I couldn't decide which was worse in
this report.
Was it
a) the lack of adequate security?
...Pro-Palestinian
demonstrators managed to bring to a halt the performance of the
Batsheva dance troupe on three separate nights during one of the
country’s biggest arts festivals...during their final performance on Saturday night, up to 20 protesters
entered the Edinburgh Playhouse auditorium and “ran amok” during
performance, forcing security staff to eject them at least nine times.
b) that the dancers presented a rather timid and cowed charcater, very un-Israeli:
Witnesses
reported that on each occasion the dancers stood stock still on stage,
the curtain was lowered and the house lights brought up until the
protesters were ejected.
c) that the audience seemed to be uninvolved accept for a post-demo cheer:
At
the end of their performance, the highly-regarded, ethnically diverse
contemporary dance group was greeted with enthusiastic applause and
standing ovations...One audience member told The Daily Telegraph:
“A few audience members, including a group including several children,
left after the first disruption but other than that the audience
remained calm and seated.
d) that the police ignored a criminal act and permitted threatening behavior::
More
than 200 protesters have also rallied outside the theatre and have been
seen shouting abuse at patrons as they left. No arrests have been made.“As we left the protesters simply screamed and yelled angrily, behind a line of police.”
e) or that they included the music of the German anti-Semite - and banned in Israel - Wagner:
During
their three one-hour performances of “Hora”, they danced to a "mash up"
including the Star Wars theme and music from Richard Wagner, the
renowned German composer.
f) or the scurrilous and fascist attitude of certain 'persons of the spirit'
Leading
up to the festival writers and artists including Iain Banks, Tom
Leonard and Al Kennedy called for the festival's artistic director
Jonathan Mills to axe the Israeli dance troupe.
g) or the craven response of the festival spokeswoman, who viewed the protest and the dance performance equally and who said:
"The festival supports freedom of expression and people's right to protest. “It
welcomes constructive criticism, regularly facilitates debates and
recognises the right to peaceful and orderly protest in any public place
including outside its theatres. Equally
the festival defends the rights of all artists, irrespective of
nationality, creed or culture to have their voices heard."
h) or that the most robust and confrontational counter-attack came from...
Brendan O'Neill who I presume is not Jewish:
Boycotts of everything Israeli have well and truly crossed the line
from political campaigns into expressions of bigotry against the people
and produce of Israel...This highly intolerant effort by one group of artists to have another
group of artists banned – or perhaps quarantined at the borders until
they renounce their home country and everything it stands for – is part
of a bigger chattering-class trend to ghettoise Israeli culture...they practise cultural apartheid against Israelis...But there is nothing political about these
censorious efforts to keep everything Israeli out of Britain. It is just
an acceptable form of bigotry, a way of advertising one’s own moral
decency by contrasting oneself to an inferior, infected people from Over
There.
^