Thursday, January 11, 2018
The Medad "4C" Construct
I suggest to all the activists and organizations to at least adopt my Four C Construct so with all the divisiveness and lack of unity among us, at least we can work together.
In short:
Communicate
Coordinate
Cooperate
Concentrate
More about them in this video, beginning at 6:00.
And if you like listening to me, try this video interview from Jan 18, 2013 conducted by Judith Nusbaum, representing the Unity Coalition for Israel.
^
Monday, January 08, 2018
Being Religious and a NYT Letter to the Editor
I delayed responding to this letter of Leon as, to be honest, I couldn't find a reference to him on social media outlets which, for me, is a sign that a person doesn't exist. It was the spelling, which he informs me " I have it spelled differently [Karyem] on Facebook. The Times has it how I write it in person."
But he found me. And now to his letter in the New York Times:
Re “Israeli Wants to Name Train Station for Trump” (news article, Dec. 28):
Rarely have my religious sensibilities been so offended as they were by the Israeli transportation minister’s plan to name a new train station in the Jewish Quarter, near the Western Wall, after Donald Trump. Mr. Trump has made a political career out of closing America’s doors to the widow, the orphan and the stranger. He ran a campaign vilifying religious minorities, but as president referred to those marching alongside neo-Nazis in a Charlottesville, Va., rally last summer as “very fine people.”
As a Zionist and a current Jerusalem resident, I appreciate the president’s decision to recognize Israeli sovereignty over its capital. But that does not mitigate the profanity of slapping his name on this sacred site.
The Western Wall is not a casino, and it is a desecration to associate the Temple Mount with that gilded, tacky brand that has already brought one great nation so low.
LEON KRAIEM, JERUSALEM
Leon is studying at a rabbinical seminary, and it is the Conservative Yeshiva in Jerusalem. He had wanted to vote for moderate progressive New York candidate for mayor Sal Albanese, who was endorsed by the...Jewish Press! I hope he is one that Daniel Gordis would not be wary of, as a rabbinical student, or a member of Conservative Judaism.
And to Leon's letter.
First of all, congratulations on being published. I have had letters published there but my batting average is quite low. But that is not because of my writing ability but because of my opinions. So, Leon, take that into consideration. If you had written in support of the naming of a train station after Trump, I'd bet you wouldn't have gotten in (there was no pro-letter, was there?).
Second, good vocabulary: sensibilities, offended the widow, the orphan and the stranger, vilifying, mitigate the profanity of slapping his name, gilded, tacky. Good future sermon potential.
Third, writing, though, that you are "a current Jerusalem resident" is a bit of a sleight-of-hand. Really now. You were passing along a misrepresentation of your Jerusalem status? Are you earning a living here? Are you making Aliyah? Why not write "currently a rabbinical student on a year's (two years?) program"?
Four, why at all should your religious sensibilities be offended? What has a train station to do with religion? It has to do with Trump's declaration regarding Jerusalem:
...today, we finally acknowledge the obvious: that Jerusalem is Israel’s capital. This is nothing more, or less, than a recognition of reality. It is also the right thing to do. It’s something that has to be done.
If your religious sensibilities were offended it should have been this part of his words:
a place where Jews pray at the Western Wall...In the meantime, I call on all parties to maintain the status quo at Jerusalem’s holy sites, including the Temple Mount, also known as Haram al-Sharif.
Why cannot Jews pray on the Temple Mount, which is a religious act and some think an obligation? If you demur, I would point out that that is probably because of a political outlook. You do know that there's a Conservative psak on the matter permitting entrance (although Reuven Hammer, supporting entrance, disagrees as to actual Jewish prayer)? The law of Israel is on the side of those who seek freedom of religion although the High Court of Justice discriminates against Jews in this matter. Even the Jordan-Israel Peace Treaty lends support to this request (Article 9).
Fifth, is it "profanity" in naming a train station after President Trump? Truly? Of course, if it is Trump himself that bothers you, rather than naming the station after a person, a non-Jew, then we are left with a political dispute. But is it proper for you to disagree, in the name of "a Jerusalem resident", "Jerusalem, Israel", as if you are now representing 800,00+ Jerusalemites and millions of Israelis, without a smidgen of veracity or authority, to that act? That the NYTimes can wave you about, albeit in the letters section? After all, you must know how they would exploit that letter.
I cannot argue on the grounds of whether Minister Katz made to correct decision. We do have a King George V Avenue - and he didn't do a thing. He happened to be king when the Balfour Declaration was made. There is French Hill, after a Colonel French or perhaps French nuns.
But if it is the proximity to Jewish holy sites that sets you off, you do know this, yes?
R. Johanan said: Why did Omri merit sovereignty? Because he added a region to Eretz-Yisrael, as it is written, And he bought the hill Samaria of Shemer for two talents of silver, and built on the hill, and called the name of the city which he built, after the name of Shemer, owner of the hill Samaria,[I Kings 16:24] R. Johanan said: Why did Ahab merit royalty for twenty-two years? — Because he honoured the Torah, which was given in twenty-two letters...R. Judah says: Manasheh has a portion therein..."because of Manasseh the son of Hezekiah, king of Judah" [Jeremiah 15:4], One Master maintains, 'Because of Manasseh' who repented..."
So, from a religious, or theological Rabbinic standpoint, Trump should be thought of having some positive merit - at least as regards the train station being named after him: he made a major contribution to Israel's sovereignty and the raising up of the worth of the Land of Israel, the Jewish national home; he gave honor to the Jewish connection to Israel and Jerusalem and he still can yet repent.
In other words, you not only were interfering but your religiosity, as regards your political viewpoint is questionable, at the least. As to the matter of your Jerusalem residency, well, maybe you will stay and not go back to the lands of Dispersion and Exile but will be a good religious Jew and stay. And use the train.
^
Sunday, January 07, 2018
Saluting Conor Cruise O'Brien
From this appreciation of Conor Cruise O'Brien:
Although Cruise O’Brien denounced nationalism in his own country, he adopted another’s in the shape of Zionism, which led to his absorbing, if one-sided, book The Siege (1986). He accepted the premises of Zionism somewhat uncritically, and paid too little attention to the Palestinian Arabs, who had been the majority population of Palestine when Zionist settlement began, and to the possibility that they had suffered an injustice. This unlikely displacement of patriotic feeling sprang partly from his own philo-semitism, and partly from his tendency to conflate all terrorists (notably, the IRA and the PLO), but also from an undoubted esprit de contradiction: he took up the cause of Zionism and Israel just as the liberal left turned against them.
Partisan as he was, Cruise O’Brien adhered to his own code of intellectual honesty in his study of Israel. In the 1920s and 1930s, the Zionist movement was split between the Labor Zionists under David Ben-Gurion and the right-wing Revisionists led by Vladimir Jabotinsky (the forebears of Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud Party). Cruise O’Brien pointed out in an essay published in his 1988 collection Passion and Cunning what many liberal supporters of Israel have tried to overlook—that in their attitudes toward the Palestinian Arabs, the only real difference was that Jabotinsky expressed himself with a public candor that seemed impolitic to Ben-Gurion.
^
They Are Calling for Ribat
The term ribāt in Arabic means a course of action whose purpose is to persevere with patience so as to outlast the enemy at what is considered a front-line location of conflict.
In the Hadith we find: "Muhammad Ibn Ka’b al-Quradhī (رحمه الله) said, “(And perform ribāt) against My enemy and your enemy until he abandons his religion for your religion” [Tafsīr Ibn al-Mundhir]."
And here is how it is used in response to the news of the dramatic increase in numbers of Jews observing the ritual stringency who ascend to the Temple Mount:
الرباط الكثيف والمواظبة عليه داخل الاقصى هو الحل الوحيد لمنع هذه الزيادة الخطيرة جدا...
which translates as
intensive and diligent ribat is the only solution to prevent this very dangerous increase...
As explained at my source, the linguistic root of ribāt stems from the term used for the binding (irtibāt) of horses in preparation for the enemy just as their enemy binds their horses in preparation for them. The word then was extended to describe those stationed at frontier posts defending those behind them whom the enemy desires to harm with evil, whether the enemy has horses he has bounded or is on foot without a riding animal for himself.
Males performing this duty are murābitīn and the females are murābitun because
“A day of ribāt for Allah’s cause is better than the world and everything it contains. [Reported by al-Bukhārī and Muslim from Sahl Ibn Sa’d]."It's a serious business:
"Since the revival of jihād more than thirty years ago, mujāhid leaders have stated that jihād – on the personal level – consists of strides on a roadmap towards shahādah. One first performs hijrah to the lands of jihād (now, dārul -Islām), then gives bay’ah, pledging what it entails of obedience (sam’ and tā’ah) to the amīr (now, the Khalīfah)...then trains (i’dād) for the purpose of jihād, then patiently spends months of rībat, serves countless hours of guard duty (hirāsah), then fights (qitāl) in battles and kills (qatl) whom he can from amongst the kāfir enemy, and finally achieves shahādah."
which leads us back to a decision taken by Internal Security Minister Gilad Ardan to proscribe them two years ago.
P.S.
The Grand Shaikh of Al-Azhar, the oldest university in the Muslim world, said on Friday that the battle with the Zionists is not only about Al-Aqsa Mosque, but also the rest of the 35 acre sanctuary around it, Quds News Agency has reported.
“Al-Aqsa Mosque is not a small area of land,” explained Shaikh Ahmed Al-Tayeb. “The sanctuary also includes the Dome of the Rock Mosque, wells and corridors.” All of them, he pointed out, make up Al-Aqsa Mosque. The Zionists want to take over Al-Aqsa. Referring to the Dome of the Rock as Al-Aqsa Mosque is a deceitful Zionist plan.
The Grand Shaikh’s comments came just days ahead of Al-Azhar’s International Conference about Jerusalem, which is scheduled to be held in Cairo on 17 and 18 January.
But the fuller version is worse:
Sheikh al-Tayyib said that the West's intention to grant Palestine to the Jews was to gather them in a place and expel them from Europe, to deny some of the Holocaust it had committed against the Jews, and because the antagonism of the Christian traditions of Judaism is traditional and inherited in the blood of many Western Christians, whether they are rulers or ruled.
Dr. al-Tayeb responded to the claim of some of them that the Aqsa Mosque mentioned in the Koran is not the Al-Aqsa Mosque, which we know in Palestine but it is a mosque on the road to Taif, saying:
Whoever claims that it is trumpet of the horns of the Zionists in the East, which is not based on evidence or evidence of evidence; it is attributed to this talk to the realist, and reference to the writings of this world, Al-Waqqadi says in al-Maghazi (3 / 958-959): The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) ended up on the night of Thursday for five nights from Khu`l al-Qa'dah, and he lived in al-Jaranah thirteen. When he wanted to leave for the city, I stayed the night at night, I was deprived of the Aqsa Mosque, which is under the valley of the maximum enemy, and was a chapel The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) was not allowed to enter the valley except for a mahram. He still did not meet until he received the pillar. What is the connection between this? Al-Aqsa Mosque, in which Allah said: "Al-Aqsa Mosque, which we have surrounded." Al-Jawqadi speaks about two mosques, one near and the other after him. He described them as the maximum and the lowest on what is used by the scholars. He did not mean that this mosque is named al-Aqsa and the other is its lower name. Who does not distinguish between the name and description.
Sheikh al-Tayeb said that Al-Azhar is keeping pace with the Palestinian issue with its conferences, scientists and authors. He said: "We have the works of the world about Jerusalem, including what is printed and what is a manuscript, and on this occasion I emphasize the importance of having a course on Jerusalem in primary, The history of the three mosques, the history of the holy mosque (the Kaaba), the history of the mosque and its developments, and also the history of Al-Aqsa Mosque, because the Arab mind is free of the culture of Jerusalem or the culture of Palestine in general. We face a strong "Israel" that has k One womb has a single frame with a people divided on itself.
^
Thursday, January 04, 2018
Israelis and Their Opinions in Polls
I have blogged about this aspect of Israeli public opinion previously.
To summarize:
1. Most Israelis lean right. This is obvious since 1977 when governments favoring right-wing policies have consistently been able to be confirmed by Knesset vote due to a majority of the parties agreeing to such a policy.
2. In answering polls, a majority responds with right-leaning opinions.
3. When asked specifics, however they tend to reply in a way in which they think complies with hw the world thinks they should be thinking.
Example from the December Peace Index:
The status of Jerusalem - between aspirations and reality: What do Israelis want? A majority of the Jewish public (72%) thinks that after stable peace between Israel and the Palestinians has been achieved, Jerusalem should be united and the capital of Israel (including those who would accept the Islamic holy places being in the Palestinians’ hands). Very few see a likelihood of alternatives that would reduce Israel’s control of the city: 12% think that in a situation of peace, the western part should remain the capital of Israel and the eastern part should be the capital of Palestine; 7% say Jerusalem should be an international city; while 5.5% believe the city should remain united and be the joint capital of Israel and Palestine. In the Arab public the highest rate, 44%, wants the city to be divided with the eastern part serving as the capital of Palestine and the western part as the capital of Israel. The second largest rate, 22%, wants it to remain united and be the capital of both countries, Israel and Palestine.And what do people think will actually happen? To the question “What, in your opinion, will in fact happen if a peace agreement is signed between Israel and the Palestinians?” half (50%) of the Jewish public answered that the city will remain united and the capital of Israel (including those who think it will remain united but the Islamic holy places will be transferred to the Palestinians), about a quarter expect it to be divided and to be the capital of both states, and small percentages chose a common capital or an international city as likely alternatives. The high rate of Arab interviewees who did not give an answer to this question, about one-third, prevents us from relating to this sample’s distribution of responses.
^
Wednesday, January 03, 2018
With What Is The State Department Occupying Itself?
From US State Department's Spokeswoman Heather Nauert's Press Briefing on January 2, 2018
QUESTION: I’m not asking you to. But do you still – does the administration believe that the West Bank is occupied by Israel?
MS NAUERT: I can only say that our position has not changed. Our position on that hasn’t changed.
QUESTION: Well, does that mean that – does that mean that you still regard the West Bank as being occupied?
MS NAUERT: Matt, I can just tell you our position hasn’t changed. I’m going to be very careful with the words because anything related to this region, as many others --
QUESTION: Exactly.
MS NAUERT: -- is extremely sensitive.
QUESTION: Exactly.
MS NAUERT: Our position has not changed, and I won’t budge from that.
QUESTION: Okay. At some point it would be nice to find out exactly what that position is. You shouldn’t be afraid – precisely because it is so sensitive, you shouldn’t be afraid, unless you’re embarrassed by what the policy is. Not you personally, but whoever. You shouldn’t be afraid to say what it is instead of just saying it hasn’t changed.
MS NAUERT: I don’t think – Matt, as you have seen, when America speaks about a matter, it is taken very seriously.
QUESTION: I know.
MS NAUERT: And so that is why it’s important for the United States to be careful with its words. And you may not get all the words that you were hoping to get, but I’m going to be careful with the words. Okay?
QUESTION: Okay. Well, does that include tweeting stuff about “little Rocket Man” and things like that?
MS NAUERT: Matt.
QUESTION: Be careful with your words? Or “fire and fury” is going to rain down on North Korea?
MS NAUERT: I’m not even going to go there, Matt. Okay?
QUESTION: If you’re saying that the position hasn’t changed, why won’t you just state the position?
MS NAUERT: Michele, the position hasn’t changed. I’m not going there, okay? You’ve got all --
QUESTION: Just – okay.
MS NAUERT: That’s it on that. Okay? Let’s move on.
So, is Judea and Samaria "occupied"?
P.S. It is, but quite legally, as a result of Israel's defense against armed aggression. It is termed "belligerent occupation" which means that it has occurred as a result of hostilities. It does not mean the occupation is illegal:
The term "belligerent occupation" is frequently used to describe the establishment of military government in enemy territory (p. 2 note 5)
As we all know:
Israel refuses to acknowledge the Convention's de jure application to any of the Occupied Territories. Israel has, however, said it will comply de facto with the Convention's humanitarian provisions in administering the West Bank and Gaza (but the applicable provisions have never been specified).
^
Monday, January 01, 2018
Yes! First Temple Archaeological Proof
As the Israel Archaeological Authority has announced today:
"A unique and significant discovery was made during archaeological works in the Western Wall Plaza, on behalf of the Israel Antiquities Authority and in association with the Western Wall Heritage Foundation: A stamped piece of clay from the First Temple period, which belonged to the “governor of the city” of Jerusalem – the most prominent local position to be held in Jerusalem of 2700 years ago.
This extraordinary find is a lump of clay, stamped and pre-fired. It measures 13 X 15 mm and is 2–3 mm thick. The upper part of the sealing depicts two figures facing each other, and the lower part holds an inscription in ancient Hebrew script.
The sealing was presented to the Mayor of Jerusalem, Nir Barkat, during his visit to Davidson's Center, near the Western Wall, last week. After the completion of the scientific research, the sealing will be on temporary exhibit in the mayor's office.
The sealing, its use unknown, was retrieved by Shimon Cohen while wet-sieving the soil from a late First Temple-period building (seventh-sixth centuries BCE).
Dr. Shlomit Weksler-Bdolah, excavator of the site located in the northwestern part of the western Wall Plaza, on behalf of the IAA, believes that "the sealing had been attached to an important transport and served as some sort of logo, or as a tiny souvenir, which was sent on behalf of the governor of the city." Dr. Weksler-Bdolah further suggests that "it is likely that one of the buildings in our excavation was the destination of this transport sent by the city governor. The finding of the sealing with this high-rank title, in addition to the large assemblage of actual seals found in the building in the past, supports the assumption that this area, located on the western slopes of the western hill of ancient Jerusalem, some 100 m west of the Temple Mount, was inhabited by highly ranked officials during the First Temple period." According to Dr. Weksler-Bdolah "this is the first time that such a sealing is found in an authorized excavation. It supports the biblical rendering of the existence of a governor of the city in Jerusalem 2700 years ago."
Prof. Tallay Ornan of the Hebrew University, and Prof. Benjamin Sass of Tel Aviv University, studied the sealing and describe it thus: "above a double line are two standing men, facing each other in a mirror-like manner. Their heads are depicted as large dots, lacking any details. The hands facing outward are dropped down, and the hands facing inward are raised Each of the figures is wearing a striped, knee-length garment. In the register beneath the double line is an inscription in ancient Hebrew: לשרער, with no spacing between the words and no definite article. It denotes לשר העיר, i.e., “belonging to the governor of the city." Prof. Ornan and Prof. Sass add, that "the title 'governor of the city' is known from the Bible and from extra-biblical documents, referring to an official appointed by the king. Governors of Jerusalem are mentioned twice in the Bible: in 2 Kings, Joshua is the governor of the city in the days of Hezekiah, and in 2 Chronicles, Maaseiah is the governor of the city in the days of Josiah.
Nir Barkat, Mayor of Jerusalem, When the find was presented to him related that "it is very overwhelming to receive greetings from First Temple-period Jerusalem. This shows that already 2700 years ago, Jerusalem, the capital of Israel, was a strong and central city. Jerusalem is one of the most ancient capitals of the world, continually populated by the Jewish people for more than 3000 years. Today we have the privilege to encounter another one of the long chain of persons and leaders that built and developed the city. We are grateful to be living in a city with such a magnificent past, and are obligated to ensure its strength for generations to come, as we daily do."
According to Dr. Yuval Baruch, archaeologist of the Jerusalem District in the IAA: “the outstanding significance of the finds brought upon the decision to conserve the First Temple-period building exposed in the Western Wall plaza excavations and open it to visitors"."
"A unique and significant discovery was made during archaeological works in the Western Wall Plaza, on behalf of the Israel Antiquities Authority and in association with the Western Wall Heritage Foundation: A stamped piece of clay from the First Temple period, which belonged to the “governor of the city” of Jerusalem – the most prominent local position to be held in Jerusalem of 2700 years ago.
This extraordinary find is a lump of clay, stamped and pre-fired. It measures 13 X 15 mm and is 2–3 mm thick. The upper part of the sealing depicts two figures facing each other, and the lower part holds an inscription in ancient Hebrew script.
The sealing was presented to the Mayor of Jerusalem, Nir Barkat, during his visit to Davidson's Center, near the Western Wall, last week. After the completion of the scientific research, the sealing will be on temporary exhibit in the mayor's office.
The sealing, its use unknown, was retrieved by Shimon Cohen while wet-sieving the soil from a late First Temple-period building (seventh-sixth centuries BCE).
Dr. Shlomit Weksler-Bdolah, excavator of the site located in the northwestern part of the western Wall Plaza, on behalf of the IAA, believes that "the sealing had been attached to an important transport and served as some sort of logo, or as a tiny souvenir, which was sent on behalf of the governor of the city." Dr. Weksler-Bdolah further suggests that "it is likely that one of the buildings in our excavation was the destination of this transport sent by the city governor. The finding of the sealing with this high-rank title, in addition to the large assemblage of actual seals found in the building in the past, supports the assumption that this area, located on the western slopes of the western hill of ancient Jerusalem, some 100 m west of the Temple Mount, was inhabited by highly ranked officials during the First Temple period." According to Dr. Weksler-Bdolah "this is the first time that such a sealing is found in an authorized excavation. It supports the biblical rendering of the existence of a governor of the city in Jerusalem 2700 years ago."
Prof. Tallay Ornan of the Hebrew University, and Prof. Benjamin Sass of Tel Aviv University, studied the sealing and describe it thus: "above a double line are two standing men, facing each other in a mirror-like manner. Their heads are depicted as large dots, lacking any details. The hands facing outward are dropped down, and the hands facing inward are raised Each of the figures is wearing a striped, knee-length garment. In the register beneath the double line is an inscription in ancient Hebrew: לשרער, with no spacing between the words and no definite article. It denotes לשר העיר, i.e., “belonging to the governor of the city." Prof. Ornan and Prof. Sass add, that "the title 'governor of the city' is known from the Bible and from extra-biblical documents, referring to an official appointed by the king. Governors of Jerusalem are mentioned twice in the Bible: in 2 Kings, Joshua is the governor of the city in the days of Hezekiah, and in 2 Chronicles, Maaseiah is the governor of the city in the days of Josiah.
Nir Barkat, Mayor of Jerusalem, When the find was presented to him related that "it is very overwhelming to receive greetings from First Temple-period Jerusalem. This shows that already 2700 years ago, Jerusalem, the capital of Israel, was a strong and central city. Jerusalem is one of the most ancient capitals of the world, continually populated by the Jewish people for more than 3000 years. Today we have the privilege to encounter another one of the long chain of persons and leaders that built and developed the city. We are grateful to be living in a city with such a magnificent past, and are obligated to ensure its strength for generations to come, as we daily do."
According to Dr. Yuval Baruch, archaeologist of the Jerusalem District in the IAA: “the outstanding significance of the finds brought upon the decision to conserve the First Temple-period building exposed in the Western Wall plaza excavations and open it to visitors"."
A short explanatory film clip.
Take that, o ye Muslims.
This find is quite special as unlike other similar finds,
"Ours is special because this was the first time the seal of the Governor of the City of Jerusalem itself was found in the right place," Weksler-Bdolah says.
^
Sunday, December 31, 2017
Temple Mount Tempest
Jordan, whose state-directed news agencies have employed language of incitement against Israel over it permitting Jews to visit the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, visit - not pray - now has another antagonist over the holy site:
Amman is reportedly frustrated with Crown Prince Mohammad Bin Salman’s new agenda, namely his desire to strip the Hashemite Kingdom of its custodianship over the Temple Mount, according to the Haaretz daily.
On Friday, there was this in Jordan:
Hundreds of Jordanians took to the streets of downtown Amman on Friday in protest against the decision by US president Donald Trump to relocate the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.
Waving Jordanian and Palestinian national flags and carrying banners, the protesters denounced the Trump’s decision and expressed their solidarity with Jerusalem...
“God willing, the Zionists will leave the city. Jerusalem will definitely be liberated.”
Jordan is the recognized custodian of Jerusalem's Islamic holy sites and Christian ones too, as per self-pronouncement and the 1013 agreement signed with the Palestinian Authority. * And Saudi Arabia of the Two Mosques of Mecca and Medina.
While researching for this post, I discovered something of a "of a "Wow. Just wow!" quality.
"On 21 August 1969, a painful incident took place in Al Aqsa Mosque, when a Jewish extremist barged into the holy site and set it on fire."
He was Christian.
Rohan. Denis Michael Rohan.
Jordan has banned the import of frozen poultry from Saudi Arabia following the outbreak of a highly pathogenic avian influenza virus. The precautionary measure seeks to protect the country’s poultry stock and also protect public health, the Ministry of Agriculture, which placed the ban, said.
The only other item that relates to the "frustration" perhaps is in Rami Khouri's piece. He used this language therein:
Saudi threats and intimidation
a heavy-handed power play to force Palestine and Jordan to follow Saudi orders.
crude but brutal political message to Jordan's King Abdullah and Palestine's President Mahmoud Abbas on how to behave on the Jerusalem issue and regional alignments.
*
The Hashemite attention to Jerusalem was not limited to restoring Islamic holy sites. It also involved building colleges, religious schools and centres to safeguard heritage, including:
The Dawa and Religious Studies College in Jerusalem, established in 1978
The Islamic Sciences College in Jerusalem, established in 1975
The Islamic Sciences College in Qalqilya, established in 1978
Al Aqsa Secondary School for Islamic Jurisprudence, established in 1958
A school for Islamic jurisprudence in Jenin, established in 1975
The Islamic Jurisprudence School in Hebron, established in 1962
The Islamic Jurisprudence School in Nablus, established in 1962
The Islamic Archaeology Department in Jerusalem, established in 1977
The Islamic Heritage Revival Department in Jerusalem, established in 1978
^
Is the ODS Odd?
Caught this item by my friend Daoud Kuttab:
ODS Movement looks to popularize one-state solution for Palestine
The Popular Movement for One Democratic State in Historic Palestine (ODS) is stepping up efforts to increase the awareness and the popularity of its cause. ODS spokesman Radi Jarai told Arab News that his movement wants to make the concept “much more accessible and understandable to people.”Jarai, an active member of Palestine’s nationalist Fatah party who has spent years in Israeli prisons, said the movement is currently made up of academics and thinkers...ODS was founded in March 2013 and welcomes both Jews and Palestinians as members.
...Yoav Haifawi, an Israeli activist and publisher of the Free Haifa blog, told Arab News that he is a longtime supporter of the one-state concept.“The biggest obstacle we face is that Israel is a privileged country for Jews. Therefore, as a colonial state that gives privileges through discrimination, the decolonization of Palestine cannot happen as long as Israel is strong and Palestinians are weak.”
Uri Davis, a Jewish member of Fatah, told Arab News that the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) is the representative of the Palestinian people...The one-state solution, Davis said, would mean a change “from the current state of affairs into a single Palestinian sovereignty (stretching) from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River under a liberal-democratic Palestinian Constitution; single Palestinian citizenship; and a single Palestinian currency, hopefully leading to a socialist democratic Federal Republic of Palestine.”
Few PLO factions have been supportive of ODS so far...
I am not sure that the state has to be socialist, I would oppose after Israel's experiment in socialism until 1977, but I suggest that the group consider:
a) including Jordan in the territory for after all, it was part of Palestine
b) trying out a federation or condominium arrangement forst for a while
and
c) try Israel as the one state. That way, no Arabs need kill Arabs as with almost every other Arab state.
The foundation declaration is here.
^
Saturday, December 30, 2017
About "Palestinians:
From the Naval Intelligence report previously mentioned:
Bedouins were the last group mentioned at the bottom.
Immigrants, eh?
Invaders, eh?
Maybe they were also "colonialist settlers"?
^
Bedouins were the last group mentioned at the bottom.
Immigrants, eh?
Invaders, eh?
Maybe they were also "colonialist settlers"?
^
Friday, December 29, 2017
What Was That "Whole"
Pro-Arab advocates who seek to deny the Jews a state in the area that was the Palestine Mandate usually point to the White Paper of 1922, the Churchill White Paper.
And they note it draws
To comment:
Palestine included the territory both West and East of the Jordan River but as a result of British machinations, all the areas east of the Jordan River were to have the application of the articles of the League of Mandate Mandate postponed. Not cancelled. Simply postponed.
Here:
Therefore, to establish a Jewish state in all of Western Palestine is quite an appropriate interpretation to this document.
Moreover, let's not overlook another paragraph in this policy statement (a policy statement, not something internationally legal and which was unduly influenced by Arab terror pogroms in April 1920, May 1921 and November 1921) which reads
^
And they note it draws
attention to the fact that the terms of the Declaration referred to [that is, the Balfour Declaration - YM] do not contemplate that Palestine as a whole should be converted into a Jewish National Home, but that such a Home should be founded `in Palestine.'
To comment:
Palestine included the territory both West and East of the Jordan River but as a result of British machinations, all the areas east of the Jordan River were to have the application of the articles of the League of Mandate Mandate postponed. Not cancelled. Simply postponed.
Here:
In the territories lying between the Jordan and the eastern boundary of Palestine as ultimately determined, the Mandatory shall be entitled, with the consent of the Council of the League of Nations, to postpone or withhold application of such provisions of this mandate as he may consider inapplicable to the existing local conditions, and to make such provision for the administration of the territories as he may consider suitable to those conditions...
Therefore, to establish a Jewish state in all of Western Palestine is quite an appropriate interpretation to this document.
Moreover, let's not overlook another paragraph in this policy statement (a policy statement, not something internationally legal and which was unduly influenced by Arab terror pogroms in April 1920, May 1921 and November 1921) which reads
it is not the case, as has been represented by the Arab Delegation, that during the war His Majesty's Government gave an undertaking that an independent national government should be at once established in Palestine. This representation mainly rests upon a letter dated the 24th October, 1915, from Sir Henry McMahon, then His Majesty's High Commissioner in Egypt, to the Sharif of Mecca, now King Hussein of the Kingdom of the Hejaz. That letter is quoted as conveying the promise to the Sherif of Mecca to recognise and support the independence of the Arabs within the territories proposed by him. But this promise was given subject to a reservation made in the same letter, which excluded from its scope, among other territories, the portions of Syria lying to the west of the District of Damascus. This reservation has always been regarded by His Majesty's Government as covering the vilayet of Beirut and the independent Sanjak of Jerusalem. The whole of Palestine west of the Jordan was thus excluded from Sir. Henry McMahon's pledge.
^
Scary
Last week, a sign showing a guillotine was held aloft at the anti-"Netanyahu-is-Corrupt" demos:
Now we have Eran Volkowsly's caricature today in Haaretz, with left-wing humor:
A double-bladed battle axe.
And, by the way, Persians and Mamelukes used them and they were termed tabarzin.
The text reads:
Now we have Eran Volkowsly's caricature today in Haaretz, with left-wing humor:
A double-bladed battle axe.
And, by the way, Persians and Mamelukes used them and they were termed tabarzin.
The text reads:
This will scare them
What scares me is either the obliviousness of Israel's leftists - and that includes most of the media which provided protective cover for that guillotine by pooh-poohing the whole incident (in democracies we change leader wither through the ballot or a judicial process) - to the seriousness of introducing bloody violence into the public discourse, something they always blame the right-wing for doing or, the possible encouragement Volkowsky lends to even worse characterizations.
Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked was drawn naked. Art.
It keeps getting worse. And the Left demands morality and ethics in public life.
And they are hypocritical as when President Rivlin was portrayed in a keffiyeh because that's as we all "know", is incitement to murder.
Sure, for Volkowsky and his editor, it's "funny". Funny as only the Left defines humor.
That's scary. Really.
^
When The British Navy Patrolled the Palestine Mandate
Going through this handbook, to which I was alerted by EOZ,
I found a short history of British naval operations in the Palestine Mandate during 1936-38:
All aboard.
^
I found a short history of British naval operations in the Palestine Mandate during 1936-38:
All aboard.
^
Thursday, December 28, 2017
Dear Jess
Dear Jess,
I read your letter to Lorde, published in The Jewish Chronicle.
I would just want to make one comment. (I was published also in TheJC awhile ago.)
You write
"Israel’s illegal settlements break the Geneva convention, which is true".
No, Jess, they do not.
Let me explain it to you briefly and concisely.
A. The League of Nations Mandate of Palestine, which was to reconstitute the Jewish people's national homeland through the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine, guaranteed, Article 6, to "encourage, in co-operation with the Jewish agency referred to in Article 4, close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands not required for public purposes."
In other words, the act of "settlement" in and of itself, is not illegal.
B. And where was this settlement activity to take place?
If we look to Article 25, we read
In the territories lying between the Jordan and the eastern boundary of Palestine as ultimately determined, the Mandatory shall be entitled, with the consent of the Council of the League of Nations, to postpone or withhold application of such provisions of this mandate as he may consider inapplicable to the existing local conditions
So, as you probably know your geography, all the area west of the Jordan River is the territory in which settlement by Jews is permitted, nay, encouraged.
C. Until the creation of the Palestine Mandate, Jess, no state called Palestine existed. It was a region, an area. The Ottoman Empire ruled it, having conquered it from Mamelukes who conquered it from Crusaders who had conquered it from Arabs (who first came to the area of Palestine in 638 CE) and who had conquered it from the Byzantine Empire.
And you surely know, Jess, that "Palestine" is the Latin name given by the Romans to Eretz-Yisrael, the Land of Israel, the Jewish homeland since around 1200 BCE or so, three-thousand years ago. You see, Jess, when the League of Nations wrote "historic connection", this is all that they were referring to, all these foreign peoples preventing the Jews from reestablishing their national home in Eretz-Yisrael.
And the Arabs living in the area called themselves Southern Syrians and demanded at first that the British reunite "Palestine" with Syria.
D. At the end of the Mandate period, during which the Arabs consistently rejected all forms of compromise, they all went to war against Israel. Jews who had lived in the areas now known as the "West Bank" had been ethnically cleansed by the thousands from that area either by Mufti-led riots in 1920, 1921, 1929, 1936 and then during the war of aggression the Arabs launched following the November 29, 1947 Partition Plan mentioned above.
They lost. And the territory that the United Nations intended to become the Arab State in Palestine was conquered and occupied, illegally, by Jordan which later annexed it, also illegally.
E. In 1967, after years of continuous Arab terror, by at first the fedayeen in the 1950s and then the PLO/Fatah from 1964 when hundreds of Israelis were killed, the Arabs declared war against Israel. Jordan fired artillery shells into Israel and part of its army invaded Jerusalem.
Israel defended itself. Legally.
So Israel became the belligerent occupier of Judea, Samaria and Gaza. And it quite legally continues to administer those areas until a peace treaty is eventually signed, if the Arabs ever decide to negotiate in good faith.
In fact, the famous UN SC Resolution 242 demanding Israel's withdrawal from territories - and to who should those territories be "returned", as it were? To Jordan which illegally occupied them? 242 doesn't even mention any "Palestinians".
F. Now, according to the Geneva Convention you mention, III, can you point to a specific "crime" of "settling"? No. It doesn't exist. All point to Para. 49 which reads:
Individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territory to the territory of the Occupying Power or to that of any other country, occupied or not, are prohibited, regardless of their motive
No one has forced me or my neighbors to live here in Shiloh or other Jewish communities established since 1967. In fact, some of us are now in places where their parents or relatives lived prior to the 1948 war. No one transferred me here. No one deported me to here.
We're here quite legally.
In fact, even the US State Department isn't sure exactly how illegal, supposedly, "settlements" are.
Jess, those using that paragraph have twisted its meaning and intent and applicability.
E. And Jess, are we "illegally occupying" Jerusalem, the Jewish People's eternal capital? That's ridiculous, correct?
Jess, write to Lorde again and update her what you learned.
Tuesday, December 26, 2017
Demography Demonology Dead?
Israel, we have lectured to for five decades, cannot maintain its rule over Judea and Samaria because there are too many Arabs. It started in government deliberations in the months after the 1967 Six Days War and continued until today.
Or yesterday.
Here's the Haaretz report by Amira Hass:
Lebanon Census Finds Number of Palestinian Refugees Only a Third of Official UN Data
A census in Lebanon finds 175,000 Palestinian refugees living in the country, while the UN figure put their number at 500,000
Fox News via Associated Press:
Census shows there are 174,422 Palestinians in Lebanon
BEIRUT – The first official census of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon has revealed that there are 174,422 Palestinians now living in Lebanon, a figure almost two thirds less than previously estimated.
The Jewish Press asks:
How Did Lebanon Misplace a Quarter-Million ‘Palestinians’?
A based-in-England Arab outlet spins it this way:
Palestinians in Lebanon less than half previous estimate, census shows
Palestinian leaders believe revelation of fewer Palestinians in the country should encourage politicians to improve their conditions
And further informs that the
UNRWA welcomed the census and will be able to better plan its programmes with the “updated and accurate information...Now we will have scientific data in hand,”
And details the method:
The census was conducted by the Lebanese Central Administration of Statistics and the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics under the umbrella of the Lebanese Palestinian Dialogue Committee, a group formed by the Lebanese government to study and propose policies related to the Palestinian population.
Hundreds of Palestinian and Lebanese youth went from house to house with tablet computers to conduct the count, and the data was then linked to the location of the dwellings using a geographic information system, Director-General of the Lebanese Central Administration of Statistics Maral Tutelian Guidanian said.
The point is that
The census contradicts earlier estimates of more than 450,000 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon.
According to the official Palestinian Authority's population data, there were 2,935,368 Arabs residing in the territory they call the 'West Bank' at the end of 2016.
If we apply the Lebanese Theorem Principle, there are probably under 2,000,000 Arabs in that area in actuality.
We know that the data show that in 2015 24.4% of the West Bank population are refugees while 68.5% of Gaza Strip population are refugees.
We know the birth rate and fertility is low. We know the growth rate is low.
And now via Lebanon we know they cheat at statistics.
It would seem the Demography Threat is not as bad as it is portrayed.
_____________
Yoram Ettinger, who has been on this issue for years, just wrote me that his data indicates but 1.85 million Arabs living in Judea and Samaria.
Yakov Faitelson is also exact in details on this matter and accuses the Pal. Authority of hiding data.
Ian Lustick who has jettisoned the Two-State Solution long ago ("Dead Plan Walking"), and again just recently, and who believes that the "paths to political decisions in Israel and the United States that could result in that outcome via negotiations are so implausible that the negotiations themselves end up protecting and deepening oppressive conditions", has argued that population data is being manipulated - by Zionists. Who is been manipulating really?
^
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













