we have to remember that there is more bringing us together that there is pulling us apart, and that the least we can do is allow every man and every woman to pray according to their conscience."Western Wall Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz commented on the prayer service: "Today, the first of [the Jewish month of] Nisan we witnessed harsh scenes, the likes of which have not been seen in the Western Wall Plaza since its liberation. A group of women, seeking to express their world view, chose to make the Western Wall the site of their protest and create an unnecessary conflict."Their actions are against the law and are in violation of a High Court of Justice ruling as well as the attorney general's directives, especially since they were given permission to hold their services near Robinson's Arch," he said, referring to an area along the western wall of the Temple Mount, which is at a distance from the Western Wall Plaza.Rabinowitz said that the Women of the Wall "insist on holding their services in the women's gallery, while offending the other worshipers. Their actions will inflict upon Jerusalem the civil war that was once its destruction."The Western Wall is the one place shared by all the people of Israel and it is not the place to make statements or express world views. I urge all those who care about the Western Wall to call to keep any disputes outside the plaza and to leave the people of Israel one place that is free of protest, riots and hatred."
P.S. Just saw Tamar Zandberg's Facebook comment
לעניין הר הבית: אני תומכת בחופש הדת והפולחן, שנמנע כרגע בהר הבית בגלל הכיבוש. אני גאה להשתייך לתנועה פוליטית שהיא בין היחידות שנאבקת לסיום הכיבוש ולפתרון צודק שיכלול חופש דת במקומות הקדושים לבני ובנות כל הדתות. אשמח לעוד שותפות ושותפים במאבק הזה, שיביא בין היתר לכך שגם יהודים יוכלו סוף סוף להתפלל בהר הבית
Regarding the Temple Mount: I support freedom of religion and worship, now prevented on the Temple Mount because of the occupation. I am proud to belong to a political movement which is the only fighting to end the occupation and a just solution to include freedom of religion in the holy places for all members, men and women, for all religions. I'd love more partners in this fight, which will bring about, among other things, that even Jews can finally pray
By her "occupation" reference, I presume that she means that the Muslims prevent Jews from praying or expressing themselves in a religious ritual fashion because they are resisting the "occupation". No historic background or knowledge.
^
2 comments:
Yisrael ,
Well this I must say is pleasing for me to read yet ironically so .
It is interesting to see a woman actually going up and wearing a Talit on The Temple Mount .
One would think a man would be the one doing such a heroic act !
God bless these brave and courageous women !
Reminds me of the time of Devorah in The Book of Judges .
Take care Yisrael .
Regards to Batya and all of Shiloh .
With kind and blessed prayers,
David Shimshon
Edward F. Villa
www.insightonthenews.net
In the article quoted, two comments by Rabbi Rabinowitz beg replies:
1) "A group of women, seeking to express their world view, chose to make the Western Wall the site of their protest and create an unnecessary conflict."
The conflict was created by the Orthodox who, after 1967, turned the Western Wall into an Orthodox synagogue, which effectively prevents anyone else (Jews and others) from praying in their own way. It was, then, the Orthodox, such as Rabbi Rabinowitz, who created the conflict, NOT the Women of the Wall.
2) "The Western Wall is the one place shared by all the people of Israel..."
EXACTLY. The Western Wall should be treated as a "holy site", NOT as a synagogue, opening it up to allow anyone who wants to pray there to do so in their own way. After all, it was the Prophet Isaiah, when commenting on the Temple, said it was to be a "house of prayer for ALL nations." Why should the Western Wall be anything less?
Post a Comment