Monday, September 05, 2011

So, the Oslo Process Was An Echo of Munich

That's the way it appears to me.

So similar:

Chamberlain's secret bid to reach a deal with Hitler, revealed in newly released documents

British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain held secret talks with Hitler's henchmen to work out ways of making the Nazis look more sympathetic to ordinary Britons, classified documents released last week reveal. The cloak-and-dagger meetings in London came shortly after Chamberlain signed his disastrous appeasement deal with Hitler in Munich in September 1938, declaring 'peace for our time' on his return to Britain. The meetings were held without the knowledge of the Cabinet and Foreign Office. Foreign Secretary Lord Halifax only learned of them later because of an MI5 mole in the German embassy.

Two newly-declassified documents show Chamberlain was ready to make more deals with Hitler after Munich, which would have the ‘happiest and most far-reaching effects for the relationship between the two countries’.  The papers reveal Chamberlain told Hitler that it would have ‘the greatest effect on public opinion in England’ if, in the event of war, they had a pact in place not to use poison gas, not to bomb each other’s civilians and to spare cities with cultural treasures.

...In his subsequent memo, Cadogan agonises over whether he should tell Lord Halifax about the clandestine meeting. He fears it might make Halifax resign and cause the Government to collapse, forcing a General Election at a time when the Nazis are poised to wage war across Europe...In the smuggled MI5 memo, Hesse tells von Ribbentrop that Chamberlain wants to finalise a deal personally with Hitler which could ensure ‘complete secrecy on the English side’ until the agreement is signed.

This also sounds familiar from the 1990s here in Israel:

...said historian Richard Cockett, author of a book on Chamberlain’s media manipulation...the just-released documents reveal that Steward had been authorised by Chamberlain to hold such meetings.  ‘If Steward was not acting under orders from Chamberlain, he was probably guilty of treason,’ he said.  ‘If he was acting under orders, then he was just a dupe.’ He said Halifax was also an appeaser but was eventually ‘changed’ by the Foreign Office and became sceptical about the policy.

Fellow historian Andrew Roberts said: ‘It is not surprising Steward was having these meetings. He was always very loyal to Chamberlain and did his bidding. Also, Steward himself was an appeaser. It is not surprising in the least bit that Chamberlain was going behind the Foreign Office’s back and holding such talks. They were sceptical of appeasement all along.’

Steward is credited as being No 10’s first spin doctor, spending a large part of his time trying to influence newspapers into writing stories that suited the Chamberlain Government...

The Israeli appeasers and behind-the-back dealers:

Shimon Peres.
Yossi Beilin.
Yair Hirschfeld.
Nimrod Novick.
Ron Pundak.
Yossi Ginnosar.

(k/t+CK)

^

So, They Are Really Disputed Territories, Not Occupied

Abbas said that the PA application to the UN calls for transforming the Palestinian territories from the status of disputed lands to a state under occupation.



That was Mahmoud Abbas, so-called head or president or whatever of the Palestinian Authority.

Thank you, Mr. Abbas.

Thanks you, Danny Ayalon.


(k/t=DF)

^


Sunday, September 04, 2011

For Those Upset With Derfner Being Fired - Don't Be Hypocrites

Don't be upset.  And don't be hypocrites.

The Left here is calling for the firing of Avri Gilad.

The initiators are Shutafut-Sharakah.

In English:

It’s time for the last word: Sign the petition to fire Avri Gilad

Countless complaints have already been submitted to the Galei Tzahal (Israel Army Radio) about the incitement and racism that Avri Gilad reveals in his program, but the broadcaster continues on as usual. We cannot allow Mr. Gilad to continue to misappropriate his role as a journalist and to sabotage the prospects for a shared society in Israel! The time has come for a public call for the firing of Avri Gilad.

In the radio program, “The last word,” broadcast on August 28, we were once again exposed to the unbridled, hate-filled views of Mr. Avri Gilad toward the Arab citizens of Israel. This time, Mr. Gilad called for the revocation of the citizenship of Arab citizens of Israel who live in the “triangle” region so as to turn Israel into a state that is “as Jewish as possible,” while also mocking the customs of Ramadan. Sign the petition and add your name to this call. When 1,000 signatures are collected, we’ll submit them to the Israel Press Council and to the Commander of Galei Tzahal, and publish the number of signatures.
Please add your name to the Hebrew petition, which states:

Dear Mr. Isaac Tonic, Commander of Galei Tzahal, and the Israel Press Council:


As Jewish and Arab citizens, we are appalled by the recurring, offensive statements of Avri Gilad against the Arab citizens of Israel in his program, “The Last Word”, and we strongly urge Galei Tzahal to fire him.


With the ridicule, venom and hatred that Mr. Gilad insists on conveying toward one-fifth of Israel’s citizens, he is violating the ethical guidelines of the Israel Press Council, which demands fair coverage and an avoidance of incitement, and misappropriating his role as a journalist in a democratic country.


Mr. Gilad systematically makes statements that incite against, and generalize about, Arab citizens of Israel. In two recent examples, Mr. Gilad suggested using Gaddafi-style violence against Israeli citizens (“surround the place, full curfew, zanga zanga, dar dar” – in his program on April 26, 2011); he declared that the day would come when “with unconcealed happiness, we will have to draft different borders… which will turn Israel into the most Jewish state possible and which will exclude the ‘triangle’ region, for example.” In the same program, a moment before he declared his aspiration for the revocation of the citizenship of 1 million citizens, Mr. Gilad mocked the fast of Ramadan, which prevents the Arab workers who are renovating his home from finishing their work according to the demands of the landlord (28.8.2011).


Since this is not a one-off slip of the tongue, but a fixed behavioral pattern, and since countless complaints already been submitted against Mr. Gilad have not been answered, we stand by our demand to fire him so that he will not be given a platform from which to continue to sabotage the prospects for a shared society in the State of Israel.

If he should be fired, according to the Left, which is now supporting Derfner, for words of presumed racism, what is the punishment for someone who advocates terror and murder?

Hypocrisy reigns.

^

B'tselem and NIF and the MFA on Transparency Legislation

As a colleague phrased it,


The Associate Director New Israel Fund believes that Israel should stop being a Jewish state — even in the basic sense of having a majority Jewish population — because only with a majority Arab population will it be truly democratic.


The New Israel for which the New Israel Fund strives is an Arab Israel.


The New Israel Fund believes that democracy forbids Jews being a majority in any state, even Israel.

In other words, I'm adding, the NIF is anti-Jewish Israel. 

You don't believe it.

You don't believe it?

Believe it:

From Wikileaks:-

¶6. (C) B'Tselem Director Jessica Montell, who estimated her 9 million NIS ($2.4 million) budget is 95 percent funded from abroad, mostly from European countries, told PolOff on February 10 that she did not believe the legislation would pass in its current form. ACRI's International Communication and Development Coordinator, Melanie Takefman, also told PolOff on February 10 that she believed the troublesome legislation would be amended and that the NGOs would likely be able to influence the draft legislation so that it would achieve its goal of greater transparency without restricting the NGOs' ability to operate. Both denied any need for greater transparency, but said they would welcome it if it applied equally to all NGOs, including NGO-Monitor and especially Jewish settler organizations.

¶7. (C) New Israel Fund (NIF) Associate Director in Israel Hedva Radovanitz, who manages grants to 350 NGOs totaling about 18 million dollars per year, told PolOff on February 23 that the campaign against the NGOs was due to the "disappearance of the political left wing" in Israel and the lack of domestic constituency for the NGOs. She noted that when she headed ACRI's Tel Aviv office, ACRI had 5,000 members, while today it has less than 800, and it was only able to muster about 5,000 people to its December human rights march by relying on the active staff of the 120 NGOs that participated. Radovanitz commented that the NIF was working behind the scenes through many NGOs to prevent the NGO legislation from passing in its current form. She commented that she believed that in 100 years Israel would be majority Arab and that the disappearance of a Jewish state would not be the tragedy that Israelis fear since it would become more democratic. She also said the NIF was currently re-evaluating its strategy and was hoping to create a movement rather than just a lot of NGOs. She said the NIF had no plans to build a human rights constituency within the right wing of Israeli society, though she believed politics had shifted to the right for the foreseeable future.

¶8. (C) The Ministry of Justice Director for Human Rights and Relations with International Organizations, Hila Tene, told PolOff in a February 10 meeting that she and the MOJ team that sit on a weekly legislative review panel would be strongly advising against the proposed legislation. She did not believe the broad definition of political activity would be included in the draft that would emerge from the Constitution and Law subcommittee. She also mentioned the vast amount of proposed legislation by the current Knesset that has failed to ever become law. The MFA Director for Human Rights and UN Issues, Simona Halperin, also told PolOff on February 11 that the MFA would be advising against the legislation. She asked for comparative legislation from the U.S. regarding NGOs and the registration of foreign agents.


All nice Jews, eh?

UPDATE

For Immediate Release
September 5, 2011
Wikileaks: US Cable quotes NGO Monitor and NGOs;
NIF official:“disappearance of a Jewish state would not be [a] tragedy”

JERUSALEM – A confidential cable from the U.S. Embassy in Tel Aviv released by Wikileaks, contains controversial comments by a New Israel Fund (NIF) official, relating to Israel’s future as a Jewish state...
“These comments from a high ranking NIF official reiterates the serious questions regarding NIF’s commitment to Jewish self-determination and Israel as a Jewish state,” said Prof. Gerald Steinberg, president of NGO Monitor. “NIF is the most powerful non-governmental actor in Israel, and its policies affect millions of Israelis, without providing any accountability or checks and balances...
More broadly, the cable reflects the centrality of the lack of transparency regarding European government funding for Israeli political NGOs reflects, including their role in the “war crimes” accusations used in the discredited Goldstone report...According to the cable, Radovanitz further stated that “NIF had no plans to build a human rights constituency within the right wing of Israeli society, though she believed politics had shifted to the right for the foreseeable future.” On this point, Prof. Steinberg added, “This reinforces extensive evidence that the current leadership of the NIF sees their primary function as a narrow political opposition group, rather promoting democratic and civic values in all sectors of Israeli society.”

NGO Monitor also notes that the cable identifies Radovanitz as a former employee of the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI), a recipient of nearly $1.3 million in NIF funding in 2009-10. Radovanitz was also the manager of Physicians for Human Rights–Israel (PHRI), and is on the board of Hamoked: Center for the defence of the individual, another NIF organization that promotes “war crimes” and similar allegations.

_______________

UPDATE

The NIF response:

...Ms. Radanovitz is no longer an employee of the New Israel Fund; she left her position almost a year ago. Her comments, as reported by Wikileaks, are her personal views. They do not reflect the policies or positions of the New Israel Fund. We valued Hedva’s contribution to NIF, but it also true that her viewpoints diverged from those of the organization...

Here's her statement.


I wonder how long she was employed.

And she was hired after being Executive Director, Physicians for Human Rights/Israel, a fairly nasty anti-Israel group.

VS adds to me:

How did Hedva Radanovitz's "personal views" affect NIF grants in the period of her employment?

Can we get a list of all their current employees whose private views are similar to those of Hedva Radanovitz?

Who was responsible for hiring Hedva Radanovitz, an individual whose personal perspectives are apparently so contrary to NIF principles? What happened to him/her?

What steps have you taken to ensure that your employees are not personally undermining the NIF's mission in their free time?
^

My Slogan for Pal. UDI

.

September 20:
It won't be the end of the world.
It won't be the start of
a "Palestine state".

^

Hosting DG on the Security Council & Int'l Law

Here:

After Mavi Marmara,

...at the Security Council on Monday voices were raised against the blockade, and the pressure to abandon it is bound to intensify.


the Security Council condemned Israel calling the blockade illegal.


Several envoys said Israel was in violation of international law, not least because Security Council resolution 1860 passed in the midst of the Gaza war in January 2009 had called for ending the blockade and opening unfettered access to humanitarian assistance throughout the strip...The United States, which habitually defends Israel in the council, said that the attempt to run the blockade by sea was ill advised...


Now the Palmer report concludes blockade is legal:

A long-awaited United Nations review of Israel’s 2010 raid on a Turkish-based flotilla in which nine passengers were killed has found that Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza is both legal and appropriate...

Nu, I ask you, are these guys plain dumb, uneducated or just biased against Israel?

^

September 20 Will Come and Go and We'll Still Be Here

Despite the news of September 20:-

The Palestinian Authority (PA) has declared September 20 as the date when it will apply for the United Nations' recognition of Palestine as an independent state.

"[Acting PA Chief] Mahmud Abbas will personally present the request to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon... at the opening of the 66th session [on September 20]," PA Foreign Minister Riyad al-Maliki told reporters on Saturday in his office in Ramallah, AFP reported.

Abbas "will insist on this historic initiative and Ban Ki-moon will present the request to the Security Council," he added.

Maliki further added that the leadership of the PA had chosen September to submit their bid as it coincides with Lebanon's presidency of the UN Security Council.

"We chose to submit it in September because the Lebanese envoy will be president of the Security Council and plays a pivotal role," Maliki said.

That day of September 20 will come and go and we'll still be here.

And so will this blog.

^

Tel Shiloh Excavation Needs Volunteers

Volunteers needed to dig at Tel Shiloh!

Call Ofer at 0547776489

^

The Chutzpah of Using Martin Luther King Jr.

From this Pal. site:


^

Quiz: Who Wrote This and About Who?

This:

‘silly chattering windbag of conceited, gushing, flat-chested, man-woman, globe-trotting, rump-wagging blethering ass.’

Answer.

^

Making Fun of Ahmadinejad

From here:


^

"If we want to make peace, we have to redraw the lines"

Who said that?

Avigdor Lieberman of Yisrael Beiteinu?

Some other radical rightwing Zionist?

A leftwing radical progressive?

Nope.

Sari Nusseibeh who

...proposes a Palestinian-Israeli federation comprised of two separate governments with porous borders and a shared capital.

"It's impossible by now to pick up a knife and saw" Jerusalem into sections, he said.

Likewise, he said, the demographic and geographic realities have changed since Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza Strip in 1967.

"If we want to make peace, we have to redraw the lines," based on current ethnic divisions, he said.

Some people are so desperate.


(k/t=AR)

^

Not That Peaceful at Eretz Shalom

Remember that Eretz Shalom conference?

Well Rabbi Froman has a surprise for the participants:-

Rabbi Froman Supports Palestinian Bid to UN

Rabbi Menachem Froman Wednesday supported and expressed his and other Israeli rabbis' wishes for success to the Palestinian bid to gain full United Nations membership of a Palestinian state within 1967 borders and East Jerusalem as its capital in September, during his meeting with President Mahmoud Abbas.

Froman said that establishing a Palestinian state benefits the peace process and Israel, as well as working to achieve comprehensive, just peace and stability for the region and the world.

Abbas received Froman in his Ramallah headquarters and reiterated the
Palestinian leadership's commitment to the peace process with Israel and
that the Palestinian bid follows Israel's refusal to abide by international
law and agreements.

...Froman congratulated Abbas on the occasion of Eid al-Fitr, the Islamic
holiday marking the end of Ramadan, the holy month of fasting for Muslims,
and wished for peace and co-existence between Palestinians and Israelis
through establishing the independent Palestinian state.

Froman offered to establish a committee of both Palestinian and Israeli
religious figures to stop mutual instigation, and to send the committee to
the US administration to spread the religious calling of peace and of
establishing a Palestinian state to live side-by-side with Israel.

From a news report I read, Dany Dayan, Yesha Council chair, read them the riot act as regards the idea of an independent Pal. state.

Will update.

^

Six Decades?

See that "six decades" there?

A Proms performance by the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra was disrupted by demonstrators at the Royal Albert Hall last night.

Around 30 pro-Palestinian protesters were eventually removed from the concert after groups shouted, sang, and unfurled a flag over one of the galleries. BBC Radio 3, which was broadcasting the concert live, was forced to come off air, the first time disturbances have forced it off air in its history...

“It was obviously very carefully orchestrated,” a spokesperson said. The protest was co-ordinated by a number of pro-Palestinian groups including the BDS, a coalition of human-rights activists who campaign for an independent Palestine, and the Boycott Israel Network. Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, a pro-Palestinian activist who was part of the first group to be removed from the hall, told The Times last night that they were targetting the IPO because they are used as “a propaganda method by the Israeli state”. “The boycott movement acted because for six decades the Palestinians have been subjected to endless oppression and illegal settlement of their land,” she said.

Six decades back is...1948.

Pre-1967.

Pre-"occupation".

Pre-"settlements".

Think about that.

And

Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi is a Jewish campaigner for Palestinian rights based in London. She recently helped found Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods, to belie the myth that the boycott campaign is anti-semitic. On the contrary she believes Jews whose ancestors experienced so much suffering have a duty to act when fellow Jews are guilty of oppressing others.


She was arrested

...on June 29 2008 when Ms Wimborne-Idrissi held up a sign reading 'Palestinian blood on Israeli hands' at an Israeli parade along Haymarket in central London. She also dyed her hands red...Solicitor Simon Natas, representing Wimborne-Idrissi, said his client’s action had been “entirely peaceful and legitimate”.  Daniel Machover, Chair of Lawyers for Palestinian Human Rights (LPHR), said: “Given Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestinian land and the persistent brutality of the Israeli authorities towards Palestinians, as witnessed in Gaza just weeks ago, supporters of these policies cannot expect their celebrations or marches to be held without reasonable dissent."

Not another ASHamed Jew.


Saturday, September 03, 2011

Did An Attack on Jaloud Rake Place?

Arab sources:

Dozens of armed Israeli settlers invaded Jaloud village, south of the northern West Bank city of Nablus, attacked residents and homes, and demanded the indigenous Palestinian villagers to leave.  Ghassan Douglas, in charge of the settlements file at the Palestinian Authority in the northern part of the West Bank, stated that the armed settlers attacked several homes and dozens of residents, while threatening them and demanding them to leave their homes and lands.

Clashes were reported between the local residents and the invading settlers; Israeli soldiers arrived at the scene and fired gas bombs and concussion grenades at the Palestinian villagers; several residents were treated for the effects of tear gas inhalation.

I haven't the faintest idea what Ghassan is talking about but from past experience, I doubt he described what happened.

Other news in Hebrew:

- Friday at Alei-Ayin.

- Jaloud


Shooting of crowd-control measures was carried out directed at terrorists on the outskirts of the nearby village of Jalud to Achiyah.
Also on the outskirts of the village of Kutzra forces needed to act in order to prevent terrorists from reaching into the community of Esh-Kodesh.

Land, Peace Exchange Equality

Extracts from Guy Bechor's Mideast rules must change
Land for peace formula dead, Israel must adopt doctrine based on equality

Ever since the Six-Day War we’ve been hearing, like a mantra, the buzz about “land for peace.” The tiny Israel, a small dot on the globe, shall give up “land,” and in exchange it shall receive “peace” from the Arab side.

This mantra was so absolute that it was accepted here as an unqualified truth that cannot be denied...s mantra is no longer valid.

While Israel paid with hard, irreversible currency when it handed over land to the Arab side, the Arabs paid with soft, completely reversible currency - that is, words and agreements.

...Now we are seeing how blatantly unequal this formula is; what’s more, it also hints at ostensible Israeli guilt, while the Arab side is seemingly doing Israel a favor...The absence of equality between the two parts of this equation should have rung warning bells in Israel a while ago. Now, the time has come to adopt a formula based on equality, as is common among the nations of the world, where no side is doing a favor to the other: Either land in exchange for land, or peace in exchange for peace...Words in exchange for words, land in exchange for land, and interests in exchange for interests.

...The waves of violence in the Arab world and the threat on the status quo, as well as the Palestinian Authority’s defiance in the face of all agreements with Israel, require new, fresh thinking...This is a golden opportunity for Israel to reexamine its strategic doctrine vis-à-vis the Arab world, thereby making a genuine contribution to the better management of the conflict with the Arab side, a conflict that has lasted for too long.

That makes sense.

^

Middle East Violence in Toronto

Saw this?


In text:

What constitutes a physical assault in Toronto these days?

This would appear to be straightforward. If, for example, one individual punches another, surely that’s assault. Especially if the punch in question was witnessed. And photographed. But as I learned firsthand on Sunday, a fist in the face doesn’t necessarily constitute assault in our increasingly culturally sensitive Toronto.

The details: I was at Yonge-Dundas Square with my nine-year-old son. We ate pizza. We drank bubble tea. And I used my new Canon camera to take photos of this neon shrine. Suddenly, a woman wearing a hijab ran toward me. She was part of a group that included two women wearing full face-covering burkas. She was screaming: “We are Muslim! You do not take pictures of us!” (Odd. I can’t find the “no photos” rule in the Qur’an.)

I informed the lady I was in a public square in a democracy. I can actually take pictures of whomever I please.

And then: Ka-pow! Her fist collided with my face. Worse, she almost knocked my new camera from my hands. My son and I were then surrounded by a mob of about 20 people, many of whom were speaking Arabic. One kept demanding I surrender my camera to him.

It was surreal. Was I in Toronto — or Riyadh?

I spotted a group of bicycle-mounted police officers. I burst through the mob with my son and made a beeline towards them. I told a Toronto Police officer what had happened and I wanted to press assault charges. Better yet, a man and a woman came forward as eyewitnesses.

The 50-something couple, originally from Syria, told the police they had observed the entire affair and my allegations were true. The couple said they understood Arabic and knew what the mob was saying.

Spidey Senses

Alas, my Spidey Senses started to tingle when I overheard the questions being asked of the witnesses. “Was it a closed-fist punch or an open hand? Was it the front or the back of the hand?”

Huh? Physical contact had been made. Why did severity matter?

After the officer took my statement, he went over to the offending woman. Another constable was inexplicably miffed I was (legally) taking photos in the first place. The irony: Just above our heads a Toronto Police Service sphere was videotaping the activities.

The officer interrogated the woman. She was still hysterical. Good. The constable would encounter firsthand what I had been forced to deal with earlier.

The cop walked back to me. No charges would be laid, he said, because he believed the woman’s story — namely, she was merely trying to knock the camera out of my hands.

Got that? Apparently, attempted property damage is OK. If a face gets in the way of a would-be vandalizing fist... hey, accidents happen.

The Syrian eyewitnesses were speechless. I continued to plead my case.

Toronto Police cruisers are emblazoned with the slogan, “To serve and protect”. But increasingly, the unofficial slogan seems closer to, “F.I.D.O.” (“Forget It; Drive On.”)

The fact we have Islamists living amongst us who despise western values isn’t news. But surely you can’t just sock someone in the mouth.

Well, apparently you can — as long as the intent of the aggressor was merely to inflict property damage.

World’s upside-down. Just thought you should know.

(k/t+ RH)

^

Women's Event at Tel Shiloh on Chana's Prayer


Wednesday, September 21, 2011

^

I'm in Wikileaks

I'm in Wikileaks [finally ;->) ]:

¶3. (C) Some Post settler contacts said that it was "about time" for Wallerstein to resign. "I have the utmost respect for Pinchas," Shilo-based settler, Yisrael "Winky" [should be Winkie] Medad, told PolOff, "but it was organizationally dumb to have both (YESHA Chairman) Dani (Dayan) and Pinchas in leadership positions -- it was bound to create friction." Medad noted that Wallerstein and Dayan are of two different generations of settler activists, and said that with the resignation of the elder Wallerstein, he expected significant changes in the policies of the YESHA Council. Medad argued that the YESHA Council had done a poor job of engaging radical settler youth movements. Until now, the council has avoided avoid any association with so-called "hilltop youths," said Medad.  "Maybe it's time to figure out how to work with them and use them for the YESHA Council's causes. Of course, we don't condone violence. We need to use their energy towards effective means of protests, not violence."

From this:

Subject: As Old Guard Resigns, Yesha Council Settlers Debate New Strategies

Origin: Consulate Jerusalem (Israel)
Cable time: Tue, 2 Feb 2010 20:29 UTC
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL

Source (with thanks to AL)
VZCZCXYZ0000
PP RUEHWEB
DE RUEHJM #0201/01 0332029
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
P 022029Z FEB 10
FM AMCONSUL JERUSALEM
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 7463
INFO RUEHAM/AMEMBASSY AMMAN 8793
RUEHEG/AMEMBASSY CAIRO 0027
RUEHTV/AMEMBASSY TEL AVIV 5166
RHEHNSC/WHITE HOUSE NSC
RUEKJCS/JOINT STAFF WASHDCHide headerC O N F I D E N T I A L JERUSALEM 000201
SIPDIS
NEA FOR FRONT OFFICE, SEMEP, AND IPA; NSC FOR SHAPIRO/KUMAR; JOINT STAFF FOR LTGEN SELVA
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/01/2020

TAGS: PGOV [Internal Governmental Affairs], PBTS [National Boundaries, Territories, and Sovereignty], KPAL [Palestinian Affairs], KWBG [West Bank and Gaza], IS [Israel]

SUBJECT: AS OLD GUARD RESIGNS, YESHA COUNCIL SETTLERS

DEBATE NEW STRATEGIES

Classified By: Consul General Daniel Rubinstein for reasons 1.4 (b) and (d).

¶1. (SBU) Summary. On January 11, Pinchas Wallerstein resigned as director-general of the Council of Jewish Communities of Judea, Samaria, and the Gaza Strip (known as the "YESHA Council," from the Hebrew acronym for "Judea, Samaria, and Gaza"). Wallerstein told the Israeli press that he was resigning over a disagreement with YESHA Council Chairman Dani Dayan over the council's stance on settler resistance to GOI policies. Prompted by his announcement, settler activists gathered in Gush Etzion on January 17 to debate the current status and likely future of West Bank settlements, followed by a closed session of the YESHA Council. Post settler contacts had a mixed reaction to Wallerstein's resignation, with some saying that the YESHA Council needs to change its structure and strategy to remain effective, moving away from confrontational strategies and rebuilding ties to the Israeli government. Others argued that the YESHA Council has made itself irrelevant through its disproportionate focus on fringe group interests, at the expense of the major settlement blocs. End Summary.

CHANGING OF THE GUARD
---------------------

¶2. (U) Three months into the GOI's ten-month moratorium on new residential construction in West Bank settlements, longtime settler leader Pinchas Wallerstein announced on January 11 that he would be stepping down from the executive board of the YESHA Council at the end of that month.

Wallerstein -- the last of the "old guard" of the Gush Emunim settlement movement, the predecessor to the YESHA Council -- cited the organization's failure to distance itself from extremist settlers as a primary reason for his resignation.  Wallerstein publicly criticized the YESHA Council for failing to condemn attacks carried out by extremist settlers against Palestinians as part of a so-called "price tag" on the moratorium. He also argued that the YESHA Council should have taken a stand against the public expressions of opposition by Israel Defense Forces (IDF) soldiers against GOI orders to evacuate unauthorized West Bank outposts, saying, "It is our duty today to make sure the military isn't involved in the politics of evacuation and demolition."

¶3. (C) Some Post settler contacts said that it was "about time" for Wallerstein to resign. "I have the utmost respect for Pinchas," Shilo-based settler, Yisrael "Winky" Medad, told PolOff, "but it was organizationally dumb to have both (YESHA Chairman) Dani (Dayan) and Pinchas in leadership positions -- it was bound to create friction." Medad noted that Wallerstein and Dayan are of two different generations of settler activists, and said that with the resignation of the elder Wallerstein, he expected significant changes in the policies of the YESHA Council. Medad argued that the YESHA Council had done a poor job of engaging radical settler youth movements. Until now, the council has avoided avoid any association with so-called "hilltop youths," said Medad. "Maybe it's time to figure out how to work with them and use them for the YESHA Council's causes. Of course, we don't condone violence. We need to use their energy towards effective means of protests, not violence."

RUMBLINGS OF CHANGES
---------------------

¶4. (C) The week after Wallerstein's resignation, approximately 120 settlers gathered under the auspices of the Gush Etzion Regional Council on January 17 to attend a conference titled, "Judea, Samaria, and What's Around It."  Shaul Goldstein, head of the Gush Etzion Regional Council and organizer of the event, told PolOff, "The purpose of the conference was to examine how we're viewed by Israelis, and to exchange ideas about how to promote our mission for a unified Land of Israel." Goldstein told PolOff that in the course of the conference, discussions took place among Israeli government, NGO, and media representatives on topics such as "How the Media Views Settlers", "Influencing the U.S. Administration," and "The Demographic Problem." Afterwards, the YESHA Council held a closed-door meeting to discuss uspecified policy changes, which Goldstein said would be announced in the coming weeks. Note: On January 31, Naftali Bennett, a former aide to then-opposition leader Netanyahu and a resident of the town of Raanana on Israel's coastal plain, not of the West Bank, was appointed to replace Wallerstein as director-general of the YESHA Council. Israeli press reported that the appointment of Bennett reflects the changing image of YESHA Council to incorporate the support of Israelis who do not live within the occupied territories. End Note.

¶5. (C) "Pinchas is a great man, but YESHA Council needs new blood -- it's stagnant," Goldstein argued,  "The old council doesn't work anymore." Goldstein said he proposed to the YESHA Council that it split into two divisions: municipality leaders, who would focus on building relationships with the Israeli government and lobbying for services and funding; and the elected council members, who would "focus on the politics." "The YESHA Council used to have good relations with the (Israeli government), and negotiated concessions for us." Goldstein said. "Now, they're seen as protesters and troublemakers." Goldstein said his "clear" priority is "to get funding for my schools and services for my communities."

¶6. (C) On January 24, the Jewish holiday of Tu B'Shvat (Arbor Day), the Israeli press reported that Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu planted a tree in the Kfar Etzion settlement. In the course of his speech, Netanyahu said that the Gush Etzion settlement bloc will remain part of Israel. Goldstein, who organized the event, told PolOff, "My friends were angry that I let Bibi (Netanyahu) in -- they said, 'Why are you legitimizing him?' I said, 'I don't need to legitimize him, he's the Prime Minister! I need him to legitimize me.'" Noting fellow settlers' concerns that such a conciliatory approach to the GOI may force settler leaders to concede to the evacuation of certain other settlements, Goldstein said, "Well, this may be the case.""

CHANGE THE SOLUTION, REBRAND THE SETTLER
----------------------------------------

¶7. (C) "What we learned from the (January 17) conference," said Goldstein, "is that the Ministry of Defense, the Israeli government, Tel Aviv, those left-wing activists -- all are concerned about the demographic problem." Goldstein noted that Israeli annexation of the West Bank would bring 2.35 million Palestinians inside Israeli borders, diluting the Jewish identity of the State of Israel. Goldstein said that he realized that Israeli settlers needed to find a solution to that demographic problem if they wanted "mainstream Israel" to accept them. "People say we're at the heart of the problem," Goldstein said. "Well, maybe we can be at the heart of the solution."

¶8. (C) On this note, Goldstein told Post he had been selected by a group of settlement-supporters to write a proposal on potential resolutions of "the demographic problem" posed by annexation of the West Bank to Israel. "I have some ideas," said Goldstein. "Not everyone will agree, but it will solve the problem." Goldstein clarified that he had undertaken this initiative outside of the remit of the YESHA Council. "A group of us are starting something new," Goldstein said. "There will be another conference in a few weeks, then we will do some fundraising."

¶9. (C) Fellow January 17 conference attendee and Goldstein friend Avihu Cohen, who co-founded the Tzur Shalem outpost in the Gush Etzion bloc, told PolOff, "The two-state solution won't work. The solution is to annex the West Bank." Cohen explained that his proposed solution would allow Arabs who want to live in Israel to work and live in Israel and vote in local elections, but they would not be able to participate in national elections. Cohen told PolOff that, "Israel is a Jewish state and non-Jews should not be allowed to participate in shaping the nation."

¶10. (C) With this premise in mind, Cohen told PolOff he is starting a new organization with the aim of "re-branding the settler," in order to combat negative images and win the heart of mainstream Israel. "The regular Tel Avivan sees settlers as Arab-hating, Uzi-toting, kippah-wearing extremists -- whereas the majority of us are not like that. We're law-abiding, respectful citizens," Cohen said. His first step would be to reach out to yeshiva students, "when they are at the age of shaping their thoughts and opinions," to explain to them the settler image problem, and "show them they can contribute to the new strategy of 'winning hearts' instead of turning to extremism and insubordination."

¶11. (C) Cohen said his strategy involved developing relationships with the Israeli government, "mainstream Israel," youth movements, and the international community.  The goal would be "to show the world that the settler is not crazy," and to demonstrate that "there's a solution for everyone to live peacefully in Israel -- and it's not the two-state solution," Cohen said. Cohen told PolOff that his initiative has the backing of Goldstein and hinted that Goldstein may be involved.

YESHA WHO?
----------

¶12. (C) Other settlement leaders told PolOff that they had not followed the YESHA Council's changing of the guard closely, and did not participate in its internal politics. Settler leaders in large settlement blocs contiguous to the Green Line were dismissive of Wallerstein's resignation.  Rabbi Yaacov Guterman, mayor of Modiin Illit, told PolOff, "YESHA? Oh, I don't know what they do. We're different. We're not part of them." Ron Nachman, mayor of Ariel, told PolOff he had no connections with the YESHA Council. "I'm the mayor of Ariel, I'm in charge and I'm committed to my city. I don't need someone to be elected above my head to tell me what to do," Nachman said.

¶13. (C) Settler leaders in the remote Jordan Valley concurred. "The Jordan Valley is not YESHA," David Elhayani, head of the Jordan Valley Regional Council, told PolOff.  "What does YESHA stand for? They represent the little settlements in the middle (of the West Bank) that are always screaming and protesting." Just as the YESHA Council meant little to residents of Maale Adumim and other large settlement blocs adjacent to the Green Line, it meant little to settlers in the Jordan Valley, he said.

¶14. (C) Elhayani argued that, given his good relations with the Israeli government, the YESHA Council was irrelevant. He told PolOff that he had received private assurances from GOI officials that there are no plans to give up the Jordan Valley as part of any peace deal. Currently, Elhayani said, he is planning to build 100 additional houses in the Jordan Valley -- which is "a lot for here," he said -- directly following the end of the current moratorium.

Who is Avihu Cohen?  What happened to his initiative?

More references:

 6 Jan 2010

¶10. (C) Moti Seide, director of utilities and services in Modiin Illit, told PolOff, &We moved out here at first 25 years ago, thinking, we'll try it out ... and time passed and it was okay. All of our children grew up here, and married, and live here. And now, we don,t know what will be in the future. Netanyahu said it,s for peace talks. Well, we don,t know if there will ever be peace talks. So why freeze our lives?" Shilo resident and prominent settler activist Yisrael "Winky" Medad agreed, saying, "look, we,re angry with Netanyahu because there,s no plan. We need to know that there is a future for us and we,re not frozen indefinitely." RUBINSTEIN

3 Dec 2009

SETTLERS PROMISE MORE CONFRONTATIONS TO COME
--------------------------------------------

¶11. (C) In general, Post contacts promised that GOI attempts to enforce the moratorium would be met by confrontation -- but not, most suggested, by organized violence. "The demonstrations come and go," said Yisrael "Winky" Medad, Shilo resident. "We hear about inspectors or police coming, then we respond. If they come to Shilo, I will be out there, blocking the entrance." Ruchie Avital, Ofra resident, told PolOff, that protests and lobbying efforts were being organized at the grassroots level, and "there are no plans to use violence."

DESPITE SUSPENSION, PLANNING CONTINUES
--------------------------------------

¶12. (C) According to settler and NGO contacts, settler leaders continue to plan for future demonstrations and illegal construction. Medad told PolOff on December 2 that settlers from across the West Bank will meet in Ofra on December 5 to discuss the current situation and plan additional demonstrations, including a Jerusalem protest in the week of December 7. ¶13. (C) Hagit Ofran of Peace Now told PolOff on December 2 that despite Netanyahu's moratorium announcement, GOI planning for new settlement contruction appears to be continuing. On November 30, Ofran observed, "there was an advertisement for two tenders from the Ministry of Housing, looking for someone to manage the planning and implementation
of housing projects in Efrat, Maale Adumim, and Beitar Illit. We're still monitoring what this means, but it seems like they are preparing for construction when the 10 months is over."

24 Sept. 2009

HAMAS, SETTLER ACTIVISTS CRITICIZE SPEECH'S LANGUAGE
--------------------------------------------- -------

¶6. (SBU) Hamas spokesman Tahir al-Nunu was predictably critical of the speech, speaking of his "astonishment" that the USG would refer to "the Jewish nature of Israel" at the UNGA, and terming settlement activity "a war crime, and not merely a hindrance to the peace process." Post's contacts among Israeli settlers in the West Bank were equally critical. Israeli-American Shilo resident and blogger JERUSALEM 00001719 002 OF 002 Yisrael "Winky" Medad's comments were characteristic: "O take umbrage," Medad said, "at the characterization of President Obama of my residential community as 'illegitimate.' More than 'illegal,' that term conveys to me a sense of moral repugnancy which I find hard to accept."

¶7. (C) Medad continued, "For Mr. Obama to term the situation of Jews living in their homeland as distinct from any eventual political resolving of the conflict as 'illegitimate' is wrong, is mean-spirited, and simply invites further Arab attempts to kill us, to dislodge us from our homes...I was quite disappointed." Ron Nachman, Mayor of Ariel settlement, was more blunt. "The President listens to Rahm Emmanuel and those left-(wing) peaceniks," Nachman said. "They mislead the President. I want to tell Mr. President that he is not doing anything new, and the whole process will not succeed. I would like to invite him to Ariel, and for him to bring with him Abu Mazen from the Palestinian side. I want to host (negotiations) here in Ariel, instead of the Waldorf Astoria." MARCHESE

17 Sept 2009

Settler-Palestinian Confrontations North of Ramallah
--------------------------------------------- -------

¶2. (C) On September 11, PolOff visited the site of recent clashes between Palestinians from al-Mughayyer village (north of Ramallah) and Israeli settlers from the nearby Adei Ad outpost. A resident of al-Mughayyer and an AmCit, Jamil Abdullah, told PolOff that on the morning of September 4, he and two of his neighbors discovered that 272 olive trees and 30 fig trees growing on their properties had been cut down.  "These olive trees were 35 years old. It will take 10 years to regrow them," Abdullah said. He blamed settlers from the
Adei Ad outpost adjacent to Shilo settlement, where twenty Israeli families currently live.

¶3. (C) Upon discovering the damage, Abdullah said, the farmers notified the Israeli District Coordination Office (DCO). (Note: the land in question is located in Area C, outside the jurisdiction of the local Palestinian Civil Police (PCP) station.) Israel Defense Force (IDF) personnel arrived about 30 minutes later, took pictures of the damaged groves, and filed an official report, he said. When other villagers appeared on their farmlands to inspect the situation, Abdullah said, armed settlers from Adei Ad appeared on the hilltop above and began to throw stones at the villagers. According to Abdullah, IDF soldiers later arrived at the scene to disperse the crowd.

Differing Accounts of the Incidents
-----------------------------------

¶4. (C) Yisrael "Winky" Medad -- a Shilo settler, and also an AmCit -- offered a very different account of the incident which he did not directly witness, but learned of from settlement security officers. According to Medad, earlier in the week, Palestinian villagers had approached Adei Ad outpost at night and destroyed a "structure" (which the local PCP chief later described to PolOff as a deserted caravan). Medad said that, when al-Mughayyer villagers returned to the outpost the next morning, an altercation broke out between them and Adei Ad settlers. Medad confirmed that the IDF then dispersed the crowd. ¶5. (C) Jamil Abdullah denied that local villagers had set off the confrontation. "We see settlers (from the nearby outpost) intruding on Palestinian lands once a week," he said. "But we're afraid of (going to) Adei Ad because we'll be shot at."  ¶6. (C) Local PCP Chief Abu Bakr offered a third version of the events, noting ruefully that Palestinian villagers occasionally infiltrated Israeli settlements to steal "livestock and other things." At the same time, Abu Bakr placed the blame for the September 4 incident squarely on the settlers. "The settlers are very aggressive, they only know the language of destruction."

¶7. (C) Comment: This incident provides a glimpse at the difficulty of establishing ground truth on Palestinian-Israeli violence in the West Bank. The close proximity of settlers and Palestinians creates constant tension that periodically erupts in incidents such as these.   RUBINSTEIN^

23 JAN 2009

HaYovel Outpost Deepening its Roots
-----------------------------------

¶3. (C) Etkes described new construction at HaYovel outpost, southeast of Eli settlement. He said bulldozers are digging electrical transmission lines and sewage channels to connect the outpost to Eli's electricity grid and sewage system. According to Etkes, construction began December 27. PA security contacts told Polspec January 15 that settlers blocked the main entrance to the Palestinian village of Qaryut on January 14 to lay a "road" on a nearby hill, next to HaYovel outpost. Shilo settler Yisrael Medad told PolOff January 18 that a new optical cable is being laid there to connect Ha Yovel to Eli and Shilo. Peace Now activist Hagit Ofran told Poloff on January 22 that she had observed a new patrol road connecting Eli and HaYovel to the main highway on January 21.

18 SEPT 2008

Settler Leaders Don't Support the Attack, but Avoid Condemnation
----------------------------------

¶4. (C) Yesha Council Chairman Dani Dayan told Poloff that he had visited the boy in the hospital in Petah Tikva late September 13. He said the boy was stabbed seven times, but survived. "I don't like what my guys did but let's get serious, no one got seriously hurt in Asira, while in Yitzhar there was an intention to kill," he said. He added that Israeli police told him no one in Asira al-Qabaliyah was injured by live fire. Gush Etzion Regional Council Chairman and Yesha Council member Shaul Goldstein told Poloff that the settler reaction "was not justified," but the media is "a dog looking to bite the settlers," focusing only on settler aggression, not the reported Palestinian attack. Settler contact Yisrael Medad told Poloff that "if the security forces were doing their job, we wouldn't have to do it ourselves."

20 JUN 2008

Police Clash with Yitzhar Settlers, Several Injured
----------------------------------

¶2. (C) Mounting tension at Yitzhar settlement (on a ridge southwest of Nablus) boiled over on June 19 when Israeli border police arrived to investigate a reported settler weapons cache, remove an illegal caravan at a Yitzhar extension called "Havat Shaked" (not on the list of post-March 2001 outposts) and to post evacuation orders for other illegal structures. Press reported that four policemen and eleven settlers were injured in clashes during the operation. Settler Yisrael Medad told PolOff that settlers unsuccessfully attempted to block police from entering Yitzhar and, once police were inside, blocked the settlement's exit and punctured police vehicle tires. Settler Rivka Livnat from neighboring Elon Moreh settlement complained to PolOff that police "beat and injured" Yitzhar's rabbi in the scuffles.

11 SEPT 2007

Classified By: Consul General Jake Walles, per reasons 1.4 (b) and (d)

¶1. (C) SUMMARY: Poloff visited Shilo and Ofrah, two major settlements north of Ramallah on August 31. Surrounding outposts included Amona, where the GoI destroyed nine permanent structures in February 2006 and where there are now over fifty caravans. There are clusters of caravans on most hilltops surrounding each settlement that are inhabited by young settlers. Several of these outposts are on the GoI's list of 24 outposts being discussed for removal in the near future. END SUMMARY.

¶2. (C) Shilo and Ofrah are both well outside the route of the separation barrier. They are home to settlers motivated primarily by ideology but who also enjoy the economic benefits of settlement life and proximity to Jerusalem. The thirty-year old settlements are growing, largely via hilltop caravan clusters.

Shilo and the Hilltops
----------------------

¶3. (C) According to Yisrael "Winkie" Medad, a settler leader and long time ConGen contact, Shilo was established in 1977 "disguised as an archaeological dig" and is believed to be the site of the ancient tabernacle. Today, there is an ongoing excavation of two fourth century Byzantine churches with spectacularly preserved mosaic tile floors. Shilo has 250 families (an estimated 20 percent of them American). Medad said in the last three years, some forty new families have moved to Shilo, while only ten have left. ¶4. (C) Medad told PolOff that Shilo's relationship with the neighboring Arab village of Turmusayya (population 3000 and 30 percent American) has soured after two Intifadas. Asked about permanent status issues, Medad said Shilo residents "don't think in those terms," but they do want an underground tunnel connecting Shilo to the larger settlement of Eli to the North and another underground tunnel connecting Eli and the Ariel settlement, inside the route of the separation barrier. ¶5. (C) Medad showed PolOff caravans at the outposts Achiya, Adead [Adei-Ad], Kedat, and Esh Kodesh, which are on the hilltops east of Shilo and "attached" to the settlement. He said they house young and newlywed settlers and usually rent for about USD 100 monthly. According to Medad, the outposts are on land legally "zoned" for Shilo and are supported by the larger settlement.

Ofrah and Amona
---------------

¶6. (C) Poloff visited Ofrah with Ruchie Avital, the settlement's spokeswoman and a resident since 1986. According to Avital, Gush Emunim developed Ofrah in 1976, and the settlement now has 500 families and additional outlying hilltop outposts. Two of the outposts, Ofrah East and Ofrah Southeast, are on the GoI list of 24 outposts that were established after March 2001 and that are being discussed for removal.  ¶7. (C) PolOff and Avital visited Amona outpost, where the GoI removed nine permanent structures in February 2006 and which now has over fifty caravans. PolOff saw nine large piles of rebar and chopped concrete left after the 2006 GoI action and that Avital said inspire the settlers to continue their activities at Amona. PolOff saw young settlers constructing a settlement movement museum housed in two caravans, toured a new sheep farm with some thirty sheep and visited an outlook gazebo with plexiglass horizon maps that was recently completed by Ofrah youth. Avital claimed the GOI will not allow Amona additional caravans, and called the GoI's 2006 actions "evil and twisted," but said life there is "thriving."  WALLES

23 AUG 2007

¶5. (C) Rachelle Heller, who was an original settler at Beit El in 1977, told Poloff that Givat Ha'or is Beit El youth enjoying the spring and conducting ritual bath ceremonies and not a new outpost. Yisrael Medad of the nearby Shilo settlement told Poloff that the youth are engaging in a "harmless" Kabbalah ritual and dismissed their activity as "skinny dipping." They indicated that after summer the youth will return to school and abandon their structures

Comment
-------

¶6. (C) Per refs B-C, PolOffs have seen similar youth encampments this summer at Homesh in the Northern West Bank and Lucifer Hill in the South Hebron Hills, and Peace Now reports similar activities at Hashomonaim, Shevut Ami (south of Quedumim), Harchivi (next to the Alon Moreh settlement) and Maon in the Southern Hebron Hills. It is difficult to determine whether the settler youth will abandon these encampments at the end of summer, and quite possibly they do not intend them as proto-outposts. However, the encampments -- especially Givat Ha'or, because of its proximity to the Beit El checkpoint and the daily traffic of international diplomats and NGO's -- may serve to test the tolerance of the IDF, Israeli public opinion, Palestinians and the international community for settlement expansion and activity. END
COMMENT.  DUFFY
 

28 MAR 2007
 

¶1. (C) According to local press, all of the roughly 300 settler activists who remained at the former settlement of Homesh following a March 26 march to the site had been evacuated by the IDF by mid-morning March 28. Dozens of settler activists burned tires and damaged IDF vehicles March 27 in an effort to resist evacuation from Homesh, which was evacuated during the August 2005 disengagement from Gaza and parts of the northern West Bank. Thousands of settlers supporting its re-establishment marched to Homesh March 26, and some 250-300 remained for two nights. Yisrael Medad, a resident of the settlement in Shilo, told poloff March 28 that efforts to continue occupying the site are continuing, with renewed calls for activists to continue coming to Homesh. Dror Etkes, settlement watch officer for the Israeli NGO Peace Now, told poloff March 27 that he doubts the settlers will be allowed to remain at Homesh, but that they succeeded in demonstrating "the unbelievable weakness of the Israeli government when it comes to settlements." ¶2. (C) Etkes opined that the primary purpose of the march was not to re-occupy the settlement, but rather to gain control of the debate on settlements. He said there is a generational rift between the older settlers who control the Yesha Council and the younger activists who grew up in settlement communities. He commented that the students occupying Homesh represent the next generation of settlement activists, who want to "kidnap headlines" and change the discussion from further disengagement to future settlement activity.  WALLES

9 DEC 2009

My JPost piece is quoted:

QSuspend Your Zionism Settler leader Yisrael Medad wrote in The Jerusalem Post (12/9):

QWhile I can comprehend Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's concern for what he considers more primary national interests than keeping his electoral platform promises to those who voted for him regarding the continuation of the Jewish return to the national homeland, his recent decisions are quite incomprehensible. To think that even the opposition leader, Kadima chairwoman Knesset Member Tzipi Livni, can justifiably criticize him from a right-wing perspective says much about Netanyahu's policies.... In essence, Netanyahu's government is inadequately dealing with the internal-social front, the economic front, and the diplomatic-security front. Our Prime Minister is asking us to suspend our Zionism, suspend our natural logic, and suspend our economic personal freedoms for quirky political behavior that will last 10 months -- after which all will revert to normal: normal growth, normal development, normal security. This is truly a matter of suspended belief.

13 AUG 2008

Migron settlers and key rabbis remain opposed
---------------------------------------------

¶5. (C) Dayan and Wallerstein confirmed that Migron settlers are opposed to the pending agreement. ""This is not an ideal compromise,"" Dayan said, and ""we're being attacked by the loyalists, extremists, and even some of our mainstream"" over the deal. Wallerstein told Poloff that several key settler rabbis, including Rabbi Dov Lior of Hebron and Rabbi Zalman Melamed of Beit El, oppose the agreement. Wallerstein said the entire Binyamin Regional Council that oversees Migron and the surrounding area opposes the agreement based on Migron residents' views. Settler Yisrael Medad told Poloff that Rabbi Zvi Yisrael Tau of Jerusalem, who taught many of the young Migron residents and is ""generally more moderate,"" may able to convince Migron settlers to agree to the deal. ¶6. (C) ""This is a very good deal,"" Wallerstein told Poloff, but ""after Gush Katif they don't believe the government will make good on its promises."" Ofra settler Aliza Herbst told Poloff that the Migron deal represents a ""crisis of confidence in Yesha leadership.""   ""Three or four years ago,"" she said, the settlers ""would have taken our word that this is a good thing, but now they don't trust even Yesha.""  WALLES




^

Friday, September 02, 2011

The Full Excerpt from Jabotinsky's "Samson" - The Three Things

I went searching on line but couldn't find the full quotation from Ze'ev Jabotinsky's biblically-themed novel, Samson relating to Samson's "farewell".

It wasn't here nor here.  Nor here.

Now, here it is, end of Chapter XXX, when Samson, now blinded and residing on the Gaza shore, takes his leave from Hermesh, a member of his Jackals who fought the Philistines.:

"Shall I give our people a message from you?"

Samson thought for a while and then said slowly:

"Tell them two things in my name—two words. The first word is Iron. They must get iron. They must give everything they have for iron—their silver and wheat, oil and wine and flocks, even their wives and daughters. All for iron! There is nothing in the world more valuable than iron.  Will you tell them that?"

"I will.  They will understand that."

"The second word they will not understand yet, but they must learn to understand it, and that soon. The second word is this: a king! Say to Dan, Benjamin, Judah, Ephraim: a king! A man will give them the signal and of a sudden thousands will lift up their hands. So it is with the Philistines, and therefore the Philistines are lords of Canaan. Say it from Zorah to Hebron and Shechem, and farther even to Endor and Laish: a king!"

"I will say it," said Hermesh.

"Go now," said Samson.

Hermesh took his had and kissed it, and while his lips were still on Samson's hand he asked in a tembling voice:

"But have you nothing to say to us, the friends who loved you - to us and our children?"

...He withdrew his hand and answered, as he turned away "Nothing."

Hermesh went back slowly across the sand, but suddenly Samson called him.  He looked round.  Samson was carefully wiping the back of his hand, and he said to him:

"I have changed my mind.  Tell them three things in my name, and not two: they must get iron; they must choose a king; and they must learn to laugh."


^

The Western Wall You Don't Usually See

From More than just bricks in a wall: What the entire Kotel looked like


Two thousand years after King Herod’s builders laid the foundations for the Kotel on the Temple Mount, Israeli archaeologists have reached these foundations. The Wall’s architectonic picture is nearly complete and will soon be unveiled publicly.

...These past few months have witnessed the completion of a historic work undertaken in the City of David: the uncovering of the lowest point of the Western Wall’s foundational structure. The discovery, which has been hidden deep underground for thousands of years, was made possible by the uncovering of a Herodian-era drainage canal by archaeologists. Now the Western Wall’s entire architectonic picture is nearly complete, and it will be unveiled publicly in the next few weeks...the digging crew, led by archaeologists Roni Reich (Haifa University) and Eli Shukron (the Israel Antiquities Authority), has reached these layers. In a few weeks, the public will likely have the chance to get a glimpse for itself.

...the four bottom layers that lie beneath the Western Wall. They measure 11 meters in width. Although they are nothing more than stones, the first-hand contact is indeed a jarring experience...Now the Western Wall architectonic picture is nearly complete: It stretches 488 meters in length...
...Four years and one High Court of Justice petition later, the archaeologists weathered the storms and uncovered the 600 meters, which, in their own unique way, tell the story of the destruction of the Second Temple and the great revolt against the Roman Empire. Archaeologists discovered five separate holes in the floor of the street that stretches above the drainage canal. Since they did not find any boulders that would account for the existence of these holes, they were left with the conclusion that they were caused as a result of deliberate action. Other artifacts, including cooking pots and coins that date back to the second, third, and fourth years of the revolt, hinted of a possible solution to the mystery: the drainage canal was apparently the last refuge for the remaining Jewish mutineers who went into hiding from Roman soldiers.

...Removing the dirt from the drainage canal was a grueling task that was aided by a group of young Jews made available to the archaeologists by the Ir David Foundation. Arab laborers, who were employed at the site in the past, refused to take part in the excavations this time because of threats to their lives.
...During the course of the excavation, the archaeologists were stunned to discover that the drainage canal had “disappeared.” The researchers happened upon the foundations of the Umayyad palace, which were exposed near the foot of the Wall facing the south. The foundations cut through the canal. “We looked for the rest of the canal, east, west,” said Shukron. “We didn’t give up, and finally we got around the palace’s foundations and reconnected with the rest of the canal and finished the dig.”

The general public will have to wait patiently. The canal and the Western Wall foundations are still not open to visitors, yet that will soon change once the proper safety equipment is installed on site.

Can you wait?

^






A Diplomat Looking for 1947-48 Documents

Here's Esther Herlitz's letter in Haaretz (Hebrew) from August 24:

שוב ושוב מתעוררת השאלה: ערביי פלסטינה (א"י) ברחו, או גורשו? הסיפור, חלקו, אולי כולו, מתועד.

כמזכירת המחלקה הערבית של הסוכנות נפל בחלקי בכל בוקר לרשום בעברית ולהפיץ את מה שאנשי ה"ש"י" (שירות הידיעות של ההגנה) אז קלטו בערבית, בהאזנה לשיחות הטלפון של המופתי.

במו אוזני שמעתי את המופתי מייעץ לאוכלוסייה הערבית לקום ולברוח, שהרי ממילא בתוך זמן קצר יחזרו לבתיהם. חאג' אמין, המופתי, גם הוסיף כי סתימת הכבישים הראשיים בהמוני "בורחים" תחסום את המעבר בפני הכוחות היהודיים.

כל זה קרה בתקופה שבין החלטת האו"ם להכרזת העצמאות. האם שמרו בארכיון המדינה את התרשומת היומית המעניינת הזאת?

זאת ועוד, כידוע, אבא חושי, ראש העיר חיפה, הפיץ כרוז לערביי העיר בשפתם וקרא להם להישאר. רבים לא שעו לקריאתו ועשו את דרכם ללבנון. הכרוז הזה קיים בלי ספק בארכיון עיריית חיפה.

לא ידוע לי אם מפקדי כיבוש לוד ורמלה כתבו יומן מלחמה שנשמר. מותר לומר על הפליטים מהערים האלה, שהם גורשו.

אסתר הרליץ
תל אביב

Translation:

Again and again, the question arises: the Arabs of 'Palestina' (Eretz-Yisrael) fled or were they expelled? The story, partially and perhaps all, is documented.



As the Secretary of the Arab Department of the Jewish Agency, it was my job every morning to record in Hebrew and distribute what the Haganah's intelligence service, Shai, had taken down in Arabic, listening in to the telephone conversations of the Mufti.


I heard the Mufti advise the Arab population to rise and run, especially as they would in any case soon return to their homes. Haj Amin, the Mufti, also added that the blocking of highways by multitudes of those "fleeing" would then block the passage of the Jewish forces.


This all happened in the period between UN Partition Decision and Israel's Declaration of Independence. Would the state archives still possess these daily interesting protocols?


Moreover, as we know, Abba Hushi, the mayor of Haifa, issued a proclamation to the Arabs in their own language and called on them to stay. Many did not heed his call and made ​​their way to Lebanon. This leaflet is without doubt in the Haifa municipal archives.


I do not know if the commanders who conquered Lydda and Ramleh preserved a battle log. It may inform us about the refugees of whom we can say were deported.


Esther Herlitz
Tel Aviv

Esther was a diplomat, becoming an Ambassador and was a Labour MK.

Well, where are those documents?

^

Now It's The Fiddler Question - ASHamed Jews at Work

The following letter was published in the 30 August 2011 edition of The Independent, a major UK national daily newspaper:

Proms exploited for arts propaganda campaign

As musicians we are dismayed that the BBC has invited the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra to play at the Proms on 1 September. The IPO has a deep involvement with the Israeli state – not least its self-proclaimed “partnership” with the Israeli Defence Forces. This is the same state and army that impedes in every way it can the development of Palestinian culture, including the prevention of Palestinian musicians from travelling abroad to perform.

Our main concern is that Israel deliberately uses the arts as propaganda to promote a misleading image of Israel. Through this campaign, officially called “Brand Israel”, denials of human rights and violations of international law are hidden behind a cultural smokescreen. The IPO is perhaps Israel’s prime asset in this campaign.

The Director of the Proms, Roger Wright, was asked to cancel the concert in accordance with the call from the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott (PACBI). He rejected this call, saying that the invitation is “purely musical”.

Israel’s policy towards the Palestinians fits the UN definition of apartheid. We call on the BBC to cancel this concert.

(k/t = DaphneAnson)

Seems there may have been some slight contretemps.  And they went choral, too.  And there's this piece.

All in all, from the signatories above, seems Jacobson's ASHamed Jews are still at work - an excerpt from The Finkler Question:

Born a Jew on Monday, he had signed up to be an ASHamed Jew by Wednesday and was seen chanting, 'We are all Hezbollah' outside the Israeli embassy on the following Saturday."...Every other Wednesday, except for festivals and High Holy-days, an anti-Zionist group called ASHamed Jews meets in an upstairs room in the Groucho Club in Soho to dissociate itself from Israel, urge the boycotting of Israeli goods, and otherwise demonstrate a humanity in which they consider Jews who are not ASHamed to be deficient. ASHamed Jews came about as a consequence of the famous Jewish media philosopher Sam Finkler’s avowal of his own shame on Desert Island Discs. “My Jewishness has always been a source of pride and solace to me,” he told Radio Four’s listeners, not quite candidly, “but in the matter of the dispossession of the Palestinians I am, as a Jew, profoundly ashamed.” “Profoundly self-regarding,” you mean, was his wife’s response. But then she wasn’t Jewish and so couldn’t understand just how ashamed in his Jewishness an ashamed Jew could be.

And he explained:

That I know of, there is no Jewish media philosopher named Sam Finkler nor any anti-Zionist group meeting regularly at the Groucho Club. They exist only in the pages of my new novel, The Finkler Question, and any relation between them and real people or organisations is of course coincidental.  Though the ASHamed Jews are a satiric invention, my novel is not primarily a satire...For many Jews and non-Jews in this country Israel has become a figure of speech, the occasion for wild and whirling words, a pretext for bottling up or setting loose emotions which originate somewhere else entirely.

I began writing the The Finkler Question in 2008 but it came to the boil for me in the early months of 2009 at the time of Operation Cast Lead, as a consequence of which, or as a consequence of the reporting of which – for it, too, like everything else to do with Israel outside Israel, was figmentary – England turned into an uncustomarily frightening place for Jews. I am not speaking only of the physical threats and even damage that some Jews endured, attacks on persons, synagogues, cemeteries, the Jew-hatred expressed by primary school children etc, but of that anti-Zionist rhetoric which, in its inflatedness and fervour – a rhapsodic hyperbole growing more and more detached from any conceivable reality – was so upsetting in itself. You do not have to be punched in the face to feel you’ve been assaulted: intellectual violence is its own affront.

And let's present more satire:

Why I’m an ashamed Jew -

Yep, you read right.
I’ve had to admit it.
I can’t live a lie any longer.
I’m deeply, deeply ashamed.

Ashamed of being Jewish?

No way. I’m very proud to be Jewish and a member of the Jewish people.

Ashamed of Israel? Wrong again. I’m proud of Israel’s achievements. I worry about its policies, sometimes; I’m concerned, sometimes, about some of its actions and those of some of its citizens, but I could say the same for Britain and I’m still proud to be British.

So why am I ashamed?

I’ll tell you.

I’m ashamed of Jews who say they are ashamed to be Jews or Jewish.
I don’t hear Palestinians coming out to declare they are ashamed to be Palestinian and denounce suicide bombs or missiles.
I don’t hear Arabs writing they are ashamed to be Arabs because of Al Qaeda or Sudan or Yemen.
I don’t hear Muslims forming groups of shame because of what Sunni does to Shia, or 9/11, or 7/7, or Madrid, or Mumbai.
I don’t know of any Ashamed Catholic groups forming because of the paedophilia apparently rife in Catholic clergy.

In fact I know of no other group of people who so often announce their ashamedness to be who they are as Jews do.

And you know what?

It makes me ashamed.

I’m an ashamed Jew who is ashamed of ashamed Jews. If that’s a paradox, so be it. And I’m not ashamed to declare my shame...


Are we the only people on earth to suffer so from our own?

^




My Akeidah Post is Up at Sh'ma

Here.

There'll be a second one is two weeks.

^

Construction; Moratorium; Construction; Statistics

I blogged this past week on our construction activity.

Take into consideration this:-

The CBS data continues to run counter to speculation by the media and left-wing activists that there would be a boom in new Jewish West Bank construction in the aftermath of the 10-month moratorium on such activity that ended on September 26, 2010.

Due to the moratorium, it is difficult to compare activity from 2011 and 2010.

But the 281 housing starts in the second quarter of 2011 represent a 42 percent drop from the last quarter of 2010, which is the only complete quarter in that year in which new settlement construction took place without any moratorium restrictions.

That is almost the same as the 285 housing starts in the first quarter of 2011.

The total of 566 settler housing starts in the first half of 2011 represents a 16% drop when compared to the 713 starts in the same period in 2009, a 44% decrease when compared with the 1,015 starts in 2008 and a 21% drop when compared with the 713 starts in the first half of 2007.

Come back in another few months.

^

More Missionary Activity

I was in Tel Aviv yesterday (and how I got there is another story*) and two observations.

One is this pamphelt that I took, if only to make sure that it would go directly to genizah:


It's the latest issue of The Watchtower in Hebrew. Seems the Jehovah's Witnesses are active in the first Hebrew city. POB 29345 Tel Aviv 61293.  You'll notice I altered a bit the name of God, as the Tetragrammaton there.

Note:

Rutherford in his book 'Enemies' writes about Jews “ultra-selfish men called 'Jews' who look only for personal gain.”(19)

In the same book he writes that the Jews “practice religion, of which the Devil is the author.”(20) In another book he again writes about the Jews: “Be it known once and for all that those profiteering, conscienceless, selfish men who call themselves Jews, and who control the greater portion of the finances of the world and the business of the world...”(21)

Speaking at 'Bible Students'(22) convention in Winnipeg, Manitoba in the early 1920’s, Rutherford described a Jew as “the hooked-nosed, stooped-shouldered little individual who stands on the street corner trying to gyp you out of every nickel you’ve got.”(23) We see here clear examples of vulgar and primitive anti-Semitism. In yet another book he wrote that Jews lost favor with God when they murdered Jesus.(24)

Why is it so important for people like these to go out there and convert?

The second was the bike lanes on the sidewalks:


They take up as much room, almost, as the pedestrian walking space and - I noticed - many bikers ride on the sidewalks outside the bike lane area and that included motorized bicycles.

What a city.

_____________

*

I left Shiloh at 6:40 AM via a tremp for a 9:30 Tel Aviv appointment but when I got out of the car at Ariel, I discovered that, having changed pants twice this week for a wedding and a Bar Mitzvah, I had left my wallet at home so, I turned around and presumed that I'd have to cancel and from Shiloh continue to Jerusalem.  I returned home by 8 and with the encouragement from my wife, went back down the hill and sure enough, 5 minutes latyer was on another tremp which brought me by 9:15 to the Azrielly Buildings which are a 20 minute walk from the Tel Aviv Municipality where I had my meeting.  Wonder of wonders.

^

Joseph Dana Is Not Wanted

So you know to stay away:



^

Who Is The Great Uniter on Israel?

Barack Obama.



^

The Anti-Light Rail Poster

The Hareidi response to the Light Rail is itt's too much immodesty all those people of both sexes packed too closely one to another:-


But that's a situation due to the free rides.

In another few days, it'll be like the buses.

Buses?

^

Thursday, September 01, 2011

What Do You Know About the Druze in Lebanon?

From the Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies (2009), Issue 03, 72: 459-487 

Between authenticity and alienation: The Druzes and Lebanon's history
by Yusri Hazrana1, Harvard University

Abstract

Almost ninety years have passed since the establishment of the Lebanese state, but it still lacks a consensual and unifying historical narrative. The Druzes of Lebanon, who claim to be the real founders of the historical Lebanese entity, reject the Lebanese historiography elaborated by Christian historians as ideologically motivated, sectarian and fabricated. Furthermore, they claim that their contribution to Lebanon's history has been systematically minimized.

The Druze leader, Kamāl Junblāṭ, was the first to raise public awareness of the importance of rewriting Lebanon's history, and the process of doing so has gained momentum among Druze intellectuals since the 1980s. This article discusses the efforts of the Druze intelligentsia to cultivate a historical narrative that presents an alternative to what they call the “Maronite narrative”; it focuses predominantly on the Emirate's history during the Middle Ages and the reciprocal relations between the Druze political experience within modern Lebanon and the intellectual formulation of their narrative.

Very interesting.

^

The Improving Demographics of YESHA


Another demographic look at the population of Yesha, this time the school pupils.

Today, over 130,000 schoolchildren went to school today in Yesha, the first day of the new school year 5772, 2011-2012.

That includes kindergartens, primary schools, middle schools, high schools.

In the primary schools, there are more than 51,000 pupils, up from 46,000 last year.

The numbers of those entering the first grade is 7,500, which represents a 9% increase, 600 more than last year's figure.

This year, more the 50 new kindergartens and nurseries were opned than existed last year.

All this, of course, indicates a steady and constant growth of the Jewish population in Judea and Samaria.


(thanks to Yigal Dilmoni of the YESHA Council)

^

"Pro-Palestine Products"

Have you read this analysis of the "success" of the BDS movement?

In any case, I found a related item from the 1948 Register of Israel on "pro-Palestine products":-


Jewish, of course.

And very pro-Israel.

^

Israelite Expansion

Are you near Stanford?

Well, you can learn about King Solomon is what is today South Jordan:

"Mining for Solomon"

Tuesday, September 6, 4:00 pm, 254 Barrows

Prof. Steven Weitzman, Stanford University

After a century-long search for traces of the historical King Solomon, archaeologists have recently claimed to locatethe possible source of his fabled wealth in southern Jordan. Has scholarship at last found evidence of the real King Solomon? Weitzman's presentation will address this question by exploring the pre-history of the archaeological quest for Solomon, a quest with surprisingly important historical consequences that go beyond our understanding of the biblical past.

Next he'll be claiming a Biblical right.

^

New Media Comment Column Up

Over at the Jerusalem Post: Hebrew Now.

^