Tuesday, August 05, 2014

More on 'No Hamas Fighter Died?'

Following up on my previous post on civilian casualties and my post on open spaces , If you depend on the UN for your data, you (and we) have a problem.


and if you depend on PCHR:

I am not that clever with math but something is missing.

How many Hamas fighters died?


As of July 28, we have this.

and now this from Aug. 3:

we know now that Hamas have ordered their people to report all deaths as innocent civilians. We know too that Hamas has a track record of lying about casualties. After Operation Cast Lead, the 2008-09 fighting in Gaza, the IDF estimated that of 1,166 Palestinian deaths, 709 were fighters. Hamas – backed by several NGOs – claimed that only 49 of its fighters had been killed, the rest were innocent civilians. Much later they were forced to admit that the IDF had been right all along and between 600 and 700 of the casualties had in fact been fighters. But the short-memoried media are incapable of factoring this in before broadcasting their ill-founded and inflammatory assertions.

Analysis of casualty details released by Qatar-based Al Jazeera indicate that so far in the conflict most of those killed in Gaza have been young men of fighting age, not women, children or old people. According to one analyst, despite comprising around 50% of the population, the proportion of women among the dead is 21%.  Preliminary analysis by the Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center in Israel suggests that 71, or 46.7%, of the first 152 Palestinians killed were fighters and 81, or 53.3%, non-involved civilians.

None of this analysis is definitive. But it does cast doubt upon the accusations of indiscriminate attack against the population by the IDF and upon the UN estimates – widely trumpeted as fact by the media and the not-exactly unbiased United Nations – that between 70 and 80% of Palestinian casualties have been civilians.


1 comment:

Anonymous said...

depending on source:
100% - 85% = 15% Hamas
100% - 86% = 14% Hamas

also, expect the number to grow, because a lot of the dead families, that where killed in their homes, will be found now.

i'm always glad if i can help you with math.