Showing posts with label The Guardian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Guardian. Show all posts

Thursday, March 25, 2021

Yet Another Unpublished Letter-to-the-Editor

On March 17, 2021, the UK Guardian published an oped by Salem Barahmeh entitled, "The Israeli and Palestinian elections offend democracy – each in their own way".

I wrote a letter-to-the-editor and it was emailed the following day:

In his March 17 op-ed, Salem Barahmeh, of the Palestine Institute for Public Diplomacy, conveniently blames Israel for the lack of democracy in the Palestinian Authority. Israel has never prevented President Mahmoud Abbas, last elected 16 years ago, from initiating elections. The responsibility for the regime Abbas oversees which among other actions severely restricts the freedoms, liberties and rights of its population too numerous to list cannot be assigned to Israel. At some time in their history, the Arabs of Palestine must assume accountability for their own actions or lack thereof.

In bemoaning the fact that upwards of 700,000 Jewish Israelis are living in the territories claimed by the Palestinian Authority, Barahmeh ignores the pre-state period of 1920-1948, when thousands of Jews who were living in those same areas such as Jerusalem's Old City and its environs, Hebron, Gaza, Nablus, Etzion Bloc and other locations then called by the United Nations in its 1947 partition plan as Judea and Samaria, were removed due to both a campaign of terror promoted by the then Mufti Amin El-Husseini and the hostilities Arabs launched after rejecting that internationally supported compromise arrangement which the Jewish community of Mandate Palestine did accept. Had Jews not been targeted in an ethnic cleansing operation, just  as twenty percent or more of Israel's current citizenry are Arab, there should be no reason 20% of Palestine's residents, if not citizens, could be Jewish.

Yisrael Medad

Shiloh, Israel

I waited a few days and I don't see it.

So now it's public here.


^



Friday, February 02, 2018

The Guardian's Holmes and His Journalism

The Guardian's Olive Holmes simply mouthpieced a report from the EU the other day.

Its essence:

Israel using tourism to legitimise settlements, says EU report
Exclusive: European Union Heads of Mission warn 
‘touristic settlements’ are being used as a political tool

I am going to guess, without any inside knowledge that Emek Shaveh was central to this.  A bit nasty they are.

In any case, as we know with archaeology in the Holy Land, Israel's archaeologists preserve all finds no matter from who, even of Arabs who occupied the Jewish homeland in 638 CE

That includes Canaanites, Philistines, Babylonians, Greeks, Romans, Byzantines, Persians, Muslims, Crusaders, Mamelukes, Ottomans...and even prehistoric civilizations.

Israel also protects the finds from those who steal, deface and destroy them (guess who).

But that is but one side to this story's unprofessional journalism.

No Israeli archaeologist is asked for a reaction.

No response from the Israel Antiquities Authority.

No quotations from a government representative like...the Minister of Toruism.

Was a "settler", aka Jewish resident, asked? From City of David or Ancient Shiloh?

Was this a balanced report?

Fair?

Objective?

Factual?

After all, the reports underlying theme is astounding:

Archaeology and tourism development by government institutions as well as private settler organisations established what it said was a “narrative based on historic continuity of the Jewish presence in the area at the expense of other religions and cultures”.

That is a flat-out lie.  Holmes had not the sense to realize that and work a bit harder to include a riposte?

Shameful, really.  (UK MediaWatch post)

^

Saturday, November 25, 2017

The Guardian Wipes Out Jewish Gaza

In a story on Gaza, which, by the way notes that Gaza is but 40th in a 2014 rank of most densely populated cities worldwide, also informs the reader that

Gaza City, famed for its port, is more than 5,000 years old. Over centuries various empires between the Nile River and Middle East – Philistines, Egyptians, Assyrians, Persians, Alexander the Great, Romans, Byzantines, Moguls, Ottomans, among others – ruled Gaza

While, on the one hand, at least Israel isn't accused of occupying Gaza in centuries ago, Gaza was part of the Land of Israel and even part of the Mandate territory to become the Jewish national home.

Let's be clear, the Jewish connection to Gaza, in various forms and over many centuries, was strong. Up until 1929, when a small community of Jews there were expelled by Arab terrorist pogroms and later, when Kfar Darom was overrun in 1948.

The territory that the tribe of Judah received after the Israelites entered the Land included Gaza (Joshua 15.47), yet they failed to occupy this area at that time (Joshua 13.3)...Gaza was conquered by King David about 1000 BCE. His son Salomon ruled over Gaza (I Kings 5.4), but its population seemed to remain Philistine. The Northern kingdom controlled Gaza after the United Kingdom was divided. 

and

The city was subsequently attacked and reconquered by Jonathan the Hasmonean during 145 BCE (1 Macc. 11:61-62). 
During the Hasmonean civil war, the city was taken by Alexander Janneaeus in 96 BCE. The Roman Pomey restored the city and Galbinus, also a Roman official, rebuilt the city (circa 57 BCE). 
King Herod the Great held the city for a short time, but after his death, it came under the authority of the Roman proconsul of Syria.

A synagogue existed there 1500 years ago. 

Whether Jews ruled the area and just resided there, wiping out the Jewishness of the territory is not proper journalism.

^

Tuesday, September 06, 2016

The Guardian is On Guard and Censorious

I posted a comment to this op-ed in The Guardian, entitled


by Moustafa Bayoumi, a student of Edward Said.

Bayoumi is "an award-winning writer, and associate professor of English at Brooklyn College, City University of New York" according to his bio at the paper.

I received this reply in less than an hour and a half:-

Hi YMedad,
We wanted to let you know that a comment of yours has been removed from theguardian.com because it was flagged by the moderation team as:
    *Off topic*
What is on topic is what is included in the article, so what is off-topic is decided on an article-by-article basis depending on the subject and will be enforced more scrupulously on sensitive subjects. Posts which could derail the conversation by leading it away from the topic of the article including ‘whataboutery’ will be removed.
A full description of our community standards can be found here: http://www.theguardian.com/community-standards.
Warning: Those who seriously, persistently or wilfully ignore the community standards, participation guidelines or terms and conditions will have their posting privileges for all the Guardian community areas withdrawn.
If you have any queries about this decision you can contact the Moderation team directly (details can be found on the Community Standards page).
Guardian Moderation Team

This was my comment:

This assertion raises some problems: "the Israeli occupation of Palestinian lands will turn 50 years old."
a) can we understand that the writer rejects the normative Arab position that actually all of Israel is occupying "Palestinian land", as when in 1964, three years before the Six Days War, the Palestine Liberation Organisation was founded? Or as in the Hamas Charter that all of "Palestine: is waqf territory?
b) If they are Palestinian lands, does that mean that Jews cannot reside on these lands if they have bought them, either pre-1948 or post -1967?
c) were those lands "Palestinian" even before the country was first termed "Palestine" by the Romans? and before, were they not Judean lands?
d) did Arabs occupy those lands in 638 CE?
e) when Jordan occupied them during 1949-1967, who was oppressing the Arabs then? Why was there no BDS movement or the like?
f) just as an aside, what is the difference, in the sense of nationality identity, between an Arab in Israel, in Judea & Samaria, aka the 'West Bank' and the Arab in Jordan (besides the fact that the Hashemite family only arrive in Jordan in November 1920 from Saudi Arabia)?

Okay, I am flummoxed and nonplussed.

I think the writer needs to clarify for his audience anything he writes.  I think what he writes is legitimate for criticism.  Indeed, the whole topic of "occupation" hinges on whether we know what he really means and if any diplomatic move will end the conflict.  If we can't assure our mutual understanding of the core issues, what use is arguing over how to solve them?

In 2014, Bayoumi was quoted as saying at a guest lecture at Colgate that there was a

need to reset the terms of the dialogue at an institutional level and to find “solutions that guarantee individual and communal rights to all and find justice for all Israelis and Palestinians, including those Palestinians who are the ancestors of those displaced in 1948.”
So, indeed, my points (a) and (c) are quite on-topic.

If I had commented on this section of his:

In fact, there are 2,898,927 Palestinians living in the West Bank, 1,850,559 in the Gaza Strip, 1,471,201 in Israel,

by writing that (a) his number for "West Bank" Arab residents is close to a million off or that (b) if there are "Palestinians" in Israel then at least my point 'f' is quite on topic would that comment be allowed?

Or if I had commented on this section

According to the New York Times, there are now more than 350,000 settlers living in the West Bank and another 300,000 living in East Jerusalem, 

by pointing out that (a) that quote if one-and-one-half year's old and that (b) the numbers are wrong [there are 460,000 Jews residing in Judea and Samaria and 210,000 in Jerusalem's post-1967 neighborhoods] would that be off-topic as well?

If I would have commented on this bit:

In fact, slim majorities of both Palestinians and Israelis still support a two-state solution
by pointing out that a poll in March, a half-year earlier had 69% Palestinian Arab support and that his poll had but 51% in favor which is quite a dramatic drop and does not augur well, would that have been off=topic?

If his details are wrong or questionable or fudged or plain misrepresentations, how can his conclusions be "on-topic"?

Or, to phrase it differently, why is The Guardian so zealous in its censorship?

^

Sunday, April 29, 2012

A Jew Presumes; I Respond

Here's a letter from April 9 in The Guardian:

Binyamin Netanyahu and Avigdor Lieberman (Report, 9 April) should realise that a fair proportion of the world's Jewry feel the same way as Günter Grass about the Israeli government's policies – which are in breach of Jewish law ("Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt", Exodus 22:21) and the Jewish tradition of support for the oppressed, especially at this time of Passover – and feel that it is they who are "sacrificing the Jewish people" in their militaristic and intransigent policies towards the Palestinian people in Gaza and the West Bank. Many of us who were supporters of Israel and the Zionist project have become disillusioned by the injustice of the present government, and their failure to take steps to achieve a lasting peace.

Michael Ellman
London

Here's my reaction:

Michael Ellman (Letter, April 10), asserts that "a fair proportion of the world's Jewry feel the same way as Günter Grass about the Israeli government's policies" of Binyamin Netanyahu and Avigdor Lieberman and that these two leaders failed "to take steps to achieve a lasting peace".  How to judge what is a "fair proportion" and if Ellman is correct on this point is beyond me, but on his second point, I can assure him that he is quite wrong.

Besides misusing a Biblical instruction which has no relevance to the Arabs of Mandate Palestine's 90-year terror campaign against Jews and Zionism, Mr Netanyahu in handing over Hebron at the 1999 Wye Agreement, which permitted Arabs to snipe at Jewish residents eventually killing an infant girl, his announcement in 2009, repeated, accepting the two-state principle and also his 2010 construction moratorium did, in the face of constant incitement, lawlessness as well as even internal Palestinian Authority corruption against its own residents, I would suggest, more than necessary in the face of Arab intransigence.  And surely no more than the Bible would demand in the situation, a Bible, incidentally, that views Judea, Samaria and Gaza as part of the historic Jewish homeland wherein Jews, like myself, should be able to reside and flourish.


Was it ever published?

What do you think?

This one though was.  And this, too.  But those were a while ago.

^



Saturday, July 16, 2011

How Pro-Pal. Is The UK Guardian?

Well, they even have a category-theme heading for it:


Who needs a UN declaration of statehood, then?

^

Friday, February 18, 2011

A Test for a Journalist

Harriet Sherwood of The Guardian published this today in a story in her View From Jerusalem column on her visit to Shchem:

...earlier this week the Israeli authorities dismantled the notorious Hawara checkpoint at the entrance to the city, where Palestinians seeking access to or from the city - for work, study, shopping, family visits, medical treatment - were kept waiting, often for several hours. Many were denied passage.

Traffic - both vehicles and people on foot – now flows freely. Other checkpoints and roadblocks are still in place around the city [are those IDF or local Pal. police roadblocks?], but the dismantling of the symbolic and hated Hawara barrier has been welcomed by locals. Not so the inhabitants of nearby Jewish settlements, who have bitterly criticised the move, saying it compromises their security.

If, God forbid, there is a security-related incident, with or without injuries, will Ms. Sherwood reconsider her relatively benign view of Jewish security concerns?

Will we read about her possible doubts of rhe irreliability of the Pals. on this issue?

^

^

Thursday, May 07, 2009

My Letter Appears in The Guardian

My letter made it into today's edition of the Guardian:

Regarding your story "End Palestinian demolitions in Jerusalem, UN tells Israel" (1 May). Of course Israel should end Palestinian demolitions, and I presume you are referring to terror explosions, suicide bombings and attacks by infernal machines like bulldozers.

Yisrael Medad
Shiloh, Mobile Post Efraim, West Bank


Of course, it was the paper that added that "West Bank" label.

At least they don't boycott me.




P.S. To be fair, here are the other letters:

Jonathan Steele is whistling in the wind in advising Barack Obama to behave sensibly, let alone decently, towards Israel (Comment, 5 May). Obama's contemptible silence during the December-January Israeli onslaught on Gaza, together with Hillary Clinton's weird implication that all could be well if only the tunnels from Egypt supplying Hamas with rocket capability could be blocked, demonstrate that on Israel-Palestine there is no more to be hoped for from this new US administration than from its predecessor. With congressional elections 18 months away, Obama's presidency is as much in hock to the blustering American Israeli Public Affairs Committee pressure group as was George W Bush's.

At least Bill Clinton tried, and Bush senior even threatened economic sanctions. No, everything will continue as before. Israel will go on persecuting the Palestinians. The outcome, unless Obama actually does force the Israelis to talk to both Fatah and Hamas, will be an ever-growing Palestinian population until Israeli Jews are outnumbered, and a two-state solution will go off the agenda.

Gerald Kaufman MP
Lab, Manchester Gorton

You don't have to support Israel's occupation of the West Bank to recognise the disingenousness of author David Gardner's justification of Hamas: "There is no legal or moral reason why Hamas ... should recognise a state that refuses to define its boundaries, which are being expanded daily on Palestinian land." Steele quotes approvingly. But Hamas would not recognise Israel within any boundaries. Until it is prepared to do so how can peace be achieved? [that's a good point even from a liberal]

Jeremy Beecham
Vice-chairman, New Israel Fund UK

Jonathan Steele writes that George W Bush's letter encouraging Israel to continue building illegal settlement "was not a treaty or even a bilateral government agreement". This didn't prevent another letter, known as the Balfour Declaration, from determining British policy in Palestine for 30 disastrous years. Drafted by Zionists [and altered and rewritten by the Cabinet] led by the Russian Jew [and chemical scientist who aided Gt. Britain's war effort] Chaim Weizmann, and handed to Balfour to sign, its creation led a Daily Mail editor of the time, JMN Jeffries, to write: "The walls of the Foreign Office without doubt have enclosed many a singular scene, but they might well have inclined together to hide from view the spectacle of a Secretary of State [Balfour] asking a visitor from Russia [Weizmann] to give him a draft of his own Cabinet's measures."

Karl Sabbagh
Newbold on Stour, Warwickshire


They must have been pained to read my letter and be found in company with me.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

The Guardian Letter is Published

Mine is the first to appear:-

Brian Klug bemoans an "oppressive atmosphere" that limits, he asserts, his and his comrades' freedom of expression within the Jewish community in the UK (No one has the right to speak for British Jews on Is rael and Zionism, February 5).

As Klug is well aware, it is not the principle that is in dispute but the details. When critics of Israel's policies in the territories or in Lebanon, or in Israel itself, adopt a standard of moral inequivalency, ignore Arab sins, glide over major societal and cultural differences, fudge historical facts, forget legal rights and, in general, act in a street-gang manner, they should know that it is fair and just to question their Jewish identity, or, at the very least, cast doubt whether they are interpreting to the non-Jewish public what Jewish identity is and what is Jewish nationalism.

Yisrael Medad
Shiloh, Israel


My original text, the letter was edited, is here.

And while we are on the subject of letters, I found there this interesting one on another, but related, subject:-

Maleiha Malik (Comment, February 2) says "Churchill wrote that Jews were part of a 'worldwide conspiracy for the overthrow of civilisation'." This is a masterpiece of selection. Churchill at that time, 1920, was obsessed with the prospect of revolutions around the world directed from Moscow by the Bolsheviks, many of whose first leaders were indeed Jewish; they were the "bad" Jews he had in view, and that was the conspiracy. Because he regarded them as unrepresentative of the Jewish people as a whole, he took the trouble to distinguish them from "good" Jews whom he looked to for the economic development of Palestine (he was unusual among his class and kind in being a pro-Zionist) and whom he numbered among his friends. He was the least anti-semitic of all the Conservative grandees. If his views had really been what your quotation suggests, they would have been identical with Hitler's.

Geoffrey Best
Oxford