Sunday, October 29, 2023

Was 'Palestine' Actually Syria?

Let's check on that way back when:

"In 1917, Ramallah-born New York surgeon, Fuad Isa Shatara, and N.A. Katibah founded the Palestine Antizionism Society. It was among the organizers of an anti-Zionist rally on November 8, 1918 in Brooklyn. Besides the two founders, the young Lebanese Orientalist Philip Khoury Hitti made an appearance as a speaker at the event. The rally passed a resolution, describing the Arabs at risk of being dominated by “a race rendered more powerful and wealthy through contact with the western civilization thus applying might against right” and protesting the “artificial importation of Zionists flooding the country against its natural capacities and thus forcing an emigration of the rightful inhabitants.”227 Thus, by 1918, the anti-Zionist Arab-American movement had already found both its central arguments and its leaders. Rihani, Hitti and Shatara would shape the movement over the next two decades. The Arab Americans worked to influence the State  Department and other influential elements of the foreign policy strata. Fuad Shatara of the Palestine Antizionism Society wrote two letters to Secretary of State Robert Lansing in November 1918 and February 1919, arguing that Zionism was in contravention to Wilson’s Fourteen Points.228 In December 1918, Hitti and George Khairalla established the New Syria National League. The group lobbied for the establishment of a Greater Syria under American protection, reaching from the Sinai to the Euphrates.229 These groups intensified their activities in light of the upcoming peace conference in Paris. Shatara and Hitti reached out to John Huston Finley, the chief of the Red Cross Commission in Palestine, asking Finley not to detach Palestine from Greater Syria.230 During the conference, Hitti’s New Syria National League also sent a telegram to Wilson, Lloyd George and Clemenceau advocating an American protectorate over Syria. 231"          

227 “Untitled,” New York Times, November 9, 1917; cited in Davidson, “Debating Palestine,” 230; see also Knee, “The King-Crane Commission of 1919,” 204. 228 Davidson, “Debating Palestine,” 231. 229 The Formation of Modern Iraq and Syria (Routledge, 2013), 147. 230 Knee, The Concept of Zionist Dissent in the American Mind, 1917-1941, 205. 231 The Formation of Modern Iraq and Syria, 147.

From this thesis.

^

4 comments:

Anonymous said...


Amanpour selecting interviewees and desperately begging: please say "genocide" (On civilians uses by 'Palestinian' regime as shields)


Nov 23, 2023

Longtime anti-Israel activist Christiane Amanpour, as part of demonizing Israel has also an obsession with semantics.

At the time of protests against Judicial reform, Amanpour pressed at least one Israeli interviewee to use the T word - 'totalitarian,' in case reform goes through. But to her disappointment, it did not.

Now, after Oct 7 atrocities by the Gaza fascist genocidal regime, who foresaw Israeli response and have always been using non -combatants to make sure they die, Ananpour knows all that, but her israelophobia virus has a particular obsession with name calling on the victim and only democratic entity in the region. The G word, bit, she is so desperate about that.

So first she had Mr. Bartov on, and she tried to extract from him her desired slur, struggling, she kept pushing like, "when is going to be the line.. crossed" so it can finally--to her joy-- be called that. But the real gist of lefty Bartov was that he is against certain people in the coalition and as soon as they are out. All is fine.

Of the "amazing" points was, deeming "ethnic cleansing" on evacuating people so they're not killed. What would anyone terming this as such, really prefer for those people to stay?

But Amanpour didn't give up, after Antonio Guterres was slammed for a lying post [https://twitter.com/maor_x/status/1726895291478245473] [https://twitter.com/HenMazzig/status/1726653958431916079] [https://twitter.com/KseniaSvetlova/status/1726705819671224809] about "unprecedented" she found UN's Griffiths still recycling Guterres pseudo line. She was so enthusiastic to post it on X.

Anonymous said...

Racist Refaat Alareer: "Hitler peacemaker like Rabin" (9/25/20); "can't tell my child who created the J-s" (2006); "most J-s are evil" (11/16/12); joking re baby in oven Oct 7 2023 [by Palestinian led atrocities] - "with/without baking powder?" (10/29/23)

Anonymous said...

Re Pan Arabism, Palestine part of Syria...

MORE ABOUT FUAD SHATARA

"Shatara scurried around, speaking before pro-Nazi organizations in the U. S."1

The infamous Nazi propaganda, Welt-Dienst - "The World Service", in March, 1938 2 promoted his NAL National Arab League as well as the Bund Nazi groups in the US3

The NAL which he headed and Habeeb Katibeh as manager, who, later changed the name into "Institute of Arab American Affairs".

Just after the 1941 Rashid Ali oro Nazi coup he tried to excuse him and suggested, it was part of "Arab program for the complete independence of all Arab States and the creation of a United States of Arabia."4


Anonymous said...

ARABIANAZIS

In May 1947, Walter Winchell wrote a lengthy piece
Daytona Beach Morning Journal, May 19, 1947, p. 2 about Arab Mazi links, including the Mufti Amin al-Husseini, Emil Ghouri (Ghuri), Wasef Kamal, Ahmed Hussein (Young Egypt) Fadhel al Jamali, Farrid Zein Eddin, Fuad Shatara (former president of the National Arab League, committeed suicide in Jan 1942), Habib Ibrahim Katibah (who worked with Shatara and continued org.).

Habib I. Katibah [Katibeh] filed a libel law suit but the judge dismissed his case and rather rebuked Katibah.

Friends Of Democracy's Battle. (1948). Vol. VI, No. 15. August 1, 1948.

NY Court Blasts Arab Apologist Katibah, Grand Mufti Linked With Nazis; Justice Charges Latter 'kindled Flames Of Pogrom'

On May 5, 1948, Hon. Maurice Simmons, Justice of the Court of Special Sessions (New York), dismissed a complaint for criminal libel made by Habib I. Katibah against the publisher of the New York Daily Mirror....

From his lengthy spech:

"The columnist's attack was levelled at a system, an ideology, the Arab world itself. Not the private lives of the individuals..."


Herald-Journal, May 13, 1948

Judge Dismisses Libel Action Against Winchell.
From the Associated Press May 5th. "Special Sessions Justice M. Simmons, in dismissing a complaint of criminal libel against the Daily Mirror the Hearst Corporation and said: 'The remarks in Winchell's column about him (H. I. Katibah) are a very feeble understatement and characterization'."

Memo from Girl Friday:
"The judge delivered a lengthy oral opinion in which he said you and the Daily Mirror 'had made, a great contribution to the public welfare in printing the Meet the Arabianazis column'."