Tuesday, September 06, 2011

Richard "Tikun Olam" Silverstein Admits to Criminal Behavior?

According to this New Tork Times story on Shamai Leibowitz, was Richard Silverstein complicit in criminal behavior? Should he have been prosecuted?:

When Shamai K. Leibowitz, an F.B.I. translator, was sentenced to 20 months in prison last year for leaking classified information to a blogger, prosecutors revealed little about the case. They identified the blogger in court papers only as “Recipient A.”

...Mr. Leibowitz, a contract Hebrew translator, passed on secret transcripts of conversations caught on F.B.I. wiretaps of the Israeli Embassy in Washington...according to the blogger, Richard Silverstein...Mr. Silverstein offered a rare glimpse of American spying on a close ally. He said he had burned the secret documents in his Seattle backyard after Mr. Leibowitz came under investigation in mid-2009, but he recalled that there were about 200 pages of verbatim records of telephone calls and what seemed to be embassy conversations.

...Mr. Silverstein, 59, writes a blog called Tikun Olam, named after a Hebrew phrase that he said means “repairing the world.” The blog gives a liberal perspective on Israel and Israeli-American relations. He said he had decided to speak out to make clear that Mr. Leibowitz, though charged under the Espionage Act, was acting out of noble motives...Mr. Silverstein said he got to know Mr. Leibowitz, a lawyer with a history of political activism...“I see him as an American patriot and a whistle-blower, and I’d like his actions to be seen in that context,” Mr. Silverstein said...Mr. Silverstein took the blog posts he had written based on Mr. Leibowitz’s material off his site after the criminal investigation two years ago. But he was able to retrieve three posts from April 2009 from his computer and provided them to The New York Times.

The blog posts make no reference to eavesdropping, but describe information from “a confidential source,” wording Mr. Silverstein said was his attempt to disguise the material’s origin...

So, Silverstein admits to being a chief participants in the events that sent Leibowitz to prison. He seems to be, upon his own confession, the recipient of and still the possessor of classified US intelligence information.  He is, it appears, the previously unnamed “blogger.”

Silverstein claims to have burned the transcripts when Leibowitz came under investigation. Is that a fair case too be prosecuted for obstruction of justice?  Is Silverstein's claims that Leibowitz’s motives were pure and good, because they were to hurt Israel rather than hurt the United States, a defense against prosecution and eventual conviction?

They didn't help Leibowitz.  Why then should they assist Silverstein?

Will the Attorney-General now initiate criminal proceedings against Silverstein?

^

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

unless dickie is lying

come on ym, you know that the guy lies

the fbi would not have grabbed him long ago?

bigger question

how did leibowitz, who served as counsel to terrorists and terrorist lovers and made his views well known...ever get a job with the fbi?

Anonymous said...

According to court transcripts, Leibowitz revealed the wiretaps not to expose US spying on an ally, but because he felt that the tapes showed Israel improperly trying to lobby in the US and get positive p.r. Leibowitz is, like Silverstein, an extreme leftie, and was once Barghouti’s lawyer (he described Barghouti, a convicted terrorist, as being "like Moses").
The US government is likely the source of the quote saying that the wiretaps on Israel's embassy were necessary because "Israeli spy activities in the US are quite active", which was never true but is even less true post-Pollard. Today Israel is terrified to act withn the US and rountinely turns away "walk in" sources and info out of fear that they're sting operations.
US intell agencies target Israel here, and are ridiculously active within Israel, but Pollard sits in jail. Textbook definition of hypocrisy.

Anonymous said...

P.S. And, yes, it's logical to assume that Leibowitz got his job with the FBI because he had already been a US government asset in Israel. But you won't see the press looking into that. Sad, scared leftie Israeli press.

Anonymous said...

this tweet going around;

@elliottjustin
Richard Silverstein tells me he burned the Israeli embassy transcripts simply because Shamai Leibowitz asked him to (in re: earlier tweet)

Anonymous said...

Learn the truth about the Dickaling at

www.kapodickie.blogspot.com