Wednesday, August 08, 2007

Koestler's Letter from 1947

There is a new documentary being produced here in Israel on the hanging of the two British sergeants by the Irgun and I am helping out.

In the course of my work, I came across this, and want to share it with you.

Taken from the New Statesman archive, 16 August 1947

Letter to a Parent of a British soldier in Palestine
Arthur Koestler


Sixty years ago British soldiers were trying to keep the peace in Palestine. The hanging of two captured British sergeants by Jewish terrorists was an especially horrific crime that incensed British public opinion. Arthur Koestler sought to justify such an act in this anguished piece, which is still of painful relevance for our own times.

Dear Sir,


Every morning when you open your paper you feel sick with fear that your boy might have been kidnapped or blown to pieces by Jewish terrorists. I am a person who sympathises with terrorists, and though I disapprove of their recent methods, I might have become one of them – by force of circumstances. I am writing to you to explain those circumstances.

I am not speaking lightly of terror; during several years I have lived in the same anxiety, for persons near to me, which you feel for your son. The persons were my mother and her family; the danger which threatened them, as Jews in German-controlled territory, was death by poison gas or quicklime. My mother was the only one who escaped. Her sister, her sister’s daughter and two grandchildren were gassed. My mother's brother managed to commit suicide. Every single Jewish terrorist in Palestine has a similar story. This is the first fact you have to let sink in; without this background you will understand nothing.

Obviously you will answer that these regrettable deeds were committed by the Nazis and not by the British; that one of the reasons your boy fought this war was precisely to save those unfortunates; and that there is no excuse for the criminal madness of the thugs who, instead of showing gratitude, throw bombs at their benefactors. As against this, allow me to mention some facts, based on official British sources, which, I submit, prove that the Jews of Palestine have no reasons for gratitude to your country, and many reasons for bitterness against it. There is a legend that in 1917 Mr. Lloyd George's government, in the kindness of their hearts, promised Palestine to the Jews; since then the Jews have insisted on this somewhat rash promise like Shylock on his pound of flesh; while the unfortunate British, caught between the conflicting claims and bullets of Arab and Jew, carried heroically the White Man's Burden.

This is the legend; the facts about the motives which prompted the Lloyd George Cabinet to launch the Balfour declaration were explained by Mr. Lloyd George himself in his statement before the Royal Commission in 1937. In the autumn of 1917, at the time of the Russian collapse, the Allies were in a critical position. "In this critical situation it was believed that Jewish sympathy or the reverse would make a substantial difference one way or the other to the Allied cause." Thus originated the promise of a "National Home"; the meaning of this term was interpreted by Lloyd George, President Wilson, Cecil, Smuts, Winston Churchill, etc., as equivalent to a future Jewish state (Royal commission Report, pp. 23-25). The Zionist leaders, according to Lloyd George's statement, promised in exchange "to rally Jewish sentiment and support throughout the Allied cause. They kept their word." (ibid., p.23). It was an honest deal, supported on both sides by long-standing sympathies, not an act of charity, and the question of gratitude does not arise.

The second part of the story is the period between the two wars. I have no space to go into details, only to point out some salient facts. It is not true that the Jews came to Palestine under the protection of British bayonets, or at the expense of the British taxpayer, or with British help under any form, as many countrymen seem to believe. The transformation of Palestine within twenty years from a malaria-infested stretch of swamp and desert into the most fertile country of the Middle East is due to Jewish labour and capital. The part played by the British Administration was to run the public services, on taxes mainly levied from the Jews.

"But," you will object, “after all we did let the Jews come to Palestine in spite of Arab opposition didn’t we? We could just as well have locked them out, and saved ourselves all this trouble…” You are again misinformed. Palestine never was a Colony or Protectorate of yours: your job and raison d’ĂȘtre in that country was to administer a Mandate on behalf of the League of Nations and that Mandate put you under the obligation “to facilitate Jewish immigration,” to help the “close settlement by Jews of the land “ and finally the establishment of the “National Home.” The deal, concluded in 1917 and known as the Balfour Declaration, had been ratified by fifty-two nations and had become the legal basis, and the only basis, of your presence in Palestine.

The third part of the story starts in 1939, with the White Paper which Mr. Morrison, in the name of the Labour Party, called "a cynical breach of faith, a breach of British honour," and Mr. Churchill "a base betrayal, the filing of a petition in moral bankruptcy." You have probably heard about this famous document which, leaving details aside, amounted to the barring of Palestine to the Jews (after a last batch of 75,000) for ever, and led to the prohibition of the buying and cultivating of land by Jews in 95 per cent of the country’s total area (Land Transfer Act of February 1940). Thus at the very moment when the extermination of the European Jews began, the doors of Palestine were slammed in their faces; while those already inside Palestine were condemned to live in one more cramped, Oriental ghetto. This policy was not only inhuman, it was apparently also illegal in the terms of International Law, and this point is essential for the understanding of all further developments in Palestine. For legally, as already mentioned, Britain’s presence in Palestine was based on the Mandate. The League’s Permanent Mandate Commission met on June 16th, 1939, and found unanimously that the new policy contradicted the terms of the British trusteeship. Now according to Article 27 of the Mandate "the consent for the Council of the League of Nations is required for any modification of the terms of this mandate." The Council of the League was to meet in September, 1939, but meanwhile the war broke out and it never met. As the Mandatory Commission (and leading politicians of all parties in this country itself) had found that the White Paper was not only a "modification" of the Mandate but directly contradicted it, it could only gain legal validity by the League’s consent; and this consent was never given. This is the reason why terrorists refuse to recognize the jurisdiction of British Military Courts and prefer to be hanged without defending themselves; and they claim that Britain’s status in Palestine is that of an occupying Power, based on force, not on law. For similar reasons the Jewish Agency denies the validity of any discrimination between "legal" and "illegal" immigrants.

I am not an expert in International Law, but it seems incontestable, as a matter of common sense, that the pretence of administering a Home which people are not permitted to enter, even when in danger of their lives, is a moral and legal perfidy. The story of Palestine from 1939 to this day is essentially the story of people struggling to save their skins, and of British efforts to prevent this by force and diplomatic pressure. Here are a few examples.

In March and April, 1939, three refugee ships – S.S. Assandu, Astir and Assimi, packed with Jews who had escaped, mainly from Germany, reached Palestine, and were refused permission to land. In the House of Commons Mr. Noel-Baker asked the then Colonial Secretary, Mr. Malcolm MacDonald, what would happen to these people. Mr. MacDonald said that they had been sent back from where they came. Mr. Noel-Baker: "Does that mean to concentration camps?" Mr. MacDonald: "The responsibility rests on those responsible for organising illegal immigration." (Debate in the House of Commons, April 26th-27th, 1939.)

Do you recognise the tune? It is unchanged to this day. The responsibility rests with the "racketeers" who tried to save these condemned people, not with those who sent them back to their death. There was also much talk in 1937 about the insanitary conditions on these hell-ships. The gas chambers, the quicklime – and the dry rot of the D.P. camps to-day, were and are doubtless sanitary.

Try to put yourself into the place of a Jew of your own age on the jetty of Haifa, shouting and waving to a relative – your son for instance – on the deck of one of those ships; he is not permitted to land; the ship lifts anchor to take its doomed hysterical load back to where it came from. The figure of your boy grows smaller; a few years later you hear that he has been gassed in Oswiecim. If, instead of Smith, your name were Schmulewitz, it might have happened to you. Something on the same lines happened, among others, to a man whom I met in Palestine two years ago; he told me that his mother and three brothers had been killed “by German sadism and the British White Paper.” His name is Friedman Yellin, and he is head of the so-called Stern Gang.

More examples? On November 24th, 1940, the passengers of the steamer Patria, who had been refused admission to Palestine, blew their ship up in Haifa harbour. Over two hundred people were blown to bits or drowned a hundred yards from the promised shore. They were not even to have been deported back to Europe, which, owing to the war, was impossible; only to a tropical island in the Indian Ocean. But these people had become allergic to barbed wire. When a person reaches that state, like the survivors in the D.P. camps to-day, he is past listening to the reasonable voice which tells him that he should never have escaped, or saved his wife and children, without a permit in triplicate to do so.

One last example. The year is 1942; the crematoria in Europe had started to work, when another hell-ship, the 180-ton cattle-boat Struma, hailing from Constanza, floundered into the harbour of Istanbul. There were 769 escapees on board, several of whom had lost their reason. The Turks were prepared to let them land in transit, on condition that the British would permit their entry into Palestine. This the Palestine Government, after consultation with London, refused; so the Turks sent the boat back to Rumania. The rest of the story you can guess: the ship blew up within a few miles of the Turkish coast; one man survived; all other passengers, including 250 women and 70 children were drowned.

The Black Sea was the Jews' main life-line of escape from the European crematorium. The Struma cut that life-line. Those who, against law and morality, refused to grant its passengers entry into Palestine, did not want them to be drowned. They were presumably even sorry and surprised. All they wanted was that they should be sent back to their "port of embarkation," where they could wash their hands of them, and thus discourage others from trying to save their skins. In the parliamentary debate of April, 1939, from which I have quoted, the Colonial Secretary had said that the Government had the fullest sympathy with Jewish refugees, but if they allowed one shipload, more would follow. This has been the guiding principle of British policy in Palestine from 1939 to this day. It was a policy of deliberately obstructing by active and passive measures, by force and by diplomatic pressure, the escape of Jews from extermination by a mass exodus into Palestine. I have quoted to you a few examples of this policy; they could be multiplied. Further evidence of the deliberate character of this policy is available, but cannot be published at this moment. But perhaps some future commission of inquiry into the administration of the Palestine Mandate will find it useful to ask, i.a., H.M. former ambassador in Anka to disclose the instructions he received during the critical period before and after the Struma episode.

The White Paper of 1939 has been described as the Palestine Munich. After the Labour victory of 1945 everybody expected that his last relic of Chamberlain’s policy would be wiped out. No party was so deeply committed to support Jewish immigration into Palestine as the Labour Party. On no fewer that eleven occasions, from 1917 to 1945, the Annual Party Conference had reaffirmed this obligation. In 1939 Philip Noel-Baker had prophesied that, if the White Paper was adopted, the only way to stop refugees would be "to tell those kindly British soldiers to shoot them down." In 1944, the Party conference had affirmed that "there is surely neither hope nor meaning in a 'Jewish National Home' unless we are prepared to let the Jews enter if they wish." In 1945, just before the Labour Government took office, this policy was once more confirmed, and Hugh Dalton declared that “it is morally wrong and politically indefensible to impose obstacles to entry into Palestine now of any Jews who desire to go there." You know the rest of the story. It is the story of yet another broken pledge; of the triumph of a Foreign Office clique and Ernest Bevin’s pigheadedness over Labour's honour.

But this time the Jews' patience is exhausted. On practically every hell-ship which approaches Palestine one or two survivor are shot down because they resist the boarding parties which carry them off to yet another cage, in the name of a policy which is "morally wrong and politically indefensible". As a result, the Jews have shown that they can fight as ruthlessly and as savagely as any other people driven to despair. Political terrorism has not been invented by them, as the penny press tries to make people in this country believe; it is as old as injustice and oppression, which is its cause. From the days of Spartacus to the French and Yugoslav maquis, the men who fought oppression by violence were called bandits by those who turned Law and Order into a mockery; and patriots and heroes if they succeeded. But this romantic halo is only given them by posterity, or distant sympathisers. Looked at from close to, the deeds of the Paris Commune, or the Russian Social-Revolutionaries, or Tito's Partisans, all shows the same ugly and revolting details: retaliations, expropriations, armed robberies, bombs, execution of hostages. And it is always the innocents who foot the bill, like Sergeants Martin and Paice, like your boys, who have to carry out a loathsome and immoral policy; for they are under orders, and they know not what they do.

The reason, according to Mr. Bevin, for using men o' war and paratroopers to fight the inglorious battle of the Palestine beaches, is Britain's duty to protect Arab interests – another version of the White Man's Burden. In fact, the situation between Jew and Arab in Palestine is much the same as between Moslem and Hindu in India. The proportion of Moslem to Hindu is roughly 1 to 3; of Jew to Arab roughly 1 to 2. In some fields, where their interests are parallel, they collaborate; in all major points their culture and political aspirations clash. As there is no hope of reconciling these for a considerable time, the inevitable solution is to partition the country. This is hard luck on the Arabs; but they have thrived on this hard luck and grown in health and prosperity as never before in history. It is also hard luck on the Jews; for the Mandate gave them Palestine including Transjordan, and now they will have to be content themselves with a fraction of one-half of it. It may be argued that it was wrong to promise in 1917 a predominantly Arab country to the Jews, but this argument leads nowhere; for to-day the Jewish third in Palestine is a fact which cannot be undone, nor can their fields and orange groves be reconverted into desert and marsh. Since the Royal Commission recommended partition in 1937, every level-headed observer has agreed to this – except the Labour Party, which urged a Jewish State in the whole of Palestine.

But, you will object, all this may be true and very regrettable; however, now that we have passed the whole problem on to Uno it is for them, and no longer for us, to decide. Again you have been misled. The Uno Commission is not the first which has been asked to suggest a policy for Palestine – it is, if I remember rightly, the seventeenth or eighteenth. The Royal Commission in 1937 suggested partition; the Chamberlain Government issued the White Paper instead. Last year we had the Anglo-American Commission; your Foreign Secretary pledged himself to carry out their suggestion if they were unanimous; they were unanimous; they were not carried out. The methods which Mr. Bevin used to sabotage any constructive solution, to get out of his Party’s, his Government’s, and his personal commitments, sounded more than anything like the subterfuges of a Jewish pettifogger. The terms under which he passed the matter on to Uno contain the same loopholes as the previous invitations to other bodies to make “suggestions.” He referred to Uno as an International Tribunal – but reserved the right to accept or reject the Tribunal’s verdict. In the light of their past experiences, it is not surprising that the Palestine Jews suspect this latest move of being another subterfuge to gain time and to continue a policy based on principles which Mr. Bevin’s colleagues in the Cabinet have branded as morally and politically indefensible. The one proof of the honesty of his intentions would be for him to state unequivocally that Britain will either accept Uno’s verdict or surrender the Mandate and clear out.

Meanwhile two things can be done to stop the vicious circle of terror and retaliation. The first is to go to Uno with constructive proposals for a just partition of the country, to be enforced if need be with international help – instead of presenting a record of impotency and bankruptcy. The second is to raise the monthly immigration quota from 1,500 to 5,000 during the period of transition without political conditions, as a minimum gesture of good will. I can assure you, on the strength of many years of experience in Palestine, that this alone would be enough to lead to an immediate suspension of terrorism and at least to a kind of armistice while Uno’s decision is pending.

Is it as simple as that? It is as simple as that. And if public opinion still has a say in your country, now is the time to stop disaster. For the Jews of Palestine fight for one thing only, for the oldest slogan in their history: Let My People Go. There were six million of them in Europe; only one of ten is left. Your countrymen are very fond of the word decency; if you have any left, let them go.

If you refuse, you will have to take the consequences, which may be more serious than you think. For you should understand that there is more at stake here than meets the eye. A great Empire which rules the seven seas can afford to flaunt the world’s opinion. But you are no longer that; you cannot afford to put might before right; and you have already antagonised on this issue public opinion in just the two countries you need most: the U.S.A. and France. The future of a country which is on the downward grade in terms of power depends more than on anything else on its moral integrity. Palestine is a test for your integrity; and in more than one sense your fate is linked with hers.

Yours truly,

ARTHUR KOESTLER

Something to Monitor

Read this:-

President Bush, in his July 16 statement, announced the United States is strengthening its financial commitment to the Palestinian people and the government led by President Abbas and Prime Minister Salam Fayyad. The President announced the intention of the United States to provide $80 million to help the Palestinians reform their security services and improve the lives of the Palestinian people.

Today, Secretary Rice and Prime Minister Fayyad signed a Framework Agreement to establish a mechanism to move forward with the President’s commitment.

The Framework Agreement formalizes the intention of the United States to provide assistance to the Palestinian Authority to promote law and order by strengthening and reforming the Palestinian security sector. The Framework Agreement contains the terms and conditions designed to ensure that U.S. assistance funds will be used for the purposes agreed upon and in a fully accountable manner.

Under the Framework Agreement, U.S. assistance will be used to enhance the capability of the Palestinian security sector, including through training. The United States and the Palestinian Authority have worked together closely to design this program and will continue to cooperate in its implementation.

I Love an Optimist

Defense Minister Ehud Barak attributes great importance to speeding up the development of technological defenses against rocket fire on the home front, as he considers this a precondition for any significant withdrawal from the West Bank.

Such a withdrawal would put Israel's main population centers in Qassam rocket range of the Palestinian Authority. Therefore, Barak believes, Israel must first develop and deploy an effective anti-missile system - a process that is expected to take three to five years.


So, when "peace" comes, we need to be prepared for...more rockets.

Great.

Of course, maybe he has plans...

A Qassam rocket fired by Palestinian militants struck the northern Gaza Strip on Tuesday, killing an eight-year-old boy and his six-year-old sister, and injuring five other children.

The rocket, fired at Israel, fell short and hit the children's house in the village of Beit Lahiya. No group claimed responsibility.

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

But Not Quite

BBC, in its report on today's expulsion, informs us that

Hebron is the only place in the Israeli-occupied West Bank where a small community of Jewish settlers lives in the heart of a Palestinian city.


A Palestinian city?

Not quite.

An "Arab-populated city"? Perhaps.

Hebron is a Jewish city and in 1929, it was ethnically cleansed by Arabs. It's history as a Jewish city is well-documented and attested to by Jewish and non-Jewish sources.

Ethnic Cleansing

I left a comment on the matter here.

So, We May Lose Some Local Arabs?

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is examining a new framework for peace in which Israel will propose transferring to the Palestinian state areas equivalent to 100 percent of the territories conquered in 1967.

Israel will suggest to the Palestinians to conduct negotiations for adequate territorial compensation from Israel's sovereign territory, in exchange for settlement blocs amounting to about 5 percent of the West Bank's area.

Israel is also examining various options of exchanging settlement blocs with Arab community blocs within Israel, in agreement with the residents. An agreement on this issue would enable Yisrael Beiteinu, headed by Avigdor Lieberman, to remain in the coalition.

From My Mailbox

I am linked here.

And I was sent a link to my June 12, 1988 letter in the New York Times Magazine.

Monday, August 06, 2007

Ever Taken A Ride With Her?

New book coming out on August 28 (and Jewess will be happy, I presume). It's called
Hack: How I Stopped Worrying About What to Do with My Life and Started Driving a Yellow Cab and the authoress is Melissa Plaut.

Here's the cover:-



Yes, a Jewish Jewess hack driver.

Plaut decided to become a New York City cabbie after getting laid off from a job as an advertising copywriter, then began posting about her interactions with patrons on a blog that forms the backbone of this memoir.

Here she is behind the wheel:-



Here's a recent excerpt (okay, from June, but I was looking for Jewish content) from her blog:-

Business was pretty steady all night, but I had a long lull when I made a few back-to-back trips to Brooklyn. The first was to Midwood, a suburban-ish neighborhood largely occupied by Orthodox Jews. It was a decent job but it took forever to get there for some reason, so I hustled back to Manhattan as fast as I could. When I finally got over the Brooklyn Bridge, I turned south down Broadway and was immediately hailed by a Hasidic man.

When he got in, he said, "I'm going to Brooklyn, take the tunnel." He was, of course, going to Borough Park, just a few neighborhoods west of Midwood.

Later on, when I talked to my fellow cabbie Allen about this turn of events, he said, "What? You picked up a Hasid?" Allen himself is an Orthodox Jew. "And he went to Borough Park?" When I said yes, he laughed and said, "Well, what did you expect?!"

Again, it took me forever to get back. The BQE was backed up so I decided to take the surface streets instead. Nearly 60 blocks later, in Park Slope, I picked up a passenger. I felt lucky for a second, thinking he was going to the city, but as it turned out, he was only going a short distance, out toward the Brooklyn Museum, a six dollar ride.


More info on her here.

Here she is on her big break at ABC TV news

Do We Do This?

BlogDay.

What is BlogDay?

BlogDay was created with the belief that bloggers should have one day dedicated to getting to know other bloggers from other countries and areas of interest. On that day Bloggers will recommend other blogs to their blog visitors. With the goal in mind, on this day every blogger will post a recommendation of 5 new blogs. This way, all blog readers will find themselves leaping around and discovering new, previously unknown blogs.

What will happen on BlogDay?

On one long moment on August 31st, bloggers from all over the world will post recommendations of 5 new Blogs, preferably Blogs that are different from their own culture, point of view and attitude. On this day, blog readers will find themselves leaping around and discovering new, unknown Blogs, celebrating the discovery of new people and new bloggers.

BlogDay posting instructions:

Find 5 new Blogs that you find interesting.

Notify the 5 bloggers that you are recommending them as part of BlogDay 2007

Write a short description of the Blogs and place a link to the recommended Blogs
Post the BlogDay Post (on August 31st) and Add the BlogDay tag using this link:
http://technorati.com/tag/BlogDay2007 and a link to the BlogDay web site at http://www.blogday.org

So Easy To Lose

Well, we lost a lot of guns during the Oslo Accords period, when Peres armed the Pals. and now, it's America's turn:-

Weapons Given to Iraq Are Missing
GAO Estimates 30% of Arms Are Unaccounted For


By Glenn Kessler
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, August 6, 2007; Page A01

The Pentagon has lost track of about 190,000 AK-47 assault rifles and pistols given to Iraqi security forces in 2004 and 2005, according to a new government report, raising fears that some of those weapons have fallen into the hands of insurgents fighting U.S. forces in Iraq.

The author of the report from the Government Accountability Office says U.S. military officials do not know what happened to 30 percent of the weapons the United States distributed to Iraqi forces from 2004 through early this year as part of an effort to train and equip the troops. The highest previous estimate of unaccounted-for weapons was 14,000, in a report issued last year by the inspector general for Iraq reconstruction.

Q-43 Was My Bus

I have an opportunity to get private personal now.

I grew up in Holliswood, a Queens neighborhood of New York City. There were 9 apartment buildings, each with an A side and a B side, seven floors each and eight apartments per floor. All that makes, just a second now, 928 apartments (plus a few on the bottom floors here and there).

The closest subway station was the last stop (then) for the E and F trains at 179th Street of Hillside Avenue. We lived on Francis Lewis Boulevard which was 204th Street for all intents and purposes (and the Avenue was 87th).

To get to the 179th St. stop, we took buses. One of those was the Q-43 which also transported me to my Junior High School at 218th St., if I recall. Nope, it was 213th Street and 92nd Avenue, south of Hillside.

Well, I just came across a Q-43 story:-

NYC bus driver, rider arrested in seat dispute

A bus driver struck a passenger about the head with a phone after the rider refused to give up his seat to an elderly woman, police said.

The driver, Larry Woods, 44, and the rider, Christian Custis, 22, were arrested and charged with assault and harassment after the incident on the Q43 bus in the Jamaica section of Queens. Woods was also charged with criminal possession of a weapon. The men were arraigned in Queens Criminal Court.

According to police, Woods asked Custis to give up his seat when the woman using a cane boarded the bus at Hillside Avenue and 164th Street on Friday. Custis refused, police said. The driver then hit Custis about the head with the bus' onboard phone.

The men were treated for minor injuries at Mary Immaculate Hospital before being arrested.

Don't You Just Love Democracy?

Hizb ut-Tahrir, founded in the early 1950s by a Palestinian judge dissatisfied with the Muslim Brotherhood, has existed in Britain for a number of years and remains legal in other Western countries, including the United States. But it is banned in a number of Muslim countries, particularly those — including Egypt, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia — that feel vulnerable to its calls for the overthrow of their governments.

The group was banned by the German Interior Ministry in 2003 for “spreading hate and violence,” under a chapter in Germany’s Constitution that is often used to clamp down on anti-Semitism. Hizb ut-Tahrir is appealing the ban.


Their "solution" for the Israel-Palestine conflict:-

Only by a return to an Islamic state that existed for centuries can both justice and security be regained for all. Why is this?

1. Two states would further separate Jews, Muslims and Christians, entrenching division between communities and families. It is a classic divide and rule policy that imperial regimes have implemented in the past and it is not surprising that both President Bush and Prime Minister Blair now support such a solution.

2. Allowing Israel to keep occupied land from 1948 would reward aggression and the ethnic cleansing that took place shortly after.

3. According to demographic trends, Muslims will outnumber Jews in 10 years or so and polls have clearly shown their preference for Islamic rule and hence a rejection of the so called 'roadmap' which would hand most of Palestine including Jerusalem to the Israelis.

4. A ‘Palestinian state’ that is being suggested, created out of the remnants of pre-1967 borders, is not a viable state; it will have no real resources, no real sovereignty and would be reliant on Israel for its survival. Such a state would also be a betrayal of the memories of Umar bin al-Khattab, Salahuddin and those who stood up for the holiest of lands against the tyranny of other foreign invasions.

Of course many in Israel and their right wing supporters abroad will oppose such a solution but tens of millions today including many Jews oppose the status quo and the proposed flawed two state model. Yet Jews, Muslims and Christians lived largely in peace and security under an Islamic government for much of the last fourteen centuries in Palestine, in Islamic Spain and under the Ottoman Caliphate. Unlike Israel’s neo-apartheid system, an Islamic state is not a racial state and would not treat non-Muslims as second class citizens. Muhammad (saw) made this very clear when he said, "He who abuses a dhimmi [non-Muslim citizen] then I will be his rival and dispute him on the Day of Judgment."

...the one state solution of the Islamic Caliphate is now the only viable option for delivering security for Jews, Christians and Muslims of the region. Allah asks the believers to stand up for justice and to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong. That, dear brothers and sisters, is our duty and our call!

Hizb ut-Tahrir Britain
19 Jumada al Awwal 1428
7 June 2007
www.hizb.org.uk


So, while Muslim countries are scared out of their minds, Britain doesn't really care.

This reminds of Political Correctness.

You know, the doctrine fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and rabidly promoted by an unscrupulous mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition
that it is entirely possible to pick up a turd by the clean end.

Mezuzot? Not Muses?

When I first heard that a Rabbi was warning against kissing, I though it was an Orthodox Rabbi warning against kissing "muses", like these:-




But, no, it was "mezuzot", really:-

A Conservative rabbi has recently ruled that kissing mezuzot should be avoided, in order to avoid the risk of contracting an infectious disease.

Rabbi Simcha Roth issued the ruling after he was approached by members of his congregation who expressed concern over the possibility that kissing a mezuzah which has been kissed by other people may constitute a health hazard.

The Cerebral Exile or, The Forgetfullness of Being

Yishai Fleisher, a founder of Kumah, and a broadcaster at Israel National Radio (aka Arutz 7) has a great op-ed in Ynet:-

A state of exile

A methodical exile is taking place; the exile of location and exile of the mind



Excerpts -

...But what then is a full exile? A full exile is when the connection between the land and the people is forgotten. If there is no memory of prior ownership, no longing to return, no stories told to children, then the exile brought about by an enemy nation which wished to impose a disconnect between the people and its land comes into full effect. If the very fact that the nation has been exiled is forgotten, then that is true exile.

The idea that the loss of collective national memory brings true exile has a surprising corollary: a nation can be in a state of exile even while living on its original soil! Like a person suffering from amnesia while sitting in his own house – a nation may be so utterly without memory that it has no idea that it is at home.

Such is the case in Israel today. The memory that has been carried in our collective conscience for two thousand years has steadily worn away and no longer serves to keep the exile at bay...

...As we have noted, physical exile is one thing, but cerebral exile, the cutting off of memory is the final guillotine of exile. Here, the groundwork for forced forgetting has been in the works for decades. On the one hand, the Jewish people's historical connection to the land has been systematically un-taught. In schools, many Jewish children learn to hate the Bible, learn a revisionist anti-Zionist history, and are simply never taught the stories and the emotional connection to places like Rachel's Tomb. On the other hand, a new milieu and accompanying lingo fill the void left in the young mind: Occupation, Palestine, Peace, and Post-Zionism. Our history and with it, our emotional connection to our land, is being erased.

...Today, those who still teach and preach a connection with these places are branded extremists, so their message makes little sense to our people. Say the word "Hebron" to a young disconnected Israeli and he will only conjure up an occupied Arab city with a few cantankerous crazy Jews who cause all the problems. The majesty of Hebron's history from Abraham to King David to the first Hasidic settlement of 18th century, to the murderous Arab riots of 1929, to the valiant return in 1967, is completely lost on him. It is no wonder then that for him it makes sense to "give it back" since nothing seems to tie us to these places in the first place.

Today's post–Zionist leaders have made Israel into a State of Exile, exiling our people from their homes, exiling our land by cutting it off and giving it away, and exiling the minds and hearts of the Jewish people by teaching them to forget. After waiting for two thousand years to return, Jews are being taught that Hebron isn't Jewish, that Bethlehem isn't Jewish, that Nablus isn't Jewish, that the Temple Mount isn't Jewish. A methodical exile is taking place, the exile of place and the exile of mind.

Sunday, August 05, 2007

Sorry, But In My Blog It Fits Perfectly

What is going to hapen to all the news that doesn't fit?

In a front page note to readers this morning, the [New York Times] stated that the print edition they will hold tomorrow will be decidedly more compact.

Beginning Monday, the Times "will reduce the width of its pages by an inch and a half," to a 12-inch standard, the paper declared.

"The move will cut newsprint expenses and, in some printing press locations, will make special configurations unnecessary. Slight modifications in design will preserve the look and texture of The Times, with all existing features and sections, and" -- it admitted at the end -- "somewhat fewer words per page."


Source.

The Beguiling Tom Segev

Tom Segev of Haaretz quotes Professor Renana Meridor, Eliyahu Meridor's widow and mother of Salai, Dan and Avital (there's another sister):-

Renana Meridor from Jerusalem writes in response to the affair of the Nakba being mentioned in textbooks, which was surveyed here last week: "Both Arab schoolchildren and Jewish schoolchildren in Israel are apparently not allowed to know that at the end of the hostilities of 1948, the part of Mandatory Palestine which remained in the hands of the Arabs was 'cleansed of Jews,' as all its Jewish residents were either killed or expelled from it."


but adds:

What both Jewish and Arab children ought to know is the following:

It is true that no Jews remained in some of the territories of Mandatory Palestine, which remained in Arab hands at the end of the hostilities of 1948. Most of the Jews who fled and were expelled lived in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem, in the settlements of Gush Etzion, in Atarot and in Neveh Yaakov - a total of no more than 2,500 people, less than half of 1 percent of the Jews who then resided in the country. The Arab refugees numbered 650,000, and fewer than 150,000 Arabs remained in the territory of Israel after the war.


Besides leaving out a few places, notably the Labour movement's kibbuzt, Bet Ha'aravah, Segev fails to note that many more places were set aside by the UN to be included in the borders of the "Arab state" and they would have suffered the same fate of ethnic cleansing not to mention what I have repeatedly poasted here, that this policy of ethnic cleansing by Arabs directed at Jews started at Tel Hai in 1920 already.

Jewess Has Linked Me

Thanks Rebecca.

Feldman Gets Floored (in my opinion) - UPDATED

Noah Feldman, brilliant law professor, was peeved that his Korean wife, who did not convert, was not accepted into his Yeshiva high school class reunion group photo.

It happens.

But Noah, who is at Harvard and maybe has some friends at the New York Times, what Wonkette mistakenly thinks is the 'Jew-York Times', you should pardon me for spreading about a bit of Judeophobia filth from that left-wing, radical blog, wrote a big asrticle about his problem for their Sunday Magazine.

Here are three good letters in reaction:

Beyond serving as a forum for graduates to keep up with one another, a school alumni newsletter is a powerful marketing tool that showcases for potential students the accomplishments of the school’s graduates. For Noah Feldman to expect his Jewish day school to report on news of his marrying outside the Jewish faith is, effectively, asking his school to publish the following promotional ad: “Come spend 12 years steeped in Jewish religious texts and Jewish identity-building, and you, too, may become successful and intermarry.”

Bluma Zuckerbrot-Finkelstein

Memphis

I am a Korean-American who converted to Judaism (mikvah included) when I married my Jewish husband. We are active members of our conservative synagogue, and our children go to Jewish day schools. During the 17 years since my conversion, I have been fully accepted into the Jewish community as a Jew, including the ultra-Orthodox community. Judaism dictates that descendants are the religion of the mother. I believe that this tenet is crucial to the survival of the Jewish religion in the ever-increasing numbers of interracial marriages.

Leona Kim Schluger, M.D.

Millwood, N.Y.

Feldman’s article could have inspired discussion of the issue of intermarriage in the modern Orthodox Jewish world, but his presentation precludes such discourse. Like any expert litigator, he has selectively emphasized certain facts to misrepresent the truth. He speaks of Baruch Goldstein at length, ignoring that the overwhelming majority of Orthodox Jews condemned his massacre of Palestinians as morally repugnant. Even Feldman’s portrayal of Joe Lieberman seems like a backhanded jab at modern Orthodoxy. After ostensibly glorifying Lieberman’s “overt normalcy,” why compare his phylacteries to the cilice of Opus Dei? Why encourage people to wonder what kind of backward, medieval man lurks within the senator’s suit?

Jenny Brenner

Efrat, Israel


==================

and this just in:-

Noah Feldman, who ignited a firestorm of criticism last week with his pointed attack on Modern Orthodoxy in The New York Times Magazine, admitted this week that he learned before publication of his article that he in fact was not intentionally cropped out of his reunion photograph.

In the article, "Orthodox Paradox," Feldman, a Harvard Law School professor, asserts that he was erased from a newsletter's photograph by his former yeshiva, the Maimonides School in Brookline, Mass., because he was standing alongside his non-Jewish girlfriend. The reunion anecdote led off the story in a dramatic way and the image of Feldman and his wife allegedly being stricken from the photo appeared central to his feelings of being left out.

The photographer, Lenny Eisenberg, told The Jewish Week Monday that he had difficulty capturing as many as 60 reunion participants within a single frame. Eisenberg ended up taking several shots from one side, then the other, and several people on the far side -- not just Feldman and his fiancee -- happened to be out of the picture when it finally appeared in the newsletter...

...Eisenberg, who is now based in New York, said the Times "paid my way to go back to [his Boston studio] and find the negative. They wanted to run the [reunion] picture to illustrate" Feldman's claim of being discriminated against because of his relationship with a non-Jew. Eisenberg returned with the photo but the Times opted not to publish it, he said, when it became obvious that there was no cropping but simply an overflowing of reunion participants beyond the camera's range.


Come to think of it, if he had testified on the stand at a trial like this, he would have been held for pejury.

Nice going, Feldman.

==============

And nice going David Frum.

Aim for the Center with Your Prayers



Never lose your direction.

Friday, August 03, 2007

Who are these people?



Here's the story:-

Israeli and Palestinian transport unions have forged a groundbreaking cooperation agreement at a special meeting held under the auspices of the ITF.

Around 20 Israeli and Palestinian transport union representatives met together in Limassol, Cyprus on 31 July – 1 August as guests of the ITF’s Cypriot affiliate the Federation of Transport, Petroleum and Agricultural Workers. There they discussed common issues such as collective bargaining, delayed payment of wages, loss of union membership and the increasing outsourcing of work to contractors. They agreed to establish a joint liaison committee to provide a mechanism for dealing with practical problems faced by transport workers in the region and for building trust between Israeli and Palestinian transport unions.

...This agreement was set out in a joint declaration signed by Avi Edri Chairman of the Histadrut Transportation Workers’ Union; Naser Yunes, President of the Palestinian General Federation of Transport Workers Unions and David Cockroft, ITF General Secretary.


(Kippah tip: Harry's Place)

I just hope none of those transport vehicles will be used to fruther...apartheid, especially not the Pal. Authority.

Reviewing Comments at Wonkette

All all remember my contretemps with Wonkette?

If not, here's a roundup and the itsy-bitsy NYTimes reference.

Anyway, I decided to give another look and, thank the Lord, there were some brave people who got good comments in (they, of course, did not include mine).

Here they are:-

BY BUBBE AT 07/23/07 12:33 PM
So it's open season on Jews? Is this just NY or all the US?
BY THE DUDE AT 07/23/07 12:33 PM
Why the blatant Anti-Semitism? It's not only revolting but it helps discredit any valid point you might make.
BY THE DUDE AT 07/23/07 12:33 PM
And why am I the first to point this out? [no, you weren't but they threatened me]
BY DR.DAWG AT 07/23/07 02:25 PM
"Jew-liani?" "Jew York Times?" I thought I'd come to a left-wing site. I used to see that sort of thing in places, well, like this: [www.stormfront.org] [www.stormfront.org] Have you lost your minds? Do we need that kind of vulgar anti-Semitic flourish to drive home the progressive point of view? And here I've been arguing, literally for years, with conservatives who claim that the Left is anti-Semitic. I'd been doing pretty well until now. Thanks a bunch, people.
BY PALEOAMERICAN AT 07/23/07 03:10 PM
Don't blame Booby Jewliani for being out of touch he hasn't dropped by his strategic command and intelligence center located at 7 WTC in quite awhile. [the closet antisemite]
BY JEN06 AT 07/23/07 05:03 PM
One of the great things about this Wonkette post is how beautifully it demonstrates that Jew-hatred exists totally independent of fact. Rudy is not a Jew. The family that owns the New York Times converted to Episcopalianism some time ago--and the paper itself is at best center-disparaging when it comes to issues affecting Jews.
Yet it it seemed good--even witty--to the Wonkette poster (and, one assumes, Wonkette itself) to make these stupid, fact-free name changes.
BY AMERICANA AT 07/23/07 06:06 PM
It took far too long for people to call this moronic poster our for his blatant antisemitism.
BY KHARGUSHOGHLI AT 07/24/07 11:43 AM
I agree with the Dr. Dawg et al. I read about this posting on a loony right blog, American Thinker [www.americanthinker.com] and figured it was just another case of the manufactured scandal about The Daily Kos. Shocked and saddened to see that this time it's true. How the HELL did this posting get on Wonkette? I think the author owes the readers and explanation and/or an apology. And the posters should do a bit of introspection about why this stupid Jew-baiting didn't phase them.
BY ANNOYEDMAN AT 07/24/07 02:04 PM
Talk about "shock and awe"...I am shocked by and in awe of the Jew hatred displayed here, and I am continually amazed at my liberal Jewish friends who blithely countenance this kind of Nazi bullshit from their political fellow travelers. Truly, antisemiticism and Jewish self-loathing are alive and well. What a terrible shame.
BY 9031 AT 07/25/07 02:37 AM
@Hans_Auff:
grow up
BY ELISSON AT 07/25/07 10:15 AM
"Rudolph Jew-Liani"? What, exactly, is your point? This sort of casual anti-Semitism isn't something I would expect to see in an intelligently-written political blog. (And I don't whip out the "anti-semitism" term at the drop of a canard.) I guess I'll have to revise my opinion...that bit about the "intelligently-written political blog" will have to go. Sad.

It's Not Only a Matter of AIDS

Brit Milah [circumcision for the uninitiated - that a pun. the professional guild of circumcisers in England is called The Initiation Society](*) not only helps prevent AIDS, but it can be helpful for sexual relations.

The Jews win again!

I wrote about this before, that there was a study that circumcision may stop millions of HIV deaths.

But now, we go one step further:

Study: Circumcision Doesn't Reduce Sexual Sensation
New Research Fuels Continuing Debate Over Foreskin Removal


Excerpts:-

Controversial new research casts doubt on the long-held belief that circumcision reduces sexual sensitivity for men who have undergone the procedure.

Circumcision, a procedure performed throughout history, for reasons ranging from the fulfillment of a biblical covenant to a means of curbing masturbation [???], has received both praise by those who tout its supposed medical benefits and scorn from those who claim it has traumatic aftereffects.

Now, in a Canadian study appearing in the most recent issue of the Journal of Sexual Medicine, researchers found that the glans, or head of the penis, is just as sensitive on a circumcised man as on an uncircumcised one.

"It's probably the best study I've seen of this kind of work," said June Reinisch, the former director of the Kinsey Institute. Reinisch was not involved with the study.

...The American Academy of Pediatrics reflects that doubt in its official policy, which states: "Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision."

...While psychologist Kimberley Payne, one of the study's authors, said the research seems to refute the idea that the foreskin keeps the penis sensitive, she was hesitant to draw a broader conclusion from her study.

"This just scratched the surface [another pun?], and there is so much more to look at," she said.

She said ultimately she hoped someone would be able to measure the full range of sexual sensation in circumcised and uncircumcised men during sex, but was unsure how that would be done.

A Rising Controversy [this ABC reporter is having fun]

Anti-circumcision groups were quick to criticize Payne's study.

The International Coalition for Genital Integrity released a statement saying, "Poor research investigating the sensitivity of the intact [not circumcised] and circumcised penis does not serve men."

Missing the Point? [here we go again]

In the end, Reinisch said, circumcision will not affect a man's ability to be aroused or experience sexual pleasure.

"Nature has certainly provided an enormous amount of sexually sensitive tissue," she said, calling the brain the most powerful sex organ of all.

"I'm not suggesting everyone be circumcised," said Reinisch. "I'm suggesting that there are some benefits. & I believe it's really a personal choice."


----------

(*) Of historical interest, here's a site of those who contributed to the Initiation Society to permit widows to afford the cost of the circumcision in the 1880s.

And What About Arab "Settlements"?

NYT reports:-

Saudi officials said a precondition of its attendance was that the conference tackle the four big “final status” issues that had bedeviled peace negotiators since 1979: the fate of Palestinian refugees who fled or were forced to flee their homes in Israel, mostly before or during the 1948 war; the status of Jerusalem; the borders of a Palestinian state; and the dismantlement of Israeli settlements in the West Bank.


And Arab "settlements"? In Israel?

Cannot we consider them illegal or, at the least, possible "switchers" for those Jewish revenant communities built in that portion of the Jewish historic patrimony originally intended to be the reconstituted Jewish homeland by the international community back in 1920-23?

Advice to Yesha Revenants

I read this report below and I think that the farmer

(a) need not have used any violence unless an actual, imminent threat was apparent.

(b) he should nevertheless make a complaint to the Journalists' Association for the use of non-media vehicles. After all, we complain when the Pals. use, say, ambulances or the Left claim the IDF uses media vehicles.

(c) he should complain to Tzippi Livni on the actions of the UN vehicle.

And remember, always carry a camera. They are so small nowadays, they wouldn't interfere with any pruning.

======

U.N. Drove Journalists To Cover Story
(IsraelNN.com) An official United Nations vehicle took a reporter and photographer for the Israeli newspaper Ha'aretz past the olive groves of a resident of the Jewish community of Mitzpe Yair Thursday night, causing a confrontation. Ha'aretz alleged that the Jewish farmer jumped on the vehicle and broke the windshield, injuring the driver. However, a resident said that the windshield broke when the driver braked the car and that the Jewish farmer was injured.

The newspaper stated that the U.N. vehicle drove by Mitzpe Yair, in the southern Hevron Hills, after visiting a nearby Arab village. The Jewish farmer charged that their intent was to uproot his trees.

Thursday, August 02, 2007

That's a Big 'If'

And also a dumb one.

What 'if'? This one:-

Israel Our Home MK David Rotem says he is ready to do everything to reach peace, including blowing up the Western Wall.

Cohen's answer came in response to a question during an interview with Voice of Peace Radio about how his hawkish party can justify remaining in a coalition with a government who is holding talks with the Palestinians, something his party opposed.
Rotem emphasized that even so-called rightists, in Israel, were pro-peace, adding that he himself would do almost anything to ensure it.

"If they guarantee to me that by blowing up the Western Wall I can save the life of one person, I will place an explosives device near it and destroy it because I am really ready to do everything for peace if I have a real partner for peace," he added.


Why not blow up the Knesset, the Supreme Court or are those scared left/liberal locations?

Theater of the Really Absurd

There's a new theater production afoot, "Jihad - The Musical".

The Plot:-

JIHAD THE MUSICAL tells the story of a young Afghan peasant, Sayid. Coming from the desert, Sayid dreams of proving himself to his bossy sister Shazzia and to the world, by making it as a flower farmer. Enchanted by a mysterious veiled woman, he leaps at her offer to work for a company that ‘exports poppies’ to the West. Unfortunately, Sayid soon discovers that the woman is a terrorist, and the company a front for a jihadi cell seeking to blow up targets in the West, most particularly one known as the Unidentified, Very Prestigious Landmark.

Farce ensues as Sayid is brainwashed by the all-singing, all-dancing jihadis, vowing to fight for their cause. Meanwhile, a sinister reporter, Foxy Redstate, uncovers the plot, encouraging Sayid to keep her in the loop in the hope that such an exclusive will propel her to media stardom. Sayid finds himself caught between the terrorists on one hand and the media on the other, driven to share in their enthusiasm for the impending terrorist spectacular. Fortunately help is on the way in the form of his no-nonsense sister, who teams up with a surrender-prone Frenchman to come to the rescue. Everything comes to a head on the night of the attack, where, caught between his sister, the bloodthirsty global media, and the jihadis he has come to see as a new family, Sayid has to decide whose side he is really on.


Kippah tip: AtlasShrugs)

Another Headline Horror

Two dead in Gaza factions clash

So has BBC reported.

Passive.

But with Israel, it's active.

Got you mixed up?

Passive = "Dead"

Active = "Shot", "Killed", etc.

It's a subtle but malicious semantic ploy.

She Said...

Livni said the West Bank can ''be an example'' for cooperation or negotiations with Israel.

How, if "peace" means I have to leave my home but a Mr. Ahmed remains inside pre-67 Israel.

That's cooperation and coexistence?

What A Difference A Headline Makes

Here's the headline of a story reported by Isabel Kershner of the New York Times on their site today (yes, I know that she isn't responsible for headlines), followed by the body of the story:-


The Headline

Gaza: Israeli Troops Kill 2 in Raid
Published: August 2, 2007


The body

Israeli forces killed two armed Palestinians and wounded several others during an army incursion into northern Gaza. The dead men belonged to the military wings of Hamas and the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, according to statements from the groups.


You noticed the difference, yes?

Why couldn't the headline editor (yes, they have story editors, foreign desk editors, photo editors and headline editors) compose this text, for example:

Two terrorists killed by Israeli troops

Can This Work for Israel? Moving Out Arabs?

When Fadhil Hamdani first came to Bosnia from Iraq in 1979 he had no idea he would stay so long. But after prolonged studies, marriage to a Bosnian woman, the birth of five children and citizenship, the years turned into decades. Now he says he feels more Bosnian than Iraqi.

But the Bosnian government does not agree. It views him as a threat to national security and is putting Mr. Hamdani and other foreign fighters who have lived in Bosnia for many years on notice of deportation.

Arabs, the largest group among hundreds of foreign fighters, fought alongside the Bosnian Muslim Army during the war here, from 1992 to 1995, against Serbs and Croats. In return, they were given Bosnian citizenship.

Most left after the war, which tore apart Muslim, Serbian and Croatian communities and cost around 100,000 lives. But a number stayed on and settled down.

Bosnian officials say their policies are merely reversing decisions that were illegally made at the war’s end. But Bosnian politicians and international officials say that the reversals are primarily motivated by a broader concern: that Bosnia should not be seen as a haven for Islamic militants.

Western officials and local politicians, mostly the Muslims’ former opponents, have accused the former fighters of promoting radical Islam and damaging Bosnia’s reputation in the process.

“Some of their structures have been very active in promoting radical activities in the form of Wahhabism,” said Dragan Mektic, Bosnia’s deputy security minister, in a recent interview, referring to a strict form of Islam. “The public feel endangered.”

Western governments have been encouraging the move.


Source

Update on Netanyahu Visit to Shiloh Bloc

Any West Bank land that Israel fails to settle is land made available for another "Hamastan," said Likud chairman Binyamin Netanyahu Wednesday during a tour of Judea and Samaria.

"Any areas we evacuate now will be taken over by Hamas, which is simply a tool of Iran. The only reason this is not also Hamastan, like the Gaza Strip has become, is because the IDF is here," said Netanyahu.

Netanyahu, who will likely be reelected Likud chairman next month, displayed his commitment to settler expansion by then planting a sapling in the unauthorized outpost of Kida, near Shiloh.

"I wish I could plant more than this tree, but that will have to wait," said Netanyahu, as he bent down to tuck earth around the sapling.

Congratulating the young farmers on being true capitalists, in addition to settlers, Netanyahu said that he was reminded of the "early pioneering spirit of Israel."

"I would like to see the maximum possible development, and the maximum possible area kept in any future peace deal," said Netanyahu.

"The current government seems to have give up on much of the territory before they have even begun negotiations."

Netanyahu's decision to visit an illegal outpost was highly controversial, and members of his staff considered canceling the appearance hours before. Likud activists from within the settler movement insisted that he visit the outpost, claiming that it would set the tone for his eventual campaign as prime minister.


Source.

On Demography

My neighbor, David Rubin, had an article published in today's JPost.

Excerpts:-

Demographic threat? Nonsense

'Anyone who believes that Israel can maintain its current hold on all the West Bank is living in a dream." Ehud Olmert...His convergence/realignment plan for unilateral withdrawal from Judea and Samaria was based specifically on this perception, the problematic reality of a tiny Jewish population living among a large and rapidly rising Palestinian Arab population. Only by relinquishing control of these territories would Israel be able to maintain its Jewish majority. This has been the widely accepted solution to the demographic threat to Israel, having massive support, almost across the political spectrum. The problem, however, is that this view is usually accepted with very little questioning and far less analysis.

The demographic argument of those who advocate Israeli withdrawal from Judea and Samaria, whether unilateral or negotiated with our peace-loving neighbors, ignores both the steady high birthrates of the Jewish population in Judea and Samaria and the ongoing and increasing emigration of the Arab population from those areas. Furthermore, the media rarely notes that the reports of massive Arab population growth have been deliberately exaggerated to serve Arab/Muslim political interests. By closing our eyes to these simultaneous trends, we are simply supporting Hamas/Fatah propaganda and lies, intended to destroy the Jewish state.

...According to the Council of Jewish Communities in Judea and Samaria, there are now over 260,000 tax-paying Jewish residents in the region. Anyone who lives in these areas knows that the demand for homes, especially among young couples, is much greater than the supply, and the persistent reports of foolish Israeli withdrawal plans have limited building projects in these areas. But Jews continue to arrive from all parts of Israel, as well as from abroad, seeking homes in places such as Shiloh, Bet El, and Hebron, and many of those who have grown up there continue stay on after they marry, in whatever housing is available, raising large families and building for the future in those disputed areas.

This is the reality on the ground.

Yes, Zionism is alive and well in the Biblical heartland of Israel, both idealistically and demographically. It's okay for Mr. Olmert to debate differences based on facts, but the persistent mantra of the demographic threat in Judea and Samaria is based on an illusion.

The writer, a long-time resident of Shiloh, is the author of God, Israel, and Shiloh: Returning to the Land.

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

I Diasagree with Misha Arens

Here's the last part of Misha Arens' Haaretz article yesterday:

Last week the Knesset passed in preliminary reading a law that would require the Jewish National Fund (JNF) to allocate land that it owns only to Jews. Presumably this means that Jews who are not citizens of Israel would qualify, but Israel's Arab citizens would be barred from access to land owned by the JNF. A blatant violation of the norms of democracy.

But wait a minute, you might say, was not the Jewish National Fund founded in 1901 so the Land of Israel could be redeemed and come under Jewish ownership? Yes, of course, but something else happened in the meantime. In May 1948, the State of Israel was established, guaranteeing equality to all its citizens. The ultimate purpose of the Zionist Congress that decided on the establishment of the JNF - the establishment of a Jewish State in Palestine - has been achieved. In a democratic state one cannot condone laws that discriminate between citizens on ethnic grounds. That was certainly not part of Herzl's vision of the Jewish State.

So what about the Law of Return? Does it not provide a special privilege - the right to immigrate to Israel - for Jews only? Yes, but that is the foundation stone of the State of Israel - to provide a haven for any Jew in the world in need of a haven; so that what happened in the years before the Holocaust and during the Holocaust would never happen again. That is the mission of the State of Israel. A most humane mission by any reckoning. In fulfillment of this mission the Holocaust survivors from Europe, the Jewish communities from the Arab world and Iran, Soviet Jewry and the Ethiopian Jews were absorbed in Israel. Maybe even some of Israel's non-Jewish citizens can identify with this mission, and those who cannot must recognize that this is the reason the State of Israel was established.

The proposed JNF law has nothing to do with this mission. Hopefully, it will not go beyond the preliminary reading in the Knesset.


Truth tell, I have some alternative thoughts about this.

I do not think that a "haven" is the adequate definition. It's a lot more.

As for the land issue, one thought that comes to mind is that American Indian land, by a 1934 law, cannot be transferred out of the tribe's possession. Now, if we Jews are the original possessors, and the Arabs are occupiers from the 7th century; and if they have been trying to prevent we Jews from coming back with violence; and if they do not fulfill all citizen responsibilities and obligations; and if they have presented a separationist ideology this past year - why do we have to yield up on land purchased by Jews for Jews - an operation quite promoted by a Herzlian vision? Numerous times Herzl wrote and spoke of purchasing land, of redeeming the country.

The Declaration of Independence states that "Impelled by this historic and traditional attachment, Jews strove in every successive generation to re-establish themselves in their ancient homeland." This English does less that justice to the Hebrew intent. The Hebrew verb, l'hei'achez, means to grasp the land firmly, i.e, not to let go.

And also "THE STATE OF ISRAEL...will foster the development of the country for the benefit of all its inhabitants; also states there." Foster development - not transfer land purchased by Jews for Jews, for the national goal of Zionism.

I Was, At First, Confused

I read this headline:-

Minister In Skirt Charged With Indecent Exposure


and thought to myself, well, this could be about Tzipi Livni who is exposing Israel to an existential threat with her policies of withdrawal, establishment of a Pal. state, etc.

But no, I was wrong.

It was about

Police Say Man Urinated In Front Of Kids, Offered Oral Sex To Cops

JOHNSON CITY, Tenn. -- A Baptist minister has been charged in Tennessee with indecent exposure and driving under the influence.

Police said 58-year-old Tommy Tester of Bristol, Va., was wearing a skirt when he was arrested last week after allegedly relieving himself in front of children at a car wash.


Gotta be more careful with my suspicions.

And the church has to be more careful with its ministers.

Did You Know Shimon Peres Mumbles?

I laughed.

Here's from the official transcript of a press conference today with President Shimon Peres and US Sect'y of State Condi Rice:

PRESIDENT PERES: I extend (inaudible) to the Secretary of State of the United States. Whenever Condoleezza Rice and I (inaudible), it brings hope and (inaudible) and I think maybe this time, more than ever before. It's not a simple proposition, highly complicated, but that's (inaudible) deal with a lot of politics and a lot of patience. (Inaudible) I do believe that the Secretary was able to lead a policy that makes us nearer, more than ever before, to the conclusive chapter of the negotiations with the Palestinians. I think the Israeli people are anxious to see this.

Madame Secretary, we are heading out to (inaudible), which will be on May 2008. I didn't hope (inaudible). And I shall use your good (inaudible) by President Bush to participate in the 60th anniversary of the Israeli state, United States (inaudible). (Inaudible) and thank you (inaudible) to you for the President and it gives us a great deal of (inaudible) to receive our invitation and issue (inaudible). Thank you.

Guess Who Came to Shiloh Today?



Recognize him?

I Know Someone Who Needs a Real 'Swift Kick'

The Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC) urges the Football Association (FA), the Union of European Football Association (UEFA) and the International Federation of Association Football (FIFA) to take appropriate measures to suspend the national Israeli football team from all international fixtures until the state of Israel entirely complies with international law and relevant United Nations resolutions to end Israeli occupation. This should include a suspension of the Israeli team from the current Euro 2008 qualifiers.

...The Palestine Solidarity Campaign calls for UEFA, FIFA and the FA to take immediate action to end the Israeli national team's participation in Euro 2008. To continue normal relations with Israeli national sports teams is tantamount to an acceptance of the Israeli state's crimes against the Palestinian people. A ban on Israeli participation would send a clear message that Israeli apartheid and occupation, like all other forms of racism, are not welcome in international football.

Palestine Solidarity Campaign
Boycott Israeli Goods Campaign
Jews for Boycott of Israeli Goods
Friends of Al Aqsa UK


Source

Yesha's Population Just Went Up

Well, according to the Pals., that is:-

144 Settlements in the West Bank are housing 476,000 Israel settlers

26 of those settlements are in the occupied city of Jerusalem, 16 of them already annexed to Jerusalem.

259,000 settlers live in settlements in and around the occupied city of Jerusalem, while 77,000 settlers live in settlements around the central West Bank city of Ramallah. In addition, 46,000 live in settlements around the southern West Bank city of Bethlehem, 29,000 located near Salfit City in the northern part of the West Bank, and 1,300 settlers live in settlements near the northern West Bank city of Tubas.

The report stated that those numbers do not include the random 165 settlements, home of 10,000 settlers, which the Israeli army considers to be illegal.



A 'settler' I will be,
I feel so good and free,
Hi-ho, the merry-o,
I've got 'settler' pedigree.

Ever Heard of Kastner? Perfidy? The "Train"?

Read Elliot Jager's op-ed/article.

Well, You Can Eat Shiloh Eggs

My neighbor is mentioned in yesterday's Haaretz:-

7,000 eggs a day

Other organic farmers in the West Bank include Yona Tzoref of the Shiloh settlement and Aharon Gayan of Itamar. Tzoref, 60, is proud that the 8,000 free-range chickens he raises - which are fed a mixture of organic grains comprised of wheat, corn and 15 percent minerals - lay about 7,000 eggs a day.


First it was perfume and now it's eggs and organic farming:-


Good eggs from the West Bank


Avri Ran is a leader of the Hilltop Youth movement from the West Bank settlement of Itamar. He has been acquitted of charges of assaulting an Israeli Arab and a left-wing activist, and residents of the Arab village of Yanun accuse him of harassing villagers. But Ran's right-wing activities are not his only claim to fame: He is also one of the largest suppliers of organic eggs in the country.

Ran is one of 10 to 15 organic farmers growing produce in the West Bank, but for all the controversy surrounding the settlements and outposts, the organic farming industry pays scant attention to where the stuff is grown.

Ornit Raz, head of Israel's organic farmers association, said the group "doesn't deal with politics," such as where the organic farms are located. "We examine the produce that comes from everywhere, according to its quality and our professional standards."

To demonstrate the separation between the political and the agricultural, Raz mentions Ran, who aside from being responsible for much of the growth of the organic egg industry, also uses his thousands of dunams to grow wheat used to make organic flour, and produces cheeses and yogurts made from goat's milk.

"He is an excellent farmer, straight and reliable," said Raz. "We as an association look at him from a professional and ethical standpoint, not a political one."

7,000 eggs a day

Other organic farmers in the West Bank include Yona Tzoref of the Shiloh settlement and Aharon Gayan of Itamar. Tzoref, 60, is proud that the 8,000 free-range chickens he raises - which are fed a mixture of organic grains comprised of wheat, corn and 15 percent minerals - lay about 7,000 eggs a day.



(Haaretz trying to be funny. Arab says: "Would that we be caged up so".

Gayan, an evacuee from the Gush Katif settlement of Kfar Darom, said Itamar, the center of organic farming in Samaria, has an advantage over other parts of the country.

"At a height of between 650 and 900 meters above sea level, it's cooler and the greenhouses aren't as hot, so the fruit ripens even in the late summer months, which are hotter, and there's still an abundance of produce in the fall," he said. Gayan said he took out a NIS 200,000 loan to set up greenhouses on three dunams and grow dozens of tons of beans, cucumbers, tomatoes, strawberries, zucchini and eggplant on another five dunams of land.

But although some of the organic farmers are succeeding, the industry is not flourishing in the West Bank, said Shivi Drori, the coordinator of the Agriculture Ministry's agricultural council for the central and northern West Bank.

Drori, who lives in the Givat Harel outpost near Shiloh and owns a non-organic winery, said organic farming in the West Bank is on the decline, especially for deciduous fruit and olive orchards.

Ariel Ben Sheetrit's difficulties in running his organic vineyard are indicative of some of the problems other organic farmers face.

The Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon grapes in Sheetrit's organic orchard on the outskirts of the West Bank settlement of Yitzhar are not looking good. On many mornings, clouds glide over to the small valley at the edge of his house, and the accompanying rain brings with it a fungus that afflicts the leaves of the grapevines he planted seven years ago.

Ben Sheetrit puts a lot of effort into his 35-dunam vineyard in his attempts to offset the various threats, while adhering to the main principle of organic farming: not using chemicals. He isn't always successful.

As an alternative to spraying chemical compounds on his crops, Ben Sheetrit weeds the vineyard himself, getting rid of the couch grass weed growing near the grapevine stems by covering them with black plastic sheets.

Staunch ideologues

With all the extra work involved, it is perhaps no surprise that, according to Drori, "quite a few farmers who tried to use organic growth methods gave up.

"It's difficult, expensive and less economical," he said. "You have to be a staunch ideologue - not only regarding the Land of Israel, but also regarding this growth method and lifestyle - to stick with it, and not everyone can do it."

Although Ariel Ben Sheetrit's task is made more difficult by the strictures imposed by organic farming, he appears to bear the traits of the ideologue that Drori recommends.

Next to his vineyard, Ben Sheetrit has built one of the only wineries in Israel that produces organic wine. One type of wine is called Shoham, "after the stone of Joseph the Righteous in the [High Priest's] breastplate," he explained. Another is called Pura, after one of the words for a winepress used in Isaiah. Ben Sheetrit, a former student at the Kever Yosef [Joseph's Tomb] yeshiva, wrote the text used on the wine labels himself.

"The grapevines put down roots with us in the earth of the good land, and breathe its air until the roots strike the heart of the land," he wrote. "The wine production process, from the planting of the grapevines to the sealing of the bottles, uses Hebrew labor by the young people of Israel, to give pleasure to the Creator, may His name be blessed."

Ben Sheetrit is also thankful for nature's bounty, noting that the vineyard doesn't need much watering because nature "gave us almost everything, and the earth has everything the grapevine needs."

You Can Now Smell Shiloh UPDATED

The perfume, that is (not the place where I live).



And there's a story:-

The woman behind the fragrance named "Shiloh," Symine Salimpour,(*) has just won a five-month-long legal battle with Angelina Jolie over the name. Symine claims that the fact that her perfume has the same name as Angelina's baby is simply a coincidence and the courts seem to agree. From the The Washington Post:

The trademark battle "was just a huge misunderstanding," Salimpour says, magnanimous in victory. "And besides having a baby named Shiloh -- because this perfume, it is my baby -- we can say we have two other things in common: We believe in human rights, and we love Brad Pitt!"


Hmmm. Should we here at Shiloh, the utmost original Shiloh, sue than Angelina for stealing our name?

Better, let's develop of whole line of Yesha fragrances.

=================

(*)
Salimpour, who is Jewish and a citizen of both France and Israel, gamely played David to Jolie's Goliath, maintaining that the naming was strictly a coincidence.

"In Hebrew, Shiloh means 'his gift,' " Salimpour says. "And I will use the perfume to give something back to the children of Israel and the Middle East." She means this literally. After Shiloh hits the market later this year, she says, 5 percent of the profits will go to the Israeli-based nonprofit organization Beit Issie Shapiro, which provides medical and educational services to disabled children.

The daughter of an Iranian-born psychiatrist and an Egyptian-born artist who met and were married in France, Salimpour is a graduate of the Sorbonne, and in 2003 received a law degree from Paris's famed EFB, the Ecole de Formation Professionnelle des Barreaux.



I told him I was a lawyer with a special interest in human rights, that I design jewelry and had lived in Israel and Paris and the South of France. The scent I wanted would present the idea of fragility and strength. And that it would be called Shiloh."

It is a complex fragrance. The forward notes, the ones that hit your nose first, are cedar wood and patchouli. Rising above that earthy base are delicious whiffs of citrus (thanks to a dab of bergamot oil) and rose petals. There are probably about 30 other scents that an expert could identify. It's a really heady scent.


Company site.

======================

UPDATE

We have been contacted by Symine!

Naim Meod Yisrael!

Thank you for your great support!

I hope that Shiloh, not the town but the pĂȘrfume, will be soon in Israel and also
brings more light to Shiloh, where you live,

Best regards,

Symine Salimpour

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

NYTimes Obliquely Mentions L'Affair Wonkette

Here by one Dan Saltzstein.

And I left this comment there but don't know if it'll be approved.

Wonkette had this clip on their blog site and the next day, referred to it, but emphasized the "Jew-liani" bit and then, out of the blue, referred too to something called the Jew York Times. I thought this was sliding too close to Judeophobia and blogged on it. Ken Layne of Wonkette then threatened me with legal action byreferring to lawyers, I refused to kuckle under and then he withdrew. Whole affair is here: http://myrightword.blogspot.com/2007/07/laffair-wonkette-round-up.html

I still haven't be able to figure out why they wrote Jew York Times.


========

UPDATE

It's there!

Once, There Was Betar in Warsaw





Source

Imagine How Much Money Could Be Made Off Of the Anarchists

The Israel Defense Forces is preparing to evacuate next week settlers who have broken into the wholesale market in the West Bank city of Hebron.

The IDF recently sent a letter to the settlers' attorney, Haim Cohen, saying it would charge settlers the cost of evacuating them if they did not leave of their own accord.

The letter, sent by the legal advisor of the Judea and Samaria Division, said that the settlers' window of opportunity to leave freely has closed, and that the IDF will forcibly evacuate them at a time it deems appropriate.

The army said in the letter to Cohen that it would use "reasonable force" during the evacuation, and raised the possibility of placing the entire cost of the exercise on the shoulders of Cohen's clients


The Anarchists Against the Fence demonstrate every Friday and the IDF and/or Border Guards expend tear gas, etc. There's a lot of money to be made there but have the Anarchists ever been threatened?

Stupid

The Village Just South of Shiloh on the Next Hill Over

West Bank's own slice of America
By Martin Patience
BBC News, West Bank

Mazraa Sharqiya is not your average Palestinian village.

Expensive jeeps and cars line the pristine streets. Expensive villas nestle behind high stone walls.

Whereas many modern Palestinian homes are built from cinderblocks, here there are opulent four-storey residences, many of them clad in marble.

With about a third of Palestinian households in the West Bank living in poverty according to the United Nations, Mazraa Sharqiya is an obvious exception to the rule.

Some Palestinians even refer to the village as the Miami of the West Bank on account of the wealth and the seemingly endless summer partying.

But the wealth found in Mazraa Sharqiya is not produced locally - it comes from the Palestinian diaspora, people who have left their homes in search of a better life.

About two-thirds of the village's 15,000 inhabitants live abroad, mainly in the United States.

During the summer, many of the residents return to their home village where they have built villas.

Ahmed Yacoub, 46, is one of them. The father-of-six left the village more than 30 years ago. He says that because of the Israeli occupation there were few opportunities for young people in the village.

Mr Yacoub first went to Puerto Rico, then Chicago, and then back to Puerto Rico where he runs a successful clothing company.

But he returns home every summer, although Israel often makes it difficult for him and his family to enter, he says.

"I like to bring my children here to teach them the Arabic language and customs," says Mr Yacoub, sitting on a chair on his patio.

"Because when they are far away then cannot learn like they do when they're in the village."

Until the early 1980s, Mazraa Sharqiya looked like any other Palestinian village in the West Bank during that period.

There were modest two-storey houses and many of the roads were unpaved.

But when expatriate Mazrawis began to find their feet abroad, the money started flowing in and the villas began going up. This has created what Mr Yacoub calls the "new town" and the "old town".

Despite being born and raised in the village, Mr Yacoub says that he often feels like an outsider.

"Some of the villagers see us as foreigners," he says. "I don't feel integrated with the rest of the village, the ones that never left."

In the summer, the village experiences a mini economic boom with the surge in population. It is not unusual to see lorries carrying luxurious, French-style, furniture crawling through the village.

Many expatriates get married in the village - and there can be as many as four weddings a day. One of Mr Yacoub's sons, Jomaa, 25, says that he is rarely in his bed before 0400. But in the winter, the village is ghostly quiet in comparison.

"The weather is very cold and most people are bored," says music-shop owner, Abdel Hakim, 28, who lives in the village all year round. "There is nothing to do."

At a local pool hall, some of the village's teenagers get in some practice. All say they would leave the village for United State if given the opportunity. "More money," says one teenage boy in broken English. And that is the dilemma that this village experiences.

Most of the expatriates say that they would like to live here permanently - but the Israeli occupation and the lack of opportunities make that difficult. It is only by their living abroad that Mazraa Sharqiya can continue to thrive.


====================

And see my wife's posts a while back on Arab mansions:

(1)

(2)

CNN's Semanticism of Bias

BT sent me this:

The headlines of Saturday evening (July 28 2007, 9:29/10:29 PM ET) on CNN's headlines:

1) Leb. kills 8 militants in refugee camp.

2) Israeli troops kill 2 Palestinians in Gaza.


This means that whenever other Arabs fight "Palestinians", the "Palestinian"
Arabs are defined as Islamic militants, suggesting that they are legitimate targets but when Israel fights for its survival from genocidal "Palestinian" terrorists, the terrorists are then (all of a sudden) being coated with such plain titles as: "Palestinian people".

Monday, July 30, 2007

Another Way of Looking at It

We've all read about the Golani soldier left behind by his unit.

FARK has another way of looking at it:

Israeli soldier, not afraid of terrorists, decides to lie down and take a nap in the middle of Hamas' hometown

Get This Book

The Jewish Revolution
Jewish Statehood

Israel Eldad
ISBN: 978-9652294142
Format: Hardback 168 pages
Publish date: 07/2007
Publisher: Gefen Publishing House
Price: $21.95

Description:

With The Jewish Revolution classical Zionism has found its true interpretation. In the highest tradition of the soldier-statesman, Dr. Israel Eldad advocates a form of Zionism that is unpopular in conventional society. He condemns
“establishmentarian,” “social-club” Zionism as a belittling of Jewish history and a threat to Jewish lives. In its
place, he calls for a revolutionary creed – one that dares assert its right to the Jewish homeland; not as defined by diplomats, politicians and Security Council Resolutions, but in biblical, historical terms.

He boldly declares that Jewish “diplomacy” failed to save millions of European Jews, and he accuses world leaders of
inviting new Holocausts by denying history’s lessons and ignoring its imperatives. He warns the Jewish people that it can rely only on its own forces, and he offers a solution to the Arab problem in the Middle East.

The Jewish Revolution combines the passion of the patriot, the logic of the scholar and the sweep of the historian.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Scholar, writer and active Zionist revolutionary Israel Eldad was born in Galicia in 1910. After graduating from the Rabbinical Seminary in Vienna and obtaining his doctorate in philosophy, he returned to Poland to teach Jewish Studies at the Vilna Teachers’ Seminary. Invited by Menachem Begin, he joined the Warsaw leadership of B’rit Trumpeldor – “Betar” – the youth section of Jabotinsky’s Revisionist Zionist Party. In 1938 he first met Avraham Stern, founder of the underground Zionist movement Lohamei Heirut Israel, “The Fighters for the Freedom of Israel – Lehi” (the Stern Group).

Arriving in Palestine in 1941, he joined the underground as a member of Lehi Headquarters Staff. During the crucial years of World War II, when the British Mandatory Government was attempting to appease the Arabs by conducting a policy of repression against Palestine’s Jewish community, Eldad made secret broadcasts, wrote articles for underground publications and edited the Wall Newspaper – “illegal” bulletins pasted on the walls at night – since compiled in book form as Let the Walls Speak.

While attempting to escape arrest by the British police, Eldad suffered a serious back injury. For two years he
remained in British prisons, his entire body encased in a cast. Dramatically freed from his military guards by Lehi
comrades in 1946, he resumed his work in the underground movement until the establishment of the State of Israel.
For many years he was editor of Sulam, a political and literary monthly recognized as the leading journal of its
kind. He wrote Ma’aser Rishon (The First Tithe), which deals with the Hebrew underground movement and his part in it. He is the author of Hegyonot Mikrah, a highly original, challenging commentary on the Bible. For four years he edited the unique historical paper Chronicles – News of the Past. He translated from German into Hebrew the complete writings of Friedrich
Nietzsche, published four volumes of selected papers and with his son Arieh wrote Jerusalem: The Challenge (1976).

Dr. Eldad was a Professor in Humanistic Studies at the Haifa Technion and at Ben-Gurion University of the
Negev in Beer-Sheva. He died in 1996 and was buried on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem.


Table of Contents
*Introduction
*An Existence of Nonconformity
*The Fall of the Bastille
*Sources of Zionism — Two Old and One New
*New Zionism vs. the New Left, or the Joseph Complex
*Zionism as Liberation, Revolution and Renaissance
*Right, Necessary and Possible
*The Zionist Front in Soviet Russia
*Intermezzo, Rhapsody, Caesura
*Eretz Yisrael or Palestine
*The Arab-Jewish Conflict
*Before Any Court of Justice
*Jordan Is a River Not a State
*Israel and Ishmael
*Three Points of No Return and Three Stages of Salvation
*Israel
*Afterword by Arieh Eldad