Thursday, July 26, 2007
Request for Legal Assistance against ISM
New York Attorney Andrew Nitzberg has asked for assistance in locating witnesses. Please read the following and help out if you can.
=====================================================
My name is Andrew Nitzberg and I am a trial attorney practicing largely in the state of New York. I am the lawyer responsible for the trial victory of Lee Kaplan against Mohammed Salahi earlier this year. (The action was for private speech by Salahi that cost Lee Kaplan several jobs. The 'free speech' defense fell flat because this was for private, not public, speech. The court records and decision are posted online by the California court administration.)
I am filing for an injunction against George Mason University for their upcoming conference of the 'International Solidarity movement', the US wing of Hamas.
I need assistance in the form of evidence. Of course there is lots of evidence to show that the ISM is a violent, Jew-hating group which directly assists terrorists in coming to their targets and similar activities. But i need evidence admissible in a court of law.
No one will be required to appear in court or to travel (except me -- the pro bono (unpaid) lawyer).
1. I need statements from persons who have directly observed ISM personnel stating things like, "Kill the Jews", "We support the resistance of the Palestinian people even when they engage in Terrorism" , "We work with Hamas in the West Bank and Gaza", "We work with Hizballah".
Persons attending the Michigan ISM conference in (I think) 2002 would be very helpful here.)
2. I need statements indicating that persons have observed ISM persons beating up persons who do not support the agenda of the ISM (this should be very easy- they beat people up every year at these things.)
3. I need statements that persons have personally observed ISM personnel with weapons or transporting weapons. Statements from ISM personnel that admit to such contact with weapons are excellent.
4. There are people looking for the 'perfect plaintiff' for the action. (We have general students (2) eager to sign on, but we would like the 'perfect plaintiff' -- who is a student (BA or grad)/administrator/faculty member who has a family member in Israel. (The Virginia criminal code makes this a very attractive plaintiff). Any
Jewish person is eligible because we can shake the family tree and find some relative who is living in Israel.
Thank you for this help. Every terrorist is my enemy because I am a friend to freedom. I am hopeful that I will find many friends in this effort.
Andrew Nitzberg
ajnn@msn.com
=====================================================
My name is Andrew Nitzberg and I am a trial attorney practicing largely in the state of New York. I am the lawyer responsible for the trial victory of Lee Kaplan against Mohammed Salahi earlier this year. (The action was for private speech by Salahi that cost Lee Kaplan several jobs. The 'free speech' defense fell flat because this was for private, not public, speech. The court records and decision are posted online by the California court administration.)
I am filing for an injunction against George Mason University for their upcoming conference of the 'International Solidarity movement', the US wing of Hamas.
I need assistance in the form of evidence. Of course there is lots of evidence to show that the ISM is a violent, Jew-hating group which directly assists terrorists in coming to their targets and similar activities. But i need evidence admissible in a court of law.
No one will be required to appear in court or to travel (except me -- the pro bono (unpaid) lawyer).
1. I need statements from persons who have directly observed ISM personnel stating things like, "Kill the Jews", "We support the resistance of the Palestinian people even when they engage in Terrorism" , "We work with Hamas in the West Bank and Gaza", "We work with Hizballah".
Persons attending the Michigan ISM conference in (I think) 2002 would be very helpful here.)
2. I need statements indicating that persons have observed ISM persons beating up persons who do not support the agenda of the ISM (this should be very easy- they beat people up every year at these things.)
3. I need statements that persons have personally observed ISM personnel with weapons or transporting weapons. Statements from ISM personnel that admit to such contact with weapons are excellent.
4. There are people looking for the 'perfect plaintiff' for the action. (We have general students (2) eager to sign on, but we would like the 'perfect plaintiff' -- who is a student (BA or grad)/administrator/faculty member who has a family member in Israel. (The Virginia criminal code makes this a very attractive plaintiff). Any
Jewish person is eligible because we can shake the family tree and find some relative who is living in Israel.
Thank you for this help. Every terrorist is my enemy because I am a friend to freedom. I am hopeful that I will find many friends in this effort.
Andrew Nitzberg
ajnn@msn.com
Mob as in Load (not Toad)
My last (*) comment left over at Jewschool aka Mobius:-
Go on over.
(*) Really, my very last comment - he's thrown in the towel but defiant in his insistence I'm a bigot and "a militant Zionist" (militant? no, I don't use a gun).
Mob - for a religious/ethnic/cultural group that has produced countless comedic entertainers in the last 100 years alone, i am utterly shocked at the humorlessness of the greater jewish community.
Me - so, that's it. that's all you've got to say? Not even 'whew, i'm tired of all this'? No apologies, no attempts at 'well, perhaps i did sterotype you', no nothing? All you have to say is that the Jews are guilty because a few of us don't have the same sense of humor as you do and worse, you claim that the "humor" we see as latent, under-the-surface, cute Judeophobia is really not antisemitic in any form and that even if it is, I/we can't organize to combat it, and if we do, we're causing more antisemtism while only you of the Left know how to combat real antisemtism.
That sentence is too long but someone around here is too short on understanding.
Go on over.
(*) Really, my very last comment - he's thrown in the towel but defiant in his insistence I'm a bigot and "a militant Zionist" (militant? no, I don't use a gun).
Dear Mob - you're right, er, correct. Go on with your life (but believe me, you do way more blogging than I do). Of course, not being able to deal with my life existence, my outlook on life, and, in all humbleness, the reality that your outlook and approach is mostly wrong (and dangerous to Zionism and Jews, maybe even more so than the Judeophobes you can't see), you simply malign, demonize, and diss me rather than applying your make-belive rules of liberalism, Chofetz Chaim, etc. And you know that The Möbius strip is a surface with only one side and only one boundary component. It has the mathematical property of being non-orientable. Oh, how so applicable to your one-dimensional denounciations of me.
Police Violence at Eitam
From Laura Ben-David's account:-
© Laura Ben David. 2007
By Laura Ben David, Neve Daniel
E-mail: bendavid.laura@gmail.com
People were coming and going. Early on we met a distraught woman on her way back. She said that they had made it to the end, and her husband was holding an Israeli flag. One soldier allegedly pushed her husband, and then it seemed to be open-season on this man as a number of other soldiers jumped in to attack him, after which the man was arrested - all for holding an Israeli flag.
A bit further on I watched four border policemen drag someone away. I had no idea what he had or had not done to warrant such excessive force. Maybe he was passively resisting? Or maybe he was a dangerous criminal? That seemed rather unlikely though.
Moshe, a 15 year old from Chashmonaim, had a very difficult time. When he and his friends reached the final hill of Eitam, he spoke to some of the soldiers there, explaining the importance for every Jew to settle the Land of Israel. A border policeman, whose name, ironically, was Arafat, started cursing them and pushing. The boys weren't looking for a fight. They were speaking nicely with one of the Yassam officers, when this man allegedly said, "I'm sick of being nice" and started to choke Moshe, while covering his mouth. Four Yassam officers reportedly joined in, and threw him onto a bus. When Moshe protested further brutal action toward someone else, the officer punched him in the face, used pressure points in his ear to cause pain, cursed at him. Finally, other cops pulled his attacker off the bus. However, soon afterwards several Yassam officers got back on the bus, pushed the border policemen who was protecting him out of the way, and proceeded to pull his tzizit, choking him, and kicking him. All the while Moshe was yelling, "I surrender, I surrender! I didn't do anything!"
Despite how terrible these reports seemed, I was determined to try to see this event through the eyes of the soldiers and officers. I desperately wanted to understand. I therefore tried talking to many of the various security personnel on the scene. I wanted to know - did it torment them to have to prevent their fellow Jews from their struggle to preserve the Jewish quality of the Land of Israel? Most were pretty tight-lipped. One of the border policemen put it this way: "This is a restricted area, no civilians are allowed. There are hostile villages here."
"Yes," I told him, "I understand. But how do you feel about doing this?"
"I don't feel. I do my orders."
I tried several other officers. One told me that he can't speak to me while in uniform, that he has a job. I suggested that I speak to him later, when he is off-duty, and he said, "Later, I just want to go home."
I couldn't help but wonder: Does the army consist solely of battalions, or of individuals too? Where should the individual end and the establishment begin? Can they coexist? Must we lose our humanity to be part of the establishment?
The current "establishment" seems to have completely sold-out on the pioneers of Israel. What was Zionism, patriotism and nationalistic spirit, is now patently illegal. Criminal activity. Our soldiers - OUR SOLDIERS! - have been charged with stopping us in our tracks. Maybe even to threaten us and hurt us. Sometimes they do. But not always.
© Laura Ben David. 2007
By Laura Ben David, Neve Daniel
E-mail: bendavid.laura@gmail.com
Sneaky
New plan for Temple Mount bridge aims to silence critics
Jerusalem's Planning and Construction Committee will begin discussing an alternative to the controversial Mughrabi Bridge project Wednesday.
The original plan for the bridge, which leads from the Old City's Dung Gate and the Western Wall to the Temple Mount's Mughrabi Gate, raised hackles in the Arab world when it was presented in February, due to allegations that it would damage the Temple Mount.
The new plan, which is to be presented by a team of experts, is very different from the previous one. It shortens the bridge, which will now follow the route of the existing ramp to the Mughrabi, instead of beginning in the area of the Southern Wall Archaeological Park, where some experts feared that it would block the view of the Temple Mount.
The bridge will consist of a wooden walkway bordered by metal, with two-meter-high iron railings, as required by the police. The number of pylons supporting it will be reduced from seven to four.
The height of the pylons will not exceed half a meter, and they will be placed on platforms in spaces excavated by the Israel Antiquities Authority during its salvage dig, allowing the antiquities to be restored and protected.
The planners mapped the archaeological finds along the bridge's path and found spaces in which the pylons could be placed without damaging the antiquities.
The bridge will not only be used by visitors coming to the Temple Mount, but also by the police, to send in large forces in case of unrest on the mount, where the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock are located.
The municipality and the Interior Ministry are now preparing to deal with the project's major opponents: Israeli Arabs, East Jerusalem residents and the Arab world.
Wednesday, July 25, 2007
L'Affair Wonkette Round-up
My first post
First links appear (thanks to CarlS)
I am threatened
Wonkette's Ken folds up
More links
http://myrightword.blogspot.com/2007/07/more-links.html
Brit Hume
Major flaming at Mobius
First links appear (thanks to CarlS)
I am threatened
Wonkette's Ken folds up
More links
http://myrightword.blogspot.com/2007/07/more-links.html
Brit Hume
Major flaming at Mobius
Who Said Kibbutznikim Are Socialists?
They're making money off of "humanitarian" efforts:-
Source.
The IDF closed Sufa Crossing on Tuesday after a Channel 10 crew managed to bypass Israeli security, cross into the Gaza Strip and interview several Palestinians.
Angry truck drivers began to throw rocks at the television crew and soldiers had to break up the ensuing brawl. The crew was then taken for police questioning for their unauthorized entry into the Strip.
The closure of the crossing sparked angry reactions towards Channel 10, which responded that their crew had exposed a severe security flaw which allowed goods to cross into Gaza without being screened.
Channel 10 claimed that the crossing operated under the control of Kibbutz Sufa, which benefited financially because of the terminal's use. The crew also discovered that each truck driver paid NIS 400 to Kibbutz Sufa in order to cross.
Source.
Typeractive
Urban Word of the Day
July 25, 2007: typeractive
July 25, 2007: typeractive
Someone who is overly talkative on emails or text messages.
Man, this Emily should get a job. She's been messaging me every 2 minutes. And there are 10 emails in my inbox from her. She is way typeractive today.
Pal. Campus Activity
From Pal. Academia:
10th paragraph
on Tuesday, the police broke up a fight between Fatah and Hamas students at An Najah University in Nablus. Three people were wounded by gunfire, including one who was shot in the head and was in critical condition, doctors said. Others were injured in beatings. The clash began when Hamas backers staged a sit-in and Fatah supporters demanded that they remove Hamas flags.
10th paragraph
And Over at Mobius...
Here's the entire full comment section up until this morning with my comment in bold at the end.
Yisrael Medad can’t take a joke, Wonkette misses the high-road
by Mobius [his mirror site] • Monday, July 23rd, 2007
Jew-liani.
We’ve all seen it already, right?
Well, West Bank-based blogger Yisrael Medad hadn’t. And even if he had, he apparently wouldn’t have gotten the joke. Which is cool and all — you wouldn’t normally expect an Orthodox religious settler to get all that D.C. politico insider baseball. Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.
At any rate, in a nod to the brilliance of said video, Wonkette’s been on a roll with a tongue-in-cheek if mildly disconcerting branding of Rudy as “Jew-liani” in various posts to their blog. If anything, Medad should have accused Wonkette of serving that dish far past its expiration date. What was that, a month ago guys?
But instead, being unfamiliar with both the video and Wonkette’s naughty charm, Medad wheeled out the antisemitism charge, setting off a round of denunciations throughout the right-wing blogosphere.
Wonkette editor Ken Layne responded in poor fashion, going so far as to allude to taking possible legal action against Medad. He later followed up with a retraction and cited an inbox full of Lizard Freeper hatemail as the source of his outrage. Being familiar with the experience, I can empathize.
I wonder, had Jon Stewart made the same joke, would Medad have reacted in the same way?
~~~
If Medad really wants to go after an antisemitic website, he should investigate why it is that every time I post a comment to this article on Digg challenging Reagan-era economist Paul Craig Roberts’ assertion that the Mossad is conspiring with Bush to fake terror attacks in America, it gets voted out of existence.
Filed under Washington, On The Web, Antisemitism
21 Responses to “Yisrael Medad can’t take a joke, Wonkette misses the high-road”
1. Hey, helllooooo! It’s Tisha B’Av, atleast for those of us currently in Israel, and soon for those abroad. I came back from hearing Eicha, and THIS is what Jewschool had to add to my meditation on the state of our people on this mournful day?! What gives?
—Sof Maarav • July 23rd, 2007 at 3:37 pm
2. Are you sure that’s not the Ron Paul brigade voting you down? They’re pretty influencial on Digg.
—Ayrkain • July 23rd, 2007 at 3:51 pm
3. “you wouldn’t normally expect an Orthodox religious settler to get all that D.C. politico insider baseball. Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
I’m not feeling the love.
—incorrect • July 23rd, 2007 at 4:48 pm
4. Well, at least you spelled my name right.
Allow me thought to respond to one charge: that of support for ethnic cleansing (the rest of what you think of me is just silly nonsense - I got the joke but I didn’t think it funny). You write -”Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.” Well, I am not sure about others like me but I don’t legitimize ethnic cleansing. Don’t worry, I won’t take you court but permit me a few sentences here.
I believe that all who wish to live in this country, the Jewish, democratic state of Israel, the culmination of the Zionist movement’s effort to redeem, at this stage, the Jewish people, can and should on one condition: that they don’t try to subvert or alter what the state is supposed to be. One thing it isn’t to be is a Palestinian Arab state. If anyone has engaged in premeditated ethnic cleansing, it it the Arabs. Tel Hai in 1920, Jaffa in 1921, Petah Tikvah in 1924, 1929 in Hevron, Beer Tuviah & Hulda and in 1947-48, Gush Etzion, Bet Haaravah, Neveh Yaakov and Atarot and Jerusalem’s Old City were ethnically cleansed of Jews by Arabs. I consider a Jew and Zionist who bandies about that term in order to malign a Jew who has returned to his homeland not only stupid and incorrect factually but a gross adoption of the enemy’s propaganda line. Despite your JBS quotation below, you have attacked a person because, I am pretty sure, you don’t know me and if you had reviewed my site (as you suggested I had done with Wonkette), you would not assign me such views in your off-handed, conveniently- justifying-your-own-views manner.
Have a nice rest of Tisha B’Av.
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 3:37 am
5. Oh, and did you blog about the ethnic cleansing of Nahr el-Bared?
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 3:53 am
6. The Chicago Tribune didn’t find it so funny (some paragraphs have been deleted for brevity’s sake):
Harry Potter and Gawker’s Jewish problem
The piece is about how “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows” comes out at 2:01 a.m. Saturday in Israel, but Israeli law prohibits stores from being open on the Sabbath, or as Gawker puts it: “Head Heebs in the Holy Land are trying to keep bookstores closed at the appointed hour of the novel’s release.”
“Some stores are planning to open anyway — these are Jews, let’s remember, and a buck’s a buck — which has resulted in predictable outrage from the Adonai-adoring elements of Israeli society.”
They didn’t just go there, did they? What, is it Fun with Ages-Old Slanderous Stereotypes Week?
The piece then quotes someone from the United Torah Judaism Party (by way of an Associated Press story) slamming the Potter books’ “defective messages” and their subculture before the Gawker writer fires back: “[I]sn’t this exactly how some of us feel about, you know, the Bible and its subculture of weird, tallis-wearing followers?”
Hee hee — Orthodox Jews and other Bible readers sure are a bunch of weirdos!
—incorrect • July 24th, 2007 at 10:16 am
7. I find it offensive that on Erev Tisha B’Av of all days, you post such venomous attacks on Jews, complete with the sentence, “Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
Seeing your Chofetz Chaim green boxed message to my right as I type this, “Jewish Bloggers for Responsible Speech online” — I can only assume you put it there as a cynical joke.
Your quote from the Rav beneath below is diametrically and utterly opposed to the language of your post.
Oh right…everything’s a joke to you, Mobius.
A fabulous Tisha B’av to you as well.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 10:35 am
8. awww, what’s the matter jameel? did i show you a part of yourself you don’t like?
you know you could give me 1001 torah proofs for justifying transferring the arabs out of the territories. don’t even front.
that i would identify it as an area of expertise for religious settlers isn’t “a venomous attack.” it a matter of fact.
what, you think i’ve never slept in a caravan? what, you don’t think i have family out in those hills? i know your kind, bro… and tisha b’av of all days is davka when i should stuff it back down your throat.
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 2:27 pm
9. Gee, this is a rereading of Kamtza-BarKamtza circa 2007. For the benefit of those reading this post, I, Yisrael Medad, resident of Shiloh since 1981 (I’ll leave out all my other bio info) do not advocate ethnic cleansing, do not advocate dumping all Arabs in the sea/river/gulf or whatever (although I do bring up the subject in arguments to offset demands for ethnic cleansing of Yesha of its Jews) and do believe, in the legacy of Ze’ev Jabotinsky, that this country can have multiple communities. I argued with Rav Kahane on the subject when I was Geula Cohen’s aide and he was an MK. So, please, let’s not get irresponsible, Mobius, and let’s stick to the facts. And I do apologize for not being the stereotype fanatic, right-wing extremist you would prefer as your opponent.
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 2:41 pm
10. And the righties play “miss the point” and “change the subject” once more. But Mo, you know that snide comment was their perfect excuse.
The REAL point of the article being, when an anti-Semitic canard is adopted by alleged philo-Semites on the Right… complete silence. But if a liberal were to co-opt its usage to make fun of it… Oh, where have I heard that definition before? Oh that’s right - SATIRE.
Reality just can’t compete.
—B.BarNavi • July 24th, 2007 at 2:46 pm
11. Yisrael: Give me a break. You eat Arab babies for breakfast, just as Mobius thinks you do.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 3:13 pm
12. “Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
What an awful thing to say. I don’t understand how we can expect large groups of people with divergent religious, political and social beliefs to humanize one another if we can’t be respectful of one another on the freaking internet.
—ira • July 24th, 2007 at 3:25 pm
13. Ira: Its not an awful thing for Mobius to say; he’s lived in a caravan before.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 4:09 pm
14. oh jameel, is this how you’re going to spend your day? don’t you have some olive trees to uproot, or some school children to throw rocks at, or maybe some posts to write pontificating on the utter evils of palestinian society?
maybe you’d care to explain to me which posek overturns “not by force of arms but by My hand alone…”
and i didn’t live in a caravan… i’ve just slept in a few.
speaking of which, has anyone ever told you how utterly offensive and vile the illustration on your blog’s header is?
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 4:30 pm
15. and how ’bout you yisrael? don’t you have another post to write about the jewish volunteers of machsom watch being “nasty ladies” because they oppose the idf’s travel restrictions on palestinian civilians? there’s a tisha b’av lesson learned…
religious settlers are the poster children for cognitive dissonance. they condemn everyone who doesn’t see the world their way (which is practically everyone except themselves), and then cry foul and “torah violations” when other jews point out the fact that they believe, say and do abhorrent things that desecrate the name of g-d and jeopardize the security of jewish people throughout the world.
identifying this cognitive dissonance is not an act of baseless hatred — it’s an act of love. love for g-d, love for eretz yisrael, love for am yisrael, and an expression of excruciating pain at the sight of my fellow yidn conducting themselves in a way that harms all of us.
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 4:52 pm
16. hey mobius– having met you, I do believe that your critique comes from a place of love.
however, I don’t think that spirit is coming across in this comment thread.
and that’s when people shut down and stop listening and start trying to win the debate instead of to learn.
It’s the afternoon of tisha b’av– ahavat chinam and all that. let’s make it constructive.
—rebecca m • July 24th, 2007 at 5:38 pm
17. i hear you rebecca, but really, which is worse: making yisrael medad look like a putz, or letting yisrael medad make all jewish people look like putzes?
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 11:09 pm
18. here - let me try to reframe this:
right now, there’s a strong sentiment on both the right and left that the charge of antisemitism is a baseless accusation used to silence criticism of israeli policy and the israel lobby. the walt & mearshimer paper is just one example evidencing this sentiment’s entry into mainstream american thinking.
it’s obvious to anyone who reads wonkette that they were making fun of right-wing antisemites by calling giuliani “jew-liani.” yet not only did medad irresponsibly and unfoundedly charge wonkette with being antisemitic, but he invited the entire right-wing blogosphere to uphold his misrepresentation as proof positive of the left-wing’s moral bankruptcy.
in other words, medad stood reality on its head and willingly fabricated a false charge of antisemitism in order to delegitimize others whose political opinions he disagrees with (not that wonkette pays anything more than superficial attention to israel anyway).
he has thus engaged in a propaganda strategy that has earned him a lot of web traffic from the neocon right, but which effectively reinforces the belief that the charge of antisemitism is baseless and employed only to smear critics of israeli policy and/or the israel lobby.
in other words, he ran a play from abe foxman’s handbook, contributing directly to a “boy who cried wolf” impression of antisemitism that makes it all the more difficult to identify and combat real expressions of antisemitism that do truly pose a danger to the jewish community.
thus, through his actions, medad has contributed to the deterioration of jewish security as a whole.
so i told him he was a putz. nu?
—Mobius • July 25th, 2007 at 12:18 am
19. Mobius, I don’t think your insight into the Wonkette psyche is any better than mine or the Chicago Tribune’s, and we both thought (along with many others) that the Wonkette anti semite shout out was not satire but represented actual anti semitism in action. And the “Jewliani” nonsense has been all over the leftwing arena, not the right wing. I’m eager to fight against antisemitism on the right (e.g. Pat Buchanan, Robert Novak), why do you find it so difficult to admit anti semitism on the left?
—incorrect • July 25th, 2007 at 12:41 am
20. i find it difficult to admit antisemitism on the left? what are you freaking talking about? i’ve not only covered the subject ad infinitum, but i’ve collaborated on several projects to make more productive inroads into addressing the issue than simply crying that the left are a bunch of nazis. in fact, within the next week or so, we should be publishing a whole expose on and challenge to antisemitism at the world social forum.
and as per my insight into the wonkette psyche, tell me — how often do you read wonkette? it doesn’t much seem the kind of site you’d be terribly interested in. but then again, you seem to enjoy trolling websites you hate reading so…
are you even aware of the fact that gawker media is owned by a hungarian jew?
—Mobius • July 25th, 2007 at 12:53 am
21. Mobius, to answer your question, I use to read Wonkette fairly often when she first started, but she ultimately grew boring and I stopped. Meanwhile I went to your site regarding you objecting to anti semitism of the left and I saw a reference to a conference. I’ll repeat the question, who are the leftist anti semites you would publicly call out (and I don’t mean fringe crazies) - you call me the troll but I’m willing to identify “mainstream” rightists as antisemites because I’m willing to apply my standards consistently whether with reference to rightists or leftists. I challenge you to do the same - are you covering for anti semitic leftists, or are you willing to name them?
—incorrect • July 25th, 2007 at 2:47 am
22. Good morning to all.
There’s a lot to respond to but as I don’t want Mobius to choke on the froth coming out of his mouth, I’ll be gentle.
I know that Mobius doesn’t know me but as I serve for him as a symbol of the target of his hatred, what can I do? He needs me. He needs me to be who I am not because that justifies his outlook and anger and uncotrollable urges (no, I am not accusing you of being a wife-beater).
So, let’s make some comments:
1) him
and how ’bout you yisrael? don’t you have another post to write about the jewish volunteers of machsom watch being “nasty ladies” because they oppose the idf’s travel restrictions on palestinian civilians? there’s a tisha b’av lesson learned…
1) me
No, not until they continue acting nasty by being completely one-sided and endangering my security (and yours) by interfering with the work that needs to be done in preventing 16 year old suicide bombers from getting through. And if they have complaints, let them report it not browbeat the teenage soldiers.
2) him
religious settlers are the poster children for cognitive dissonance. they condemn everyone who doesn’t see the world their way (which is practically everyone except themselves), and then cry foul and “torah violations” when other jews point out the fact that they believe, say and do abhorrent things that desecrate the name of g-d and jeopardize the security of jewish people throughout the world.
2) me
But, dear Mobius, don’t you realize that that is exactly what you are doing? And I’ll add that yes, there are, among almost 300,00 Jews living in J&S with another 200,000 in eastern Jerusalem neighborhoods who I consider wrong, fanatical and harmful to me, my ideology and themselves but that the overwhelming populace is just fine - not the stereotype you would wish. I think, given the venomous tone (oh, I did mention froth, didn’t I?) that you are engaged in ‘projection’ but don’t worry, it is only a psychological disorder and there is a cure.
3) him
i hear you rebecca, but really, which is worse: making yisrael medad look like a putz, or letting yisrael medad make all jewish people look like putzes?
3) me
Oh, come on, you don’t really look like a putz, or do you?
4) him
not only did medad irresponsibly and unfoundedly charge wonkette with being antisemitic, but he invited the entire right-wing blogosphere to uphold his misrepresentation as proof positive of the left-wing’s moral bankruptcy. in other words, medad stood reality on its head and willingly fabricated a false charge of antisemitism in order to delegitimize others whose political opinions he disagrees with (not that wonkette pays anything more than superficial attention to israel anyway).
4) me
No, I didn’t. I did not willigly fabricate. It’s there, Mob, (pronounced with a long O, as in load), you just refuse to see it because you are “Left” as in left-out, way out. Open your eyes and thou shall see.
5) him
…which effectively reinforces the belief that the charge of antisemitism is baseless and employed only to smear critics of israeli policy and/or the israel lobby.
5) me
really? no, it is very well-based (and take a look at Gawker, too).
6) him
in other words, he ran a play from abe foxman’s handbook, contributing directly to a “boy who cried wolf” impression of antisemitism that makes it all the more difficult to identify and combat real expressions of antisemitism that do truly pose a danger to the jewish community.
6) me
fox = wolf. that’s good. And when was the last time you really fought antisemitism, Mob? When I was a bit younger than you, my friends and I in Betar in 1964-65 were combatting James Madole’s National Renaissance Party in NY and preventing George Lincoln Rockwell of the American Nazi Party from speaking at Columbia University and that’s just for starters. Nu, when? where? what?
7) him
so i told him he was a putz. nu?
7) me
Nu? So you think me a putz. So feel better. I wouldn’t call you a putz, Mob. You’re not long enough.
Your comment is awaiting moderation.
—Yisrael Medad • July 25th, 2007 at 3:25 am
Mobius, I don’t think your insight into the Wonkette psyche is any better than mine or the Chicago Tribune’s, and we both thought (along with many others) that the Wonkette anti semite shout out was not satire but represented actual anti semitism in action. And the “Jewliani” nonsense has been all over the leftwing arena, not the right wing. I’m eager to fight against antisemitism on the right (e.g. Pat Buchanan, Robert Novak), why do you find it so difficult to admit anti semitism on the left?
—incorrect · July 25th, 2007 at 12:41 am
i find it difficult to admit antisemitism on the left? what are you freaking talking about? i’ve not only covered the subject ad infinitum, but i’ve collaborated on several projects to make more productive inroads into addressing the issue than simply crying that the left are a bunch of nazis. in fact, within the next week or so, we should be publishing a whole expose on and challenge to antisemitism at the world social forum.
and as per my insight into the wonkette psyche, tell me — how often do you read wonkette? it doesn’t much seem the kind of site you’d be terribly interested in. but then again, you seem to enjoy trolling websites you hate reading so…
are you even aware of the fact that gawker media is owned by a hungarian jew?
—Mobius · July 25th, 2007 at 12:53 am
Yisrael Medad can’t take a joke, Wonkette misses the high-road
by Mobius [his mirror site] • Monday, July 23rd, 2007
Jew-liani.
We’ve all seen it already, right?
Well, West Bank-based blogger Yisrael Medad hadn’t. And even if he had, he apparently wouldn’t have gotten the joke. Which is cool and all — you wouldn’t normally expect an Orthodox religious settler to get all that D.C. politico insider baseball. Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.
At any rate, in a nod to the brilliance of said video, Wonkette’s been on a roll with a tongue-in-cheek if mildly disconcerting branding of Rudy as “Jew-liani” in various posts to their blog. If anything, Medad should have accused Wonkette of serving that dish far past its expiration date. What was that, a month ago guys?
But instead, being unfamiliar with both the video and Wonkette’s naughty charm, Medad wheeled out the antisemitism charge, setting off a round of denunciations throughout the right-wing blogosphere.
Wonkette editor Ken Layne responded in poor fashion, going so far as to allude to taking possible legal action against Medad. He later followed up with a retraction and cited an inbox full of Lizard Freeper hatemail as the source of his outrage. Being familiar with the experience, I can empathize.
I wonder, had Jon Stewart made the same joke, would Medad have reacted in the same way?
~~~
If Medad really wants to go after an antisemitic website, he should investigate why it is that every time I post a comment to this article on Digg challenging Reagan-era economist Paul Craig Roberts’ assertion that the Mossad is conspiring with Bush to fake terror attacks in America, it gets voted out of existence.
Filed under Washington, On The Web, Antisemitism
21 Responses to “Yisrael Medad can’t take a joke, Wonkette misses the high-road”
1. Hey, helllooooo! It’s Tisha B’Av, atleast for those of us currently in Israel, and soon for those abroad. I came back from hearing Eicha, and THIS is what Jewschool had to add to my meditation on the state of our people on this mournful day?! What gives?
—Sof Maarav • July 23rd, 2007 at 3:37 pm
2. Are you sure that’s not the Ron Paul brigade voting you down? They’re pretty influencial on Digg.
—Ayrkain • July 23rd, 2007 at 3:51 pm
3. “you wouldn’t normally expect an Orthodox religious settler to get all that D.C. politico insider baseball. Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
I’m not feeling the love.
—incorrect • July 23rd, 2007 at 4:48 pm
4. Well, at least you spelled my name right.
Allow me thought to respond to one charge: that of support for ethnic cleansing (the rest of what you think of me is just silly nonsense - I got the joke but I didn’t think it funny). You write -”Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.” Well, I am not sure about others like me but I don’t legitimize ethnic cleansing. Don’t worry, I won’t take you court but permit me a few sentences here.
I believe that all who wish to live in this country, the Jewish, democratic state of Israel, the culmination of the Zionist movement’s effort to redeem, at this stage, the Jewish people, can and should on one condition: that they don’t try to subvert or alter what the state is supposed to be. One thing it isn’t to be is a Palestinian Arab state. If anyone has engaged in premeditated ethnic cleansing, it it the Arabs. Tel Hai in 1920, Jaffa in 1921, Petah Tikvah in 1924, 1929 in Hevron, Beer Tuviah & Hulda and in 1947-48, Gush Etzion, Bet Haaravah, Neveh Yaakov and Atarot and Jerusalem’s Old City were ethnically cleansed of Jews by Arabs. I consider a Jew and Zionist who bandies about that term in order to malign a Jew who has returned to his homeland not only stupid and incorrect factually but a gross adoption of the enemy’s propaganda line. Despite your JBS quotation below, you have attacked a person because, I am pretty sure, you don’t know me and if you had reviewed my site (as you suggested I had done with Wonkette), you would not assign me such views in your off-handed, conveniently- justifying-your-own-views manner.
Have a nice rest of Tisha B’Av.
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 3:37 am
5. Oh, and did you blog about the ethnic cleansing of Nahr el-Bared?
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 3:53 am
6. The Chicago Tribune didn’t find it so funny (some paragraphs have been deleted for brevity’s sake):
Harry Potter and Gawker’s Jewish problem
The piece is about how “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows” comes out at 2:01 a.m. Saturday in Israel, but Israeli law prohibits stores from being open on the Sabbath, or as Gawker puts it: “Head Heebs in the Holy Land are trying to keep bookstores closed at the appointed hour of the novel’s release.”
“Some stores are planning to open anyway — these are Jews, let’s remember, and a buck’s a buck — which has resulted in predictable outrage from the Adonai-adoring elements of Israeli society.”
They didn’t just go there, did they? What, is it Fun with Ages-Old Slanderous Stereotypes Week?
The piece then quotes someone from the United Torah Judaism Party (by way of an Associated Press story) slamming the Potter books’ “defective messages” and their subculture before the Gawker writer fires back: “[I]sn’t this exactly how some of us feel about, you know, the Bible and its subculture of weird, tallis-wearing followers?”
Hee hee — Orthodox Jews and other Bible readers sure are a bunch of weirdos!
—incorrect • July 24th, 2007 at 10:16 am
7. I find it offensive that on Erev Tisha B’Av of all days, you post such venomous attacks on Jews, complete with the sentence, “Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
Seeing your Chofetz Chaim green boxed message to my right as I type this, “Jewish Bloggers for Responsible Speech online” — I can only assume you put it there as a cynical joke.
Your quote from the Rav beneath below is diametrically and utterly opposed to the language of your post.
Oh right…everything’s a joke to you, Mobius.
A fabulous Tisha B’av to you as well.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 10:35 am
8. awww, what’s the matter jameel? did i show you a part of yourself you don’t like?
you know you could give me 1001 torah proofs for justifying transferring the arabs out of the territories. don’t even front.
that i would identify it as an area of expertise for religious settlers isn’t “a venomous attack.” it a matter of fact.
what, you think i’ve never slept in a caravan? what, you don’t think i have family out in those hills? i know your kind, bro… and tisha b’av of all days is davka when i should stuff it back down your throat.
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 2:27 pm
9. Gee, this is a rereading of Kamtza-BarKamtza circa 2007. For the benefit of those reading this post, I, Yisrael Medad, resident of Shiloh since 1981 (I’ll leave out all my other bio info) do not advocate ethnic cleansing, do not advocate dumping all Arabs in the sea/river/gulf or whatever (although I do bring up the subject in arguments to offset demands for ethnic cleansing of Yesha of its Jews) and do believe, in the legacy of Ze’ev Jabotinsky, that this country can have multiple communities. I argued with Rav Kahane on the subject when I was Geula Cohen’s aide and he was an MK. So, please, let’s not get irresponsible, Mobius, and let’s stick to the facts. And I do apologize for not being the stereotype fanatic, right-wing extremist you would prefer as your opponent.
—Yisrael Medad • July 24th, 2007 at 2:41 pm
10. And the righties play “miss the point” and “change the subject” once more. But Mo, you know that snide comment was their perfect excuse.
The REAL point of the article being, when an anti-Semitic canard is adopted by alleged philo-Semites on the Right… complete silence. But if a liberal were to co-opt its usage to make fun of it… Oh, where have I heard that definition before? Oh that’s right - SATIRE.
Reality just can’t compete.
—B.BarNavi • July 24th, 2007 at 2:46 pm
11. Yisrael: Give me a break. You eat Arab babies for breakfast, just as Mobius thinks you do.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 3:13 pm
12. “Guys like Medad usually have other areas of expertise, like say, halakhic proofs legitimizing ethnic cleansing.”
What an awful thing to say. I don’t understand how we can expect large groups of people with divergent religious, political and social beliefs to humanize one another if we can’t be respectful of one another on the freaking internet.
—ira • July 24th, 2007 at 3:25 pm
13. Ira: Its not an awful thing for Mobius to say; he’s lived in a caravan before.
—Jameel @ The Muqata • July 24th, 2007 at 4:09 pm
14. oh jameel, is this how you’re going to spend your day? don’t you have some olive trees to uproot, or some school children to throw rocks at, or maybe some posts to write pontificating on the utter evils of palestinian society?
maybe you’d care to explain to me which posek overturns “not by force of arms but by My hand alone…”
and i didn’t live in a caravan… i’ve just slept in a few.
speaking of which, has anyone ever told you how utterly offensive and vile the illustration on your blog’s header is?
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 4:30 pm
15. and how ’bout you yisrael? don’t you have another post to write about the jewish volunteers of machsom watch being “nasty ladies” because they oppose the idf’s travel restrictions on palestinian civilians? there’s a tisha b’av lesson learned…
religious settlers are the poster children for cognitive dissonance. they condemn everyone who doesn’t see the world their way (which is practically everyone except themselves), and then cry foul and “torah violations” when other jews point out the fact that they believe, say and do abhorrent things that desecrate the name of g-d and jeopardize the security of jewish people throughout the world.
identifying this cognitive dissonance is not an act of baseless hatred — it’s an act of love. love for g-d, love for eretz yisrael, love for am yisrael, and an expression of excruciating pain at the sight of my fellow yidn conducting themselves in a way that harms all of us.
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 4:52 pm
16. hey mobius– having met you, I do believe that your critique comes from a place of love.
however, I don’t think that spirit is coming across in this comment thread.
and that’s when people shut down and stop listening and start trying to win the debate instead of to learn.
It’s the afternoon of tisha b’av– ahavat chinam and all that. let’s make it constructive.
—rebecca m • July 24th, 2007 at 5:38 pm
17. i hear you rebecca, but really, which is worse: making yisrael medad look like a putz, or letting yisrael medad make all jewish people look like putzes?
—Mobius • July 24th, 2007 at 11:09 pm
18. here - let me try to reframe this:
right now, there’s a strong sentiment on both the right and left that the charge of antisemitism is a baseless accusation used to silence criticism of israeli policy and the israel lobby. the walt & mearshimer paper is just one example evidencing this sentiment’s entry into mainstream american thinking.
it’s obvious to anyone who reads wonkette that they were making fun of right-wing antisemites by calling giuliani “jew-liani.” yet not only did medad irresponsibly and unfoundedly charge wonkette with being antisemitic, but he invited the entire right-wing blogosphere to uphold his misrepresentation as proof positive of the left-wing’s moral bankruptcy.
in other words, medad stood reality on its head and willingly fabricated a false charge of antisemitism in order to delegitimize others whose political opinions he disagrees with (not that wonkette pays anything more than superficial attention to israel anyway).
he has thus engaged in a propaganda strategy that has earned him a lot of web traffic from the neocon right, but which effectively reinforces the belief that the charge of antisemitism is baseless and employed only to smear critics of israeli policy and/or the israel lobby.
in other words, he ran a play from abe foxman’s handbook, contributing directly to a “boy who cried wolf” impression of antisemitism that makes it all the more difficult to identify and combat real expressions of antisemitism that do truly pose a danger to the jewish community.
thus, through his actions, medad has contributed to the deterioration of jewish security as a whole.
so i told him he was a putz. nu?
—Mobius • July 25th, 2007 at 12:18 am
19. Mobius, I don’t think your insight into the Wonkette psyche is any better than mine or the Chicago Tribune’s, and we both thought (along with many others) that the Wonkette anti semite shout out was not satire but represented actual anti semitism in action. And the “Jewliani” nonsense has been all over the leftwing arena, not the right wing. I’m eager to fight against antisemitism on the right (e.g. Pat Buchanan, Robert Novak), why do you find it so difficult to admit anti semitism on the left?
—incorrect • July 25th, 2007 at 12:41 am
20. i find it difficult to admit antisemitism on the left? what are you freaking talking about? i’ve not only covered the subject ad infinitum, but i’ve collaborated on several projects to make more productive inroads into addressing the issue than simply crying that the left are a bunch of nazis. in fact, within the next week or so, we should be publishing a whole expose on and challenge to antisemitism at the world social forum.
and as per my insight into the wonkette psyche, tell me — how often do you read wonkette? it doesn’t much seem the kind of site you’d be terribly interested in. but then again, you seem to enjoy trolling websites you hate reading so…
are you even aware of the fact that gawker media is owned by a hungarian jew?
—Mobius • July 25th, 2007 at 12:53 am
21. Mobius, to answer your question, I use to read Wonkette fairly often when she first started, but she ultimately grew boring and I stopped. Meanwhile I went to your site regarding you objecting to anti semitism of the left and I saw a reference to a conference. I’ll repeat the question, who are the leftist anti semites you would publicly call out (and I don’t mean fringe crazies) - you call me the troll but I’m willing to identify “mainstream” rightists as antisemites because I’m willing to apply my standards consistently whether with reference to rightists or leftists. I challenge you to do the same - are you covering for anti semitic leftists, or are you willing to name them?
—incorrect • July 25th, 2007 at 2:47 am
22. Good morning to all.
There’s a lot to respond to but as I don’t want Mobius to choke on the froth coming out of his mouth, I’ll be gentle.
I know that Mobius doesn’t know me but as I serve for him as a symbol of the target of his hatred, what can I do? He needs me. He needs me to be who I am not because that justifies his outlook and anger and uncotrollable urges (no, I am not accusing you of being a wife-beater).
So, let’s make some comments:
1) him
and how ’bout you yisrael? don’t you have another post to write about the jewish volunteers of machsom watch being “nasty ladies” because they oppose the idf’s travel restrictions on palestinian civilians? there’s a tisha b’av lesson learned…
1) me
No, not until they continue acting nasty by being completely one-sided and endangering my security (and yours) by interfering with the work that needs to be done in preventing 16 year old suicide bombers from getting through. And if they have complaints, let them report it not browbeat the teenage soldiers.
2) him
religious settlers are the poster children for cognitive dissonance. they condemn everyone who doesn’t see the world their way (which is practically everyone except themselves), and then cry foul and “torah violations” when other jews point out the fact that they believe, say and do abhorrent things that desecrate the name of g-d and jeopardize the security of jewish people throughout the world.
2) me
But, dear Mobius, don’t you realize that that is exactly what you are doing? And I’ll add that yes, there are, among almost 300,00 Jews living in J&S with another 200,000 in eastern Jerusalem neighborhoods who I consider wrong, fanatical and harmful to me, my ideology and themselves but that the overwhelming populace is just fine - not the stereotype you would wish. I think, given the venomous tone (oh, I did mention froth, didn’t I?) that you are engaged in ‘projection’ but don’t worry, it is only a psychological disorder and there is a cure.
3) him
i hear you rebecca, but really, which is worse: making yisrael medad look like a putz, or letting yisrael medad make all jewish people look like putzes?
3) me
Oh, come on, you don’t really look like a putz, or do you?
4) him
not only did medad irresponsibly and unfoundedly charge wonkette with being antisemitic, but he invited the entire right-wing blogosphere to uphold his misrepresentation as proof positive of the left-wing’s moral bankruptcy. in other words, medad stood reality on its head and willingly fabricated a false charge of antisemitism in order to delegitimize others whose political opinions he disagrees with (not that wonkette pays anything more than superficial attention to israel anyway).
4) me
No, I didn’t. I did not willigly fabricate. It’s there, Mob, (pronounced with a long O, as in load), you just refuse to see it because you are “Left” as in left-out, way out. Open your eyes and thou shall see.
5) him
…which effectively reinforces the belief that the charge of antisemitism is baseless and employed only to smear critics of israeli policy and/or the israel lobby.
5) me
really? no, it is very well-based (and take a look at Gawker, too).
6) him
in other words, he ran a play from abe foxman’s handbook, contributing directly to a “boy who cried wolf” impression of antisemitism that makes it all the more difficult to identify and combat real expressions of antisemitism that do truly pose a danger to the jewish community.
6) me
fox = wolf. that’s good. And when was the last time you really fought antisemitism, Mob? When I was a bit younger than you, my friends and I in Betar in 1964-65 were combatting James Madole’s National Renaissance Party in NY and preventing George Lincoln Rockwell of the American Nazi Party from speaking at Columbia University and that’s just for starters. Nu, when? where? what?
7) him
so i told him he was a putz. nu?
7) me
Nu? So you think me a putz. So feel better. I wouldn’t call you a putz, Mob. You’re not long enough.
Your comment is awaiting moderation.
—Yisrael Medad • July 25th, 2007 at 3:25 am
Mobius, I don’t think your insight into the Wonkette psyche is any better than mine or the Chicago Tribune’s, and we both thought (along with many others) that the Wonkette anti semite shout out was not satire but represented actual anti semitism in action. And the “Jewliani” nonsense has been all over the leftwing arena, not the right wing. I’m eager to fight against antisemitism on the right (e.g. Pat Buchanan, Robert Novak), why do you find it so difficult to admit anti semitism on the left?
—incorrect · July 25th, 2007 at 12:41 am
i find it difficult to admit antisemitism on the left? what are you freaking talking about? i’ve not only covered the subject ad infinitum, but i’ve collaborated on several projects to make more productive inroads into addressing the issue than simply crying that the left are a bunch of nazis. in fact, within the next week or so, we should be publishing a whole expose on and challenge to antisemitism at the world social forum.
and as per my insight into the wonkette psyche, tell me — how often do you read wonkette? it doesn’t much seem the kind of site you’d be terribly interested in. but then again, you seem to enjoy trolling websites you hate reading so…
are you even aware of the fact that gawker media is owned by a hungarian jew?
—Mobius · July 25th, 2007 at 12:53 am
And If You missed the Gawker Attempt at Being Funny and...
What Just A Few years Will Do
Temple Mount Makes CBS News (and more)
Israel police Tuesday permitted a limited number of Jewish worshippers to ascend Jerusalem's Temple Mount, the site of the two ancient Jewish temples that according to Jewish tradition were both destroyed on this day, in 586 B.C. and 70 A.D. It's Judaism's holiest shrine, but it's also holy to Muslims, and therefore, reports Jablinowitz, it's considered the powder keg of the Middle East. A group called the Temple Mount faithful prayed nearby, complaining that not more Jews were permitted to enter the Mount.
Source.
=====================
And Uri Orbach, in his satirical way, deals with the fundamentals of the issue. Excerpts:-
Unfortunately the Temple was destroyed in July-August. Two thousand years later, secular Israel is too busy during these two months to remember anything about what happened so long ago. In the midst of the summer break and on the beach, the Ninth of Av creeps up with stubble on its face and that Temple where cows were slaughtered, as if there were no quinoa in the world.
The Ninth of Av is not a popular day in Israel. Israeli society likes to celebrate, including Israel's festivals, but fast days are no small headache. Israelis like to think that the Ninth of Av is only related to the past, to some distant temple, which they do not particularly miss and certainly do not wish to see reappear all of a sudden.
And then, on a seemingly normal summer's eve, TV sets start airing black-and-white films with no commercials in between. Suddenly there are pictures of Jerusalem and religious people everywhere, wearing sneakers and hair on their faces as they sit on the ground at the Western Wall.
"What's going on? Who died? Oh yes, the Temple, yes the Temple, and I for a brief moment thought something happened."
What has remained of this Jewish tradition within the pace of Israeli life? Just leftovers. The Temple is perceived as the symbol of religious rule in which no one is interested in nowadays. Jerusalem on the whole is increasingly being distanced from Tel Aviv, which lives around the clock. Add to this the fact that schools undergo renovations during July-August and you'll understand why children do not even encounter the Ninth of Av within the mandatory education curriculum.
Had Israel's education focused on healthy nationalism, the understanding "of remembering the secret of redemption" would have perhaps appealed to more people. With the destruction of the Temple, hundreds of thousands of our people perished. True, it was long ago, but beyond national destruction, a massacre of our people also took place.
Since then we have experienced sacrifices and a Holocaust, massacres and the Inquisition. However, the destruction of the Temple symbolized the beginning and the reason for the painful exile that culminated in the Holocaust of European Jewry. The Holocaust was part of the deportation process of an entire people.
So despite the Ninth of Av occurring in the summer, there is national, religious and Zionist significance in remembering what happened to us as a people just 2,000 years ago. This is not about slogans and symbols of memory alone, but about education. Israeli society finds it difficult to remember events that occurred only last summer and two summers ago. To ask it to remember a sultry event of destruction and holocaust, plus a fast, plus lamentations – that's going too far.
The prevalent feeling is that the Ninth of Av is a matter for religious Jews. It's a good thing we have them so that they can mourn for us too. Even visiting the Temple Mount, which is our national right, not a religious one, is consistently portrayed as a terrible headache, so you come to us now with your Temple and all its geopolitical ramifications, and with the Arabs who are likely to become terribly angry?
======================
Majadele cedes role in Mughrabi Gate project to cabinet
The cabinet yesterday set up a ministerial committee to oversee the Temple Mount's Mughrabi Gate project, thereby effectively depriving Culture Minister Ghaleb Majadele, who previously had ministerial responsibility for the work, of this job.
The decision follows Majadele's tour of the area a few days ago during which he reportedly ordered archaeological excavations at the site to stop.
However, both Majadele and the Israel Antiquities Authority, which is carrying out the dig, deny that he gave such an order. The authority said that the work, which is a necessary step to replacing a collapsed ramp leading to the Mughrabi Gate from the Western Wall plaza, was halted due to planning problems and not the minister's orders.
The ministerial committee will be headed by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. Majadele, who said he welcomed the decision, will be one of its other members, along with Public Security Minister Avi Dichter and the present and former Jerusalem affairs ministers, Rafi Eitan and Jacob Edery.
The ministerial committee is expected to approve a plan prepared by an interministerial committee, under which the collapsed ramp will be replaced by a bridge, and the space under the bridge will be used to expand the women's prayer area at the Western Wall. The plan will apparently be submitted to the Jerusalem planning commission for approval next Tuesday.
Brit Hume Mentions "L'Affair Wonkette"
Meanwhile the Wonkette blog is being taken to task for a posting that referred to "Rudy Jew-liani" in an interview with the "Jew York Times."
A rival blogger observed — "Wonkette, that foul-mouthed but titillating blogger of Washington foibles, seems to have gone anti-Semitic."
Wonkette has demanded an apology and implied legal action if one is not forthcoming.
Source
It's in a paragraph entitled "Keep It Clean" but there's no direct link to me.
And OrthoMom.
L'Chayim! - Shiloh Wine
Shiloh's boutique winery
By Daniel Rogov
By Daniel Rogov
Wine and Spirits / Established in the Shiloh settlement [that should be community] of the Shomron region, with vineyards at an altitude of 700 to 900 meters above sea level, this boutique winery has released its first wines from the 2005 vintage. Production in 2005 was of 5,000 bottles and in 2006, 17,500 bottles were produced from Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Chardonnay grapes. The winery is currently releasing wines in an upper-level Masada and a mid-level Herodion series. To purchase the wines, contact the winery directly at (09) 792-1292.
Gvaot, Merlot, 2005: Dark royal purple in color, with orange reflections. Reflecting 18 months in barriques with spicy oak and mouth-coating, near-sweet tannins in fine balance with minty, herb-scented cherry and berry flavors, those with overlays of milk chocolate and mint. Full-bodied, with fine tannins and a caressing finish. Drink now-2010. NIS 85. Score 90. K
Gvaot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Herodion, 2005: A medium- to full-bodied blend of 85 percent Cabernet Sauvignon and 15 percent Merlot, reflecting sweet and spicy cedar wood from its 14 months of development in French oak, the wood in good balance with soft, gently mouth-coating tannins and fruits. Medium- to full-bodied, aromatic and showing deep currant, black cherry and dark red fruits. Finishes with a touch of heat but that will integrate nicely given time. Best starting in 2009. NIS 85. Score 88. K
Gavot, Red, Herodion, 2005: Dark garnet in color, medium-bodied, with soft tannins and gentle oak integrating nicely, this blend of 60 percent Cabernet Sauvignon and 40 percent Merlot was aged in French oak for 12 months. Aromatic, round and soft, with appealing aromas and flavors of blackberry and purple plum fruits, those supported by hints of spice and chocolate. Drink now or in the next year or two. NIS 75. Score 87. K
Gvaot, Chardonnay-Cabernet Sauvignon, Masada, 2005: Not a typographic error - truly a blend of Chardonnay and Cabernet Sauvignon (75 and 25 percent respectively, the Cabernet with minimal skin contact yielding a rather unique blanc de noirs. Full-bodied, with a texture of cream and glycerin, showing a surprising but appealing array of citrus fruits, pear and wild berries. A complex and "interesting" wine but not one for more than short-term cellaring. Drink now. NIS 75. Score 86. K
Tuesday, July 24, 2007
Be Careful If You Dress as a Female Muslim
This report has great potential for the fashion world, or for the sex worker trade:-
In Mombasa, Kenya, the coastal city's "twilight ladies" have ditched their skimpy "uniforms" for the much more conservative buibui—a billowing, ankle-length gown with head covering that Muslim women in the region wear. Sex workers say it lets them hide their identity, avoid arrest, and look respectable.
Unsurprisingly, Muslim women who cover themselves head to toe with the buibui aren't exactly happy with this fashion makeover.
More Links
Memeorandum
Damian Penny
Gina Cobb
Yid With Lid
Atlas Shrugs
Debbie Schlussel
Pajamas Media
among others.
Again, thanks to all.
=================
and more:-
Jewess
Muqata
Boker Tov
and Mobius is bashing me
===============
Chicago Trib
Luke Ford
Digg
Damian Penny
Gina Cobb
Yid With Lid
Atlas Shrugs
Debbie Schlussel
Pajamas Media
among others.
Again, thanks to all.
=================
and more:-
Jewess
Muqata
Boker Tov
and Mobius is bashing me
===============
Chicago Trib
Luke Ford
Digg
Tisha B'Av Mincha at the "Rav Goren Minyan"
The "Rav Goren Minyan" is the code name for the Mincha (afternoon) service held in the Machkema Building adjacent to the Western Wall on Tisha B'Av and Yom Kippur (the Border Police use it all the time). Rav Shlomo Goren zatzal established a synagague there officially in 1977 after some 9 years of it being located in a second-floor room of the Omariyah school [first picture at that site] located on the northern wall of the Temple Mount. Although the window was small, I recall it being a magnificent view as the entire Har Habayit area was opened to us, including Second Temple flagstones that were eventually covered up by trees by the Waqf.
The Machkema building abuts into the Temple Mount but one fooor up above the colonnaded portion all along the Western Wall. So, while in the two rooms one is "inside" the Temple Mount, one is also not at the esplanade level.
Here are some pictures:
1) General view from the second hall looking in (it seats maybe 15 and can get crowded and does get very hot)

2) View from the rear looking east

3) Me at the back door.

4) The sign noting that one is passing the Kotel "on through to the other side"

5) The outer room (in the left-upper corner you can see one of the three windows facing the Temple Mount. They are heavily protected with mesh to prevent things coming in or people going out ;>). One needs get close to get a good view of the esplanade below).

6) My two granddaughters and son-in-law looking out.

7) My two granddaughters and myself

8) And a special bonus. Remember to Police Station and Magen David office at the back of the Kotel plaza? No more. There are digs there now:-
The Machkema building abuts into the Temple Mount but one fooor up above the colonnaded portion all along the Western Wall. So, while in the two rooms one is "inside" the Temple Mount, one is also not at the esplanade level.
Here are some pictures:
1) General view from the second hall looking in (it seats maybe 15 and can get crowded and does get very hot)

2) View from the rear looking east

3) Me at the back door.

4) The sign noting that one is passing the Kotel "on through to the other side"

5) The outer room (in the left-upper corner you can see one of the three windows facing the Temple Mount. They are heavily protected with mesh to prevent things coming in or people going out ;>). One needs get close to get a good view of the esplanade below).

6) My two granddaughters and son-in-law looking out.

7) My two granddaughters and myself

8) And a special bonus. Remember to Police Station and Magen David office at the back of the Kotel plaza? No more. There are digs there now:-
Nasty Ladies
Machsom Watch, an NGO [a radical, progressive, left-wing advocacy group] that monitors IDF checkpoints in the West Bank, said it was distressed by the IDF's call for former servicemen to come from abroad to serve in the territories.
"A large number of the checkpoints that are called "seam-line" are actually found deep inside the territories and far from the Green Line, and these checkpoints harm the Palestinians' quality of life," the organization said in a statement. "Therefore Machsom Watch is distressed by the fact that volunteers from abroad with good intentions to defend the State of Israel are sent to do missions that do not promote security but actually harm it."
Source.
Why Not Visit?
David Golinkin, president of the Schechter Institute of Jewish Studies in Jerusalem, writes that we should:-
Visit the Temple Mount!
=====================
Stephen G. Rosenberg, a Fellow of the Albright Institute of Archaeological Research, Jerusalem, is in doubt over whether:-
Should Jews build the Third Temple?
Visit the Temple Mount!
On Tisha Be'av our hearts turn to the Temple Mount, the site of the First and Second Temples, whose destruction we mourn every year. Therefore, it behooves us to ask: Does Jewish law permit us to go up to the Temple Mount today? This may seem like an esoteric question, but it has far-reaching political consequences.
Shortly after the Six Day War in June 1967, the Chief Rabbinate posted a large sign at the entrance to the Temple Mount stating that, according to Jewish Law, it is forbidden to enter the Temple Mount. This prohibition was reiterated by chief rabbis Shlomo Amar and Yona Metzger in January 2005. As a result, many Jews, especially the Orthodox, have not entered the Temple Mount area for the past 40 years.
But does Jewish law really forbid Jews to go up to the Temple Mount, our holiest site?
The most important source is found in the Mishna (Kelim 1:6-9): "There are 10 degrees of holiness. The Land of Israel is holier than any other land...The Temple Mount… The Rampart [an area of ten cubits surrounding the Temple itself]… The Court of Women… The Court of Israelites is still more holy…".
Halachic authorities have tried to determine if these 10 degrees of holiness still exist today. The reply, however, is dependent upon a disagreement in the Talmud (Shavuot 16a) and upon a difference of opinion between Maimonides and the Ra'avad of Posquieres (Bet Habehira 6:14-16). According to Maimonides, the original holiness that King Solomon bestowed upon the First Temple "was holy for its time and for the future." But, according to the Ra'avad, the First Temple "was holy for its time and not for the future...".
Many authorities have ruled, on the basis of the Talmud and Maimonides, that it is still forbidden for a Jew to enter the Temple Mount today "lest he wander into the forbidden area in the Rampart or in the Court [of the Israelites] which is punishable by karet [premature death] even today... and today we have all contracted ritual impurity by having been in contact with a corpse."
HOWEVER, IT appears that these halachic authorities have been overly stringent, and that there are many reasons to allow entry into parts of the Temple Mount:
1. There is much doubt in the Talmud over whether the Temple Mount "was holy for its time and for the future," or not. There is also a doubt if Halacha follows Maimonides or the Ra'avad. Furthermore, even if Halacha follows Maimonides, there are a number of reasons to allow entry into parts of the Temple Mount.
2. We know from many sources that Jews continued to enter and even pray on the Temple Mount from the 1st to the 15th centuries. Many important rabbis of the Mishna entered the Temple Mount area in the first and second centuries.
The Christian Pilgrim of Bordeaux, who was in Jerusalem in the year 333 CE, relates that the Jews used to come to the Temple Mount every year on the Ninth of Av in order to recite lamentations over the Temple ruins and rend their garments.
Ben-Zion Dinaburg proved that there was a Jewish "house of prayer and study" on the Temple Mount between the 7th and 11th centuries. Maimonides himself paid a visit to the Temple Mount on the 14th of October, 1165. Rabbi Menahem Hameiri of Provence (1249-1315) testifies: "And the simple custom is to enter [the Temple Mount], according to what we have heard."
3. As Maimonides and others have stressed, those who have contracted ritual impurity from a corpse are not forbidden to enter the entire Temple Mount area. They are forbidden only to enter the Rampart and the Court of Women, and the serious penalty of karet applies only to those who enter the Court of the Israelites and beyond.
IF WE CAN define the sanctified section of the Temple itself on what is today called "the Temple Mount," we will be able to determine where it is permissible to enter. Indeed, Rabbi David ibn Zimra (1479-1573) and at least 10 modern rabbis - including Rabbis Hayyim Hirschenson, Hayyim David Halevi, Shlomo Goren, Yosef Kafah, and Shlomo Riskin - have ruled that it is permissible to enter parts of the Temple Mount today.
The main sources for the boundaries of the Temple during the Second Temple period are the Mishna, tractate Midot and Josephus (Wars 5, 5, 1-6 and Antiquities 15, 11, 3-7).
There are many contradictions between these three sources, but almost unanimous agreement among rabbis and archeologists regarding two basic points:
A. The Temple Mount today is much larger than the Temple Mount described by Josephus or the Mishna. It is clear that the entire southern area south of the Mughrabi Gate, and all of the northern area north of the raised platform around the Dome of the Rock, were added by King Herod and are therefore not included in the sanctified area of the Temple Mount mentioned in the Mishna.
B. The huge rock underneath the Dome of the Rock is the "Foundation Stone" which was located under the Holy of Holies; or it is the foundation of the Altar in the Temple.
WITHOUT entering into detailed measurements, it is permissible to enter the area south of the Mughrabi Gate and near the Aksa Mosque and the area north of the raised platform surrounding the Dome of the Rock.
On the other hand, one should not enter that raised platform at all. On the west, one should stay close to the Western Wall, and on the east, one should stay close to the eastern wall.
Finally, there is an urgent practical reason for Jews to enter the Temple Mount area today. In 1967, the Israeli government gave the Muslim Wakf control of the Temple Mount. Since then the Wakf has made a concerted effort to obliterate the remnants of Jewish antiquities on the Temple Mount.
Furthermore, when the Wakf expanded the Aksa Mosque in 1999, they illegally removed 250 truckloads of dirt containing thousands of years of Jewish and non-Jewish antiquities. Bar-Ilan University's Dr. Gabi Barkai, a member of the Committee Against the Destruction of Antiquities on the Temple Mount, and numerous volunteers are now sifting through this dirt and recovering thousands of ancient artifacts. The Wakf was able to get away with this plunder because Jews do not visit the Temple Mount, and they don't visit the Temple Mount because of the strict rabbinic rulings cited above.
Indeed, just last week it was reported that the Wakf has begun new "repairs" on the Temple Mount which will no doubt destroy more archeological treasures.
Thus it is permissible to enter parts of the Temple Mount; and I believe we should make a concerted effort to do so in order to emphasize that the Temple Mount is our holiest site and cannot be plundered.
=====================
Stephen G. Rosenberg, a Fellow of the Albright Institute of Archaeological Research, Jerusalem, is in doubt over whether:-
Should Jews build the Third Temple?
Traditionally the Temple Mount Faithful attempt to set up a foundation stone for the Third Temple on Tisha Be'av, and the police routinely prevent them from doing so. The occasion for this street theater is the anniversary of the destruction of the First Temple in 586 BCE and that of the Second Temple in 70 CE, both said to have occurred on the same calendar date.
It is certainly right that the date be commemorated; but would rebuilding the Temple be an appropriate act for the State of Israel today?
Assuming there were no Dome of the Rock and no Muslim presence on the Temple Mount, no Wakf and no Aksa Mosque, the pressure to rebuild the Temple would be enormous - but would it, in historical terms, be sound?
The last time such an opportunity occurred was in the time of Julian the Apostate, in 362 CE. That Roman Emperor, who succeeded Constantine, reversed his predecessor's decision to turn the empire into a Christian state and returned to the former pagan religions, which were permissive of other cults, including the Jewish one. It seems that he gave permission for the Temple to be rebuilt, and then went off to fight his enemies.
In Jerusalem work commenced on reconstructing the altar, but hardly had a few stones been put one on another, when a massive earthquake hit the area and the work collapsed. Worse still, Julian was killed in Persia and his place was taken by the Emperor Jovian, who reinstalled Christianity as the official religion. Any hope of rebuilding the Temple ceased, never to return.
IN 638 CE, the hordes of Islam conquered Jerusalem and by 692 the Caliph Abd al-Malik had completed the Dome of the Rock, which stood on the mountain inviolate for the following 1,315 years.
During the Crusader years it was converted to Christian use, and most Crusaders thought it had been built originally as the Temple of Solomon, but it was not changed structurally and returned to the Muslims on expulsion of the Crusaders in 1187. However, it did not return as a mosque, as it had never been one.
As the Dome was not a mosque, why did Abd al-Malik build it? It may be that he was attempting to set up a place of pilgrimage in competition to Mecca, which was controlled by his rival, Ibn al-Zubayr, but it seems more likely that, probably advised by an ex-Jewish companion, he recognized the historic significance of the site and in particular of the rock, the foundation stone, the even shetiya, that carried so much religious baggage. It was the scene of the Mihrab of Dawood (shrine of David) and the Bayit al-Makdis of Sulayman (Temple of Solomon) so al-Malik may have selected the site as a kind of location of ultimate holiness, maybe even for the Day of the Last Judgement.
The unique design of the building, a circular dome over an octagonal base, emphasized its concentration on the central feature, the Rock. Unlike any mosque, the building had no directional focus and was entered by four doorways, one to each of the cardinal points, as if to encourage access to persons or, indeed, their souls coming from the four corners of the earth.
LATER THE Muslims observed that the Rock was the mythical arrival and departure point of Mohammed on his white steed Buraq, but Abd al-Malik had recognized the precedence of Solomon and even Abraham on the site.
This makes it clear that the sanctity of the site stems from its Jewish origins, though the Muslims, of course, claim Abraham as one of their own, and venerate Solomon as divine. Now, even if the Muslim attitude would be to allow a Jewish presence, and even a rebuilding on the site, would it be in the Jewish interest to proceed with a third Temple?
WHEN HEROD decided to rebuild the Temple in 19 BCE, 18 years after having been handed the throne by the Romans, there must have been much trepidation among the population, the priests and others, about his intentions. He managed to calm their fears by employing only priests on the Temple itself and by enabling the Korban Tamid, the daily sacrifices, to continue without interruption.
The resources that he used were vast and would have pleased the local craftsmen, who were provided with employment for many years. The end result pleased even his rabbinic critics, though well after the event: "Whoever has not seen Herod's building has never seen anything beautiful," they crowed.
This was a surprising reaction, as very few rabbis were yet around to see the Temple in its glory. Additionally, modern reconstructions show a rather high, lopsided building with an overblown classical front sitting on a vast platform that completely ignores the beautiful mountain it covered. Such an oversize terrace must have intimidated anyone venturing on to it.
The huge expanse of uncovered space would not be conducive to our weather, be it sunshine or rain. For all its glory, the structure was not completed until 60 CE, well after the death of Herod, and it only stood another six years before its service was embroiled in the revolt against the Romans.
So what did Herod's great work really achieve? Did it achieve unity among the Jewish people? Did it achieve harmony between our different factions? Did it achieve reconciliation with our governors, the Romans, who admired the structure built on classical lines by their favorite Jewish ruler? Did its presence give us protection against our enemies or absolution for our sins?
QUITE THE contrary. The daily sacrifices were used by the zealots to exclude the offering of the Roman emperor, which led to reprisals and insults by the occupying army. Different parties saw different ways of resolving the crisis, but could find no unanimity among themselves. The High Priest, who might have been a potential leader, was just another political appointment, as he had been under the Seleucids; even his sacred clothing was held hostage in the hands of the Roman governor. The priests were divided in their loyalties and unable to conduct the divine service in a dignified manner.
When it came to the actual revolt in Jerusalem, things turned perilous, and civil war reigned. The zealots, led by John of Gischala, got the upper hand and the peace party was unable to stop them. Another zealot leader, Simon bar Giora, was welcomed into the city to oppose Gischala, but the two soon joined together against the moderates. That union did not last and within a short time there were three "gangster" parties (in the words of Josephus) who burnt each other's grain supplies, not realizing that they would all suffer in the end.
Only the Romans could benefit from the chaos, and so they did, in spite of the brave efforts put up by the separate parties, one of whom used the Temple precinct for a heroic, if vain, last stand. The magnificent Herodian Temple, as finally completed, had stood for only 10 years.
THIS WAS not so different from the vicissitudes of the First Temple. Solomon completed it with forced labor shifts, directed by his chief taskmaster, Adoniram. On Solomon's death, the majority of the tribes revolted against his successor Rehoboam, put the hated Adoniram to death by stoning, and set up the Northern Kingdom, which had no use for the Temple.
In the south, the Temple was sacked by Pharaoh Shishak in about 925 BCE, and all its gold was stripped away and taken to Egypt. Rehoboam was forced to present to the people shields of polished brass to simulate the looted metal. The golden glory of Solomon's Temple had lasted for just 40 years.
Not long after, king Asa had to use the replaced Temple treasures to bribe Ben-Hadad of Aram (Syria) to help him fight against Baasa, king of Northern Israel. Worse than all that loss of treasure was the fact that the First Temple, as described in our sacred books, became the focus of idol worship in the reigns of the Judahite kings Asa, Jehoram, Amaziah and the queen Athaliah, who gave its treasures to the House of Baal.
The timely restoration under Hezekiah was undermined by his son Manasseh, and the renaissance initiated by Josiah was sabotaged by the desecration of his successors that culminated in defeat by the Babylonians in 597 BCE, followed by destruction 11 years later.
What happened to the glory of the First Temple? It lasted 40 years. The Second Temple never achieved glory until its rebuilding by Herod, and that lasted 10 years.
Will a Third Temple fare any better? The records of history are against it.
Monday, July 23, 2007
Ken From Wonkette Replies
Hi Yisrael,
Thanks for responding and at least looking at the clip.
Nobody has threatened you with legal action. I'm an editor, not a lawyer, and any stuff like this I forward to the bosses and lawyers, obviously.
Well, I am now tired of explaining humor/irony to people looking to be outraged by everything, so I will say good-bye.
The Little Green Football nuts (*) have apparently moved on to their next crusade so my inbox is now cleansed of their nonsense.
Ken
Well,
a) read like a threat to me. here, you reread this line:
Send us the link when you do and I'll send that to our lawyers and that will be the end of that.
To me that meant: "if you don't apologize and post it, our lawyers will handle it and you know what that can mean".
and
b) one blog's nonsense is another blog's cogent argumentation based on facts and rational analysis.
==========
(*)
See what he means.
Wonkette Threatens Me With Legal Action
I posted the other day in response to a Wonkette item and I asked: Wonkette Antisemitic?
Well, a Ken Layne from Wonkette wrote me the following:
Here's my reply:
Keep tuned.
Well, a Ken Layne from Wonkette wrote me the following:
You know, it's kind of poor manners to go accusing people of being
antisemitic based on nothing more than you being too lazy to read the site and know any of the references.
But since you don't, and since you so thoughtlessly and wantonly libel our editors and the owners and stockholders of our company, I will direct you to the specific reference from the day before, which just happens to be a viral video on YouTube that everybody in politics is talking about:
http://wonkette.com/politics/jew_liani-dept%27/finally-a-campaign-ad-for-the-fascist-in-us-all-275420.php
You can go ahead and apologize on your site now. Send us the link when you do and I'll send that to our lawyers and that will be the end of that.
Here's my reply:
Hi Ken,
Being fairly obedient, I watched the clip.
If I understand you and Wonkette correctly, you thought it was cute/clever or whatever, to borrow a term, "Jew--liani", from that clip and, without any comment about its specific ethnic frame of reference, slap it up on a new post the following day. And someone at Wonkette thought that it was so cute/clever or whatever, that they added "Jew York Times" for increased effect, if I am following the thinking over at Wonkette.
Well, I don't think the way you think. I think it was the grossest of manners on Wonkette's part to repeat the "Jew-liani" bit. Even you, now, seem to admit that it was, at the very least, a slur. But where does the "Jew York Times" come in? Are we now in a Jesse Jackson redux of that 1984 "Hymietown" remark? I'm sure you know what I am referring to but since proper blog manners are to send links, try this one: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/clinton/frenzy/jackson.htm
You'll note that Jackson made an emotional apology in the end of the affair.
I reviewed my blog post. I am pretty sure I did not malign, defame, libel or otherwise use any deprecatory term and phrase that is any worse that anything that appears on your site. Here it is again:-
"Wonkette" Antisemitic?
Wonkette, that foul-mouthed but titilating blogger of Washington foibles, seems to have gone anti-semitic. Editor Alex Pareene and Interns Nick Mueller and Lauren Spohrer may be responsible for this post which refers to someone they call "Rudy-Jew-liani " who gave an interview to the "Jew York Times".
Anybody for bonking Wonkette?
You'll see that I placed a question mark at the headline. That means asking, not stating a fact. I emphasized that Wonkette "seems" to have gone anti-semitic. That means perhaps, or maybe. (You didn't really, did you?)
So, to roundup:
I don't think I'll apologize. I think Wonkette needs to. I think that the "public square" can tolerate a lot: foul language, innuendos, etc. I don't think a responsible blog need repeat what I would consider an antisemitic reference. The way it appears on your site, there is no reference to the YouTube clip. Only if you click on 'more', is it revealed. That is an error, I think, on your part. Anyone reading the post as it appears sees something any normal, and I stress normal, person would assume to be a sliding pattern into a slur based on religion, especially that reference to the Jew York Times. Here's one way it was used derogatively: http://www.seeingtheforest.com/archives/2005/12/repubicans_drop.htm
So, in summary, let me know what your lawyers think after carefully reviewing my response. As for any end, I'm patient.
Keep tuned.
My Wonkette Post Is Being Linked
American Thinker. (here)
Maverick News. (here)
Carl at IsraelMatzav. (here)
Jawa Report. (here)
And check out LGF.
Maverick News. (here)
Carl at IsraelMatzav. (here)
Jawa Report. (here)
And check out LGF.
War is [A Drunken] Hell
'WWI spirits' dug up in Macedonia
A remote Macedonian mountain village is at the centre of a treasure hunt for bottles of what is thought to be vintage cognac from World War I. Farmers in Gradesnica have unearthed what they say are cases of spirits from trenches once used by French soldiers.
Valued at thousands of euros a bottle, it is said to have survived a German shell strike that killed many soldiers.
The liquor could fetch at least 5,000 euros (£3,360) per bottle, according to Skopje University expert Mihail Petkov. "I don't think wine would stay drinkable after 90 years so I think it's probably cognac, as its quality improves with age. People have been coming from France to look for it."
He explained that French wine-producers once had to pay a military tax, which they met by supplying wine and spirits directly to the army.
In 1916, Gradesnica was at the heart of fighting during a drive by Allied forces to bolster Serbia and halt the advance of the Central Powers' troops.
Story from BBC NEWS
A remote Macedonian mountain village is at the centre of a treasure hunt for bottles of what is thought to be vintage cognac from World War I. Farmers in Gradesnica have unearthed what they say are cases of spirits from trenches once used by French soldiers.
Valued at thousands of euros a bottle, it is said to have survived a German shell strike that killed many soldiers.
The liquor could fetch at least 5,000 euros (£3,360) per bottle, according to Skopje University expert Mihail Petkov. "I don't think wine would stay drinkable after 90 years so I think it's probably cognac, as its quality improves with age. People have been coming from France to look for it."
He explained that French wine-producers once had to pay a military tax, which they met by supplying wine and spirits directly to the army.
In 1916, Gradesnica was at the heart of fighting during a drive by Allied forces to bolster Serbia and halt the advance of the Central Powers' troops.
Story from BBC NEWS
One State; One Population or a Catastrophe
As the NYT reports,
How to express?
Well, Professor Yuli, the problem with you is that there should be only one population, one that includes everybody who wants to be Israeli. Following my mentor, Jabotinsky, one needn't necessarily be Jewish to be Israeli (although it helps) but we are not talking about a bi-national state. Jabo didn't approve of that as he wrote:
That was written in 1930. And Yuli Tamir is stuck back in some visionary idyllic "peace".
And where will Israel be with this educational program?
A catastrophe.
The education minister, Yuli Tamir, of the left-leaning Labor Party, told Israel Radio that there were two populations in Israel, Jewish and Arab, and that “the Arab public deserves to be allowed to express its feelings.”
How to express?
Israel’s Education Ministry announced Sunday that it had approved a textbook for use in the state’s Arab schools that for the first time described Israel’s 1948 war of independence as a “catastrophe” for the Arab population
Well, Professor Yuli, the problem with you is that there should be only one population, one that includes everybody who wants to be Israeli. Following my mentor, Jabotinsky, one needn't necessarily be Jewish to be Israeli (although it helps) but we are not talking about a bi-national state. Jabo didn't approve of that as he wrote:
In our case it means: should we Jews be condemned forever to remain a minority in Palestine, even a minority protected by the best imaginable kind of bi-national constitution, when Palestine will eventually become in its entirety an Arab national state, gradually but inevitably obliterating all the essential expression of our own Jewish individuality?
If, on the contrary, we Jews become the majority in Palestine (in which case, no doubt, it will be a matter of pride for us to endow our country with the most perfect of all bi-national constitutions), the tendency will be in the opposite direction, towards a Jewish national State ever more pronounced and complete ; and with every oncoming year that tendency will grow stronger because a Jewish majority will mean an open door for further Jewish immigration.
True, the "national" prospect for the Arabs under a Jewish majority would be much brighter than the "national" prospect for the Jews in an Arab majority state. The reason is obvious: Palestine is situated in the middle of several countries whose civilisation is, and will remain, Arabian. The Arabs of Palestine will always enjoy the advantage of easily accessible Arab influences across the border; not so the Jews.
Furthermore: should Palestine be allowed to crystallise as a state with an Arab majority , that would only be the beginning of further Arabisation. The next step would be for that state to join an Arab or pan-Arab federation; which would mean that the Jews, even if they formed a "considerable" minority within Palestine as such, would sink to the status of a very small percentage within the greater state.
To sum up the bi-national state trick is worthless. The crux of the problem remains the same old one: Jewish majority or Arab majority. For the Jews to agree to a minority status under the aegis of a bi-national regime would be suicidal. Nor can Arab nationalism be expected to welcome the opposite prospect.
That was written in 1930. And Yuli Tamir is stuck back in some visionary idyllic "peace".
And where will Israel be with this educational program?
A catastrophe.
He Saw Her Panties
Woman raped before "honor killing": court
A Kurdish woman was brutally raped, stamped on and strangled by members of her family and their friends in an "honor killing" carried out at her London home because she had fallen in love with the wrong man.
Banaz Mahmod, 20, was subjected to the 2-1/2 hour ordeal before she was garroted with a bootlace. Her body was stuffed into a suitcase and taken about 100 miles to Birmingham where it was buried in the back garden of a house.
Her badly decomposed body was found in April 2006, three months after the killing.
Last month a jury found her father Mahmod Mahmod, 52, and his brother Ari Mahmod, 51, guilty of murder after a three-month trial. Their associate Mohamad Hama, 30, had earlier admitted killing her.
...They believed Banaz had brought shame on the family by leaving her husband, an Iraqi Kurd she had been forced to marry at 17, and falling in love with Rahmat Suleimani, an Iranian Kurd.
In the recordings, transcripts of which were relayed to the court, Hama and his friend are hearing laughing as he described how she was killed with Banaz's uncle "supervising".
"I was kicking and stamping on her neck to get the soul out. I saw her stark naked, only wearing pants or underwear," Hama is recorded as saying.
Tu B'Av
"Behold, there is a yearly feast of the L-rd in Shiloh…"
*Tu B'Av In Shiloh*
*Monday July 30, 2007*
*Walk in the footsteps of Elkana and Shmuel in Tel Shiloh*
*From 3:00 p.m. on - Activities for the whole family: guided tours, Mishkan model and audio-visual show, street theater, handicraft workshops, incense workshop, bee workshop, winepress grape-stomping, and storytelling tent*
*Safari, bus, private cars, and walking tours, kite-flying festival in Yishuv Kida, and nature tours with Nisim Krispil in the areas surrounding the Shiloh bloc*
* *
*From 6:00 p.m. - Ethnic Foods Fair, Acrobats and Jugglers, and Fascinating Activites for Children and Families*
*At 8:00 p.m.*
*Exciting Concluding Performance featuring:*
*Hasidic performer Asaf Nagel,*
*the brothers duo Udi and Shahar Ariel singing Meir Ariel's songs*
* *
*Reduced-price family rate tickets at the site*
*To book secure transportation from Jerusalem and Petach Tikva, or for further information call:*
*Amana: 1-800-260-240*
*Tel Shiloh: 02-994-4019; Shiloh Office: 02-940-1111*
*Tu B'Av In Shiloh*
*Monday July 30, 2007*
*Walk in the footsteps of Elkana and Shmuel in Tel Shiloh*
*From 3:00 p.m. on - Activities for the whole family: guided tours, Mishkan model and audio-visual show, street theater, handicraft workshops, incense workshop, bee workshop, winepress grape-stomping, and storytelling tent*
*Safari, bus, private cars, and walking tours, kite-flying festival in Yishuv Kida, and nature tours with Nisim Krispil in the areas surrounding the Shiloh bloc*
* *
*From 6:00 p.m. - Ethnic Foods Fair, Acrobats and Jugglers, and Fascinating Activites for Children and Families*
*At 8:00 p.m.*
*Exciting Concluding Performance featuring:*
*Hasidic performer Asaf Nagel,*
*the brothers duo Udi and Shahar Ariel singing Meir Ariel's songs*
* *
*Reduced-price family rate tickets at the site*
*To book secure transportation from Jerusalem and Petach Tikva, or for further information call:*
*Amana: 1-800-260-240*
*Tel Shiloh: 02-994-4019; Shiloh Office: 02-940-1111*
Sunday, July 22, 2007
Is "Wonkette" Antisemitic?
Wonkette, that foul-mouthed but titilating blogger of Washington foibles, seems to have gone anti-semitic.
Editor Alex Pareene and Interns Nick Mueller and Lauren Spohrer may be responsibl;e for this post which refers to someone they call "Rudy-Jew-liani" who gave an interview to the "Jew York Times".
Anybody for bonking Wonkette?
Editor Alex Pareene and Interns Nick Mueller and Lauren Spohrer may be responsibl;e for this post which refers to someone they call "Rudy-Jew-liani" who gave an interview to the "Jew York Times".
Anybody for bonking Wonkette?
Can't Get a Handle on Handel
As I am on the board of Israel Academic Monitor, I'd like you to see this catch of theirs:-
They found a PhD candidate at the Cohn Institute for History and Philosophy of Sciences and Ideas, Tel Aviv University, one Ariel Handel, whose PhD thesis is about space, time and their relations at the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Wow. Wow-wee. Okay, I know you won't believe it but here's a summary of his gobbledygook:-
Space and Time in the Occupied Territories, Uncertainty as Control Technology
He goes on but I had to stop.
They found a PhD candidate at the Cohn Institute for History and Philosophy of Sciences and Ideas, Tel Aviv University, one Ariel Handel, whose PhD thesis is about space, time and their relations at the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Wow. Wow-wee. Okay, I know you won't believe it but here's a summary of his gobbledygook:-
Space and Time in the Occupied Territories, Uncertainty as Control Technology
The Paper’s main argument would be that Israel is controlling the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) by systematically dismantling the relation between space and time, or, in other words, by disassembling the correlation between spatial absolute value and usage value.
Absolute value is what can be measured in uniform distance units, which are, basically, indifferent to the occurrences in the measured space: for example, aerial
distance between two points. Usage value, in contrast, deals with spatial actual usage possibilities. If between two points stands impassable wall, no matter what is the absolute distance from one to another, the actual distance, considering the usage value, would be infinite. Spatial usage value always embodies time in it. Paving road between two points does not change the distance in kilometers, but shortens drastically the actual distance between them. In the same manner, blocking road lengthens the actual distance by containing time postponement within it.
I will attempt to analyze few basic modes of spatial control (i.e. clear sites in which space itself takes major part in control shaping), which are used for describing Israel’s control mode in the OPT: prison, ghetto, siege, camp and “movement policing”. The comparison would be done by spatial analysis tools, putting emphasis on relations between inside and outside, opacity and permeability,
characteristics and locations of supervision points and the visibility relations (what is been watched, where from, where to and why). The analysis would show that although having few similarities among each of the mentioned models none of them fully describes the situation in the OPT, which can be understood only by referring to what I would like to call “technologies of spatial uncertainty”.
He goes on but I had to stop.
More Wall Posters
Er, How "Traditional" is a Mixed-Marriage
Dear Readers,
I once posted a few items on mixed-marriages. I don't really think positively about them but hey, everyone is free to make his own choices, mistakes or errors.
But this caught my eye simply as a philosophical semantic question:-
If we're relating to "tradition", just how traditional are mixed-marriages?
And here's another:-
I once posted a few items on mixed-marriages. I don't really think positively about them but hey, everyone is free to make his own choices, mistakes or errors.
But this caught my eye simply as a philosophical semantic question:-
July 22, 2007
Deborah Elizabeth Bernstein, the daughter of Constance Bernstein and Dr. Kenneth Bernstein of Needham, Mass., is to be married today to David William Foster, a son of Nancy and William Foster of Signal Mountain, Tenn. The Rev. Garnett Foster, a Presbyterian minister and an aunt of the bridegroom, is to perform a ceremony incorporating Jewish and Christian traditions at the Rollins Chapel at Dartmouth College in Hanover, N.H.
If we're relating to "tradition", just how traditional are mixed-marriages?
And here's another:-
Barbara Ann Huscher and Steven H. Cohen were married on Thursday evening at Pine Manor College in Chestnut Hill, Mass. The Rev. Dr. Thomas Gallen, a Methodist minister, officiated, and Rabbi Devon A. Lerner took part in the interfaith ceremony.
Off Goes a Letter to the Washington Post
Hady Amr and Joel H. Samuels claim that "Palestinian negotiators also acknowledged the corollary Israeli need for sovereignty over not only the Wailing Wall, but also the Jewish Temple Mount" ("For Jerusalem, Shared Sovereignty", July 21). But this is false. No neogtiator for the Palestinian Authority has ever offered shared sovereignty nor "recognized" it. Some have bemoaned Yassir Arafat's faux paus at the 2000 Camp David Conference, when he told President Clinton that no Temple ever existed on the Temple Mount but nothing more has been forthcoming.
There has been a suggestion of a "divine sovereignty" but no practical benchmarks for that concept exist. When the Muslim Waqf will allow a group of 10 Jews to pray in a corner of the esplanade on Mount Moriah and thus religiously share the holy site, or will allow archeological exacvations there to discover its Jewish past and halt its destruction of the same, then we will know a change has been made.
And these kooks add:-
American leadership on "shared" sovereignty in Jerusalem can help bring peace to Israelis and Palestinians. Equally important is the implicit message this will send to the Muslim world: that "shared" solutions for "shared" U.S. and Muslim world security can be found and that Americans are committed to making that happen.
Sometimes and in some places, conflict is so intractable that all but the most unlikely solutions are fated to fail. In those times and places, we need to try methods that have not been considered in the hopes that unconventional solutions will offer opportunities not available through line-drawing. This is such a time; Jerusalem is such a place; shared sovereignty is such a solution. And the benefits can be global.
Since when have the Pals. shared anything?
Biton Beaten
The Seforim blog posted about Rav Daniel Biton's new book, "Milchemet Chorma". It's a Satmar anti-Neturei Karta tract (if that makes sense to you).
Anyway, he had his leg broken according to the wall poster I photographed this morning - although I was apprehensive that it would have been covered up over the Shabbat as I had spotted it on Thursday.
Here's one of the whole poster, in situ:-

and here's a close-up of the report on his attack and subsequent hosptial treatment:-

Funny enough, 27 years ago, the NK were out demonstrating in Washington for his release from jail.
I had thought that his being roughed up had to do with his book but now that I read the fine print as well as this JPost story, it seems the Rosh Kollel was not attacked by fellow Satamrists/NKs but by police while he was demonstrating for the continued hanging of a big wall sign warning females to dress modestly. Of course, he could have got himself in that situation to protect himself from a more fearsome attack from his neighbors (after all, he had his book published in the States) but that's just a conspiracy theory.
Anyway, he had his leg broken according to the wall poster I photographed this morning - although I was apprehensive that it would have been covered up over the Shabbat as I had spotted it on Thursday.
Here's one of the whole poster, in situ:-

and here's a close-up of the report on his attack and subsequent hosptial treatment:-

Funny enough, 27 years ago, the NK were out demonstrating in Washington for his release from jail.
I had thought that his being roughed up had to do with his book but now that I read the fine print as well as this JPost story, it seems the Rosh Kollel was not attacked by fellow Satamrists/NKs but by police while he was demonstrating for the continued hanging of a big wall sign warning females to dress modestly. Of course, he could have got himself in that situation to protect himself from a more fearsome attack from his neighbors (after all, he had his book published in the States) but that's just a conspiracy theory.
Letter on the Tzipi Livni Piece
This letter appeared in today's Sunday Magazine of the NYTimes:-
The article describes the Irgun as “Zionist guerrillas who used what would today be called terrorist methods to blast the British out of Palestine.” In fact, today the Irgun would not be considered terrorist. After all, if members of Al Qaeda, who routinely slaughter Iraqis by the hundreds, are “insurgents,” and Hamas, which has done the same in Israel, is made up of “militants,” it is unlikely the Irgun, which focused primarily on British forces and which was loath to kill civilians, would be considered terrorist. But given the rampant double standards that bedevil Israel, who knows?
George Burger
Toronto
Can't You Just Plotz?
Noah Feldman's bewailing in the NYTimes' Sunday Magazine - he married out, to a Korean, about his treatment by his former Orthodox educational institution and Rabbi is the only time an Orthodox Jew can get into this paper.
Funny enough, his classmate spent this Shabbat next door to me at Shiloh as she's Rav Dov Berkovits' niece.
Funny enough, his classmate spent this Shabbat next door to me at Shiloh as she's Rav Dov Berkovits' niece.
For Tisha B'Av
If we were really serious about our desire for the rebuilt Temple and the imminent coming of Mashiach, why do we keep our Kinnot books from year to year and not throw them away?
Mordechai of Lechovitz
More sayings.
Mordechai of Lechovitz
More sayings.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







