Monday, May 18, 2009

The Element of Historical Experience

From
Obama and the Middle East
By Hussein Agha, Robert Malley
New York Review of Books
Volume 56, Number 10 · June 11, 2009


What many critics of Israel seem incapable of accepting, these two, no 'lovers of Israel', are unabashed to write:

Aspirations reflect historical experience. For Israel's Jewish population, this includes displacement, persecution, the life of the ghetto, and the horrors of the Holocaust; and the long, frustrated quest for a normal, recognized, and accepted homeland. There is a craving for a future that will not echo the past and for the kind of ordinary security—the unquestioned acceptance of a Jewish presence in the region—that even overwhelming military superiority cannot guarantee. There is, too, at least among a significant, active segment of the Israeli population, a deep-seated attachment to the land, all of it, that constitutes Eretz Israel.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well, I stand corrected. I do not hate the Jewish country, I do not hate jews, what I do hate e.g. is a ultra-modern jewish army unleash on civilians to punish a piss poor terrorist organizations that only rule those same civilianz through terror. It's the death of civilians I hate Sir, not you. All appologiez for voicing my protest.

Martijn Lauwens said...

Beautiful words, anon.